Open 577: Hope Plus One! (GAME OVER - SCUM WIN)

[mastin2]

Mastin, are you town?

In fact I am.

You, however, are

not

.

[mastin2]

I can't imagine mastintown going along with this.

If I was scum, you'd be dead. You have been, and always will be, my preferred nightkill.

In fact, you living this far is actually a bit of an alarm bell.

[mastin2]

That was a pretty quick flip-flop.

Indeed. Thus, scum.

[GGG]

I'm going Mastin, DGB. Especially the whole if you weren't scum and I was you'd be dead.

My play this game has been erratic, unsure, flip floppy, non committal etc. which is nothing like my scum games where I have strong reads and in control of the narrative. Basically I'm town because I suck at being town

[mastin2]

GGG for sure. DGB, I kinda am/was due to yesterDay's shenanigans... but maybe she really is just that bad?
I can't picture them being scum together unless GGG knew I'd get paranoid and unvote.

I do agree on GGG being really,

really

obviously scum, here, but DGB is

NOT

"that bad". She's one of the best players on the site as both alignments as far as I'm concerned. So if she seems "that bad", scum.

I think GGG was just bussing.

[GGG]

GGG for sure. DGB, I kinda am/was due to yesterDay's shenanigans... but maybe she really is just that bad?
I can't picture them being scum together unless GGG knew I'd get paranoid and unvote.

I do agree on GGG being really,

really

obviously scum, here, but DGB is

NOT

"that bad". She's one of the best players on the site as both alignments as far as I'm concerned. So if she seems "that bad", scum.

I think GGG was just bussing.

Bussing makes no sense there though, it was still early and build a C/A scum case would have been much less dangerous. Kind of like your doing on me instead of bussing DGB.

[Cane + Able]

I'm going Mastin, DGB. Especially the whole if you weren't scum and I was you'd be dead.

My play this game has been erratic, unsure, flip floppy, non committal etc. which is nothing like my scum games where I have strong reads and in control of the narrative. Basically I'm town because I suck at being town

As it stands, you're my lynch du jour, because you are objectively scummy whereas my read of DGB relies on an association which may or may not exist and another possible association which conflicts with today's votes.

You say you're town. Give me a better candidate with solid reasoning that I can follow.

For your case(s), try not to rely too much on D3 because that shit was all sideways for err'body due to copper's gambit.

[Cane + Able]

I think GGG was just bussing.

Explain in what world that would make sense in the opening hours of MyLo.

[texcat]

Bussing makes no sense there though, it was still early and build a C/A scum case would have been much less dangerous. Kind of like your doing on me instead of bussing DGB.

Wasn't this the same argument that copper used? Nothing scum has done this game has made any sense.

[mastin2]

Bussing makes no sense there though, it was still early and build a C/A scum case would have been much less dangerous. Kind of like your doing on me instead of bussing DGB.

Okay. With C/A and myself both as town, let's run through it. C/A votes for DGB. I immediately take C/A's side, call them obvtown, and DGB scum.

Assuming you're scum. What do you go for? Calling us a scumteam and defending your scumbuddy, creating a VERY dangerous 2v2 which if you lose, condemns you in lylo...

...Or bus your buddy?

I dunno about you, but for me, you'd have to be really, really insane to do anything but the latter. You defended DGB initially. Then you saw the tides turn against her. Thus, you started attacking her, in a throwing save to attempt a recovery from the disastrous lylo beginning. You'd have no way of anticipating things would go badly, but once they did, you'd go into damage control mode, to minimize the harm.

Thus, bussing.

This makes a whole heck of a lot more sense than you and C/A (who I think is town anyway, but let's just go with hypotheticals) voting DGB as a scumteam, and a whole HECK of a lot more sense than you being town doing what you've done.

Besides. You've done incredibly-scummy stuff. Texctcat's done some fairly town-looking stuff. C/A is ridiculously obvtown, and becoming moreso the more he posts. And DGB? DGB's got some crazy associatives pointing her way, little things that have added up. Even individually, you'd be the most scummy players in the game. Given the condemning interactions you have, and it's all-but assured. Only reason I'm not voting right now is to be absolutely certain by looking at things in more detail than I have.

[Cane + Able]

What else other than tunnelling Arcy yesterday makes DGB scummy

vote:dgb

What was said between these two posts that made you decide to vote DGB?

[Cane + Able]

Scumreads as I understand them:

C&A:

DGB

,

GGG

(

mastin2

possibility)
GGG:

mastin2

,

DGB

texcat:

mastin2

,

GGG

(

C&A

possibility)
mastin2:

DGB

,

GGG

DGB:

C&A

3 scumreads on DGB.
3 scumreads on GGG.
2.5 scumreads on mastina.
1.5 scumreads on C&A.
0 scumreads on texcat.

I'm feeling pretty good about voting either of DGB/GGG. There be scum in those two. That said, I'd have doubts about my scumread on GGG with a DGB scum flip, because I

don't

share mastin's opinion that he's bussing.

[Cane + Able]

Scum has had ample time to quickhammer me. So I'm certain that DGB should be today's lynch.

VOTE: DGB

[GGG]

What else other than tunnelling Arcy yesterday makes DGB scummy

vote:dgb

What was said between these two posts that made you decide to vote DGB?

You guys voted eachother.

At that point it's pick between the two people because as soon as designated vote time comes in the game ends. And as much as I dislike your playstyle you are less scummy than dgb

[Cane + Able]

Considering mastin2 is scumreading DGB, it should be interesting to see whether she hammers her.

She's kinda painted herself into that corner, now.

[DrippingGoofball]

I can't imagine mastintown going along with this.

If I was scum, you'd be dead. You have been, and always will be, my preferred nightkill.

In fact, you living this far is actually a bit of an alarm bell.

Why would you NK me, seeing that I pushed a mislynch really hard?

You could NK someone else and do exactly what you are doing now!

[DrippingGoofball]

Scum has had ample time to quickhammer me.

And didn't? Are you confessing scum?

[DrippingGoofball]

Hmmm and I'm looking at Mastin, C+A, and GGG all scum reading DGB. And I know that at least one of those 3 has to be scum.

You're right, and it's GGG.

I've been telling everybody why the entire game.

Could you be right?

[DrippingGoofball]

Mmmm Caneable sounding town in 2622.

[DrippingGoofball]

VOTE: mastin2

For being scummily disingenuous.

[texcat]

I'm just lurking here. I want to see if Mastin wants to hammer before I do anything.

[DrippingGoofball]

I am town and mastin is scum, of course she'll want to hammer.

[theelkspeaks]

Vote Count 5.2
With 5 Alive, it is 3 to lynch.

mastin2 (1)

- Dripping Goofball

Dripping Goofball(2)

- GGG, Cane + Able

Not Voting (2)

- texcat, mastin2

[mastin2]

In fact I do want to hammer. DGB's all-but confscum right now.
VOTE: DrippingGoofBall.

[Cane + Able]

God, I've been sweating bullets waiting for you to get back before somebody unvoted.