Open 529 -- Picking Simplicity -- Game Over

[penguin_alien]

24 hours minimum, 48 hours maximum.

[JacobSavage]

You have no idea why I might think Maenara griping about the 3p LyLo composition is shady?

I was more asking why asking when did you become confirmed town.

Pwrsonally i think its more likely that you are town that Maerna bur I wouldnt say 100%

[penguin_alien]

Maenara, I'm thinking I just might have an answer for you in significantly less than 24 hours...

[penguin_alien]

I'm cop

ah, I already have. Ok so first of all I am cop.

But ... I didn't check wake. I checked someone else and I got a not guilty, I don't think I should divulge the identity of said person atm.

First of all I'm the

cop

Rainbow and Sven aren't guilty.

People need to get in here and vote for someone other than RD, Sven and don

...I am so incredibly torn between whether Antihero went on holiday in the scum QT and JS forgot who I replaced or whether Maenara wanted me around to fuck up LyLo.

[penguin_alien]

Living players with my reads at this point (breaking this up so as not to piss everyone off):

aptil
ArcAngel9

don_johnson

JacobSavage
jmo16mla

penguin_alien

Maenara
Antihero

Titus

That leaves three anti-town in aptil, AA9, JS, jmo, Titus.

I'd put aptil in there based on everything. jmo, likely given his sidelines feel. Not JS. Titus-AA9, not sure; Brian Skies was weird with BoroPhil, but I need to look at AA9's entrance more carefully. Titus pings a bit.

...In trying to remember what I was thinking a month ago, if I came in and strong-read all three remaining anti-town players, I will be so incredibly sad. Although my reads are demonstrably shit anyways this game, as I had JS as least likely scum in that group.

Looking over Titus and AA9 now.

[penguin_alien]

So Titus and AA9 were both reading Maenara as town and JS as scummy (and Antihero as scummy in the former's case, which dilutes it a bit)

At this stage, I see no reason why Maenara would make 3p LyLo harder for herself by limiting herself to one pretend scum suspect and eliminating someone who was town reading her and unlikely to fluctuate. As far as my crap reads go, I'd like to think that DJ as third party had reason to be making me think he was town, and Antihero had less content to consider than Maenara.

If Maenara's scum, she's played a hell of a game.

JS, you have one post to convince me of Maenara-scum.

[Maenara]

That was less than 24 hours, yes.

[JacobSavage]

Can't I have more than one? You work me too hard.

Leaving you lead actually helps her a lot more. AA9, at least in my experience is known to be erratic so can be quite a danger if left in lylo, the avoidence of voting Antihero despite pretty much deciding that it was between AA/Anti or me/Anti. The obvious thing to do there was to vote anti-hero then vote between one of us tommorrow.

The Maerna /Anti interaction gives the most away I feel.

[penguin_alien]

What is given away therein?

[JacobSavage]

This is going to sound like a cop out, but just look at their ISO's

Particually around #2257 I reads basically as Mae screaming at her partner to do something but at the same time not wanting to put any major pressure on him, literally she doesn't vote him in the first 200 posts (Internet died trying to go to the page) yet she constantly has him as a suspect (Quite strongly actually)

[JacobSavage]

VOTE: Maerna

[Nobody Special]

Votecount 8.01

JacobSavage - 1 - Maenara
Maenara - 1 - JacobSavage

Not Voting: penguin_alien

With 3 alive, it takes 2 to lynch.

Deadline: (expired on 2014-01-16 22:22:27)

[Maenara]

Didn't get around to wrapping up this thing before we wrapped up 2013. Eh.

And what you're trying to get at, JS, is absolute bull. It's not even funny; I was scum with you like a month ago, and this is exactly the kind of thing you were talking about in our quicktopic. Yes, I had Antihero as a suspect and didn't vote for him, big bloody surprise. When exactly are you trying to get at? You mention both "the first 200 posts" and the last day here, which are vastly different scenarios. For the longest time, I didn't vote for him because, guess what,

there were better suspects with better traction

. I'm not sure if you noticed, but half this bloody game has been spent going "Hey, guys? Could we maybe, like, vote for someone? Like, the

same

person, maybe?" and being screwed up by whacky cop gambits. And as for the late game, what did you honestly think I was going to do? Let you - or AA9, there frankly wasn't much difference in your behaviour - cruise by while Penguin and I brought AA to L-1? Hell, he could've self-hammered, and we'd be none the wiser as to the two of you. In case you didn't think this through, the expected situation for today would be you, AA9 and me as the leftovers, with the confTown being dead, and yeah, big surprise, I wanted to gather information before that happened. The alternative situation would have been voting for you because "Well, Brian Skies played pretty well", and yeah, it turns out that would've been the right choice, but it's kind of an atrocious thing to base a LyLo vote upon.

So yeah. I didn't vote Antihero. You're absolutely right.

What's your excuse for this game?

- 2014 out.

[Maenara]

...

Apologies for lack of breaks in paragraph.

Another night, perhaps.

- 2014 out. Again.

[penguin_alien]

OK, it's been 48 hours since I screwed up a game and let down my team in the end, so I'm ready to go for it here.

Don't know where you are Maenara, but I can still end this in 2013.

Also don't know given my crap reads this game, but I just can't see Maenara scum and JS town. If nothing else, town-JS should have voted Maenara as soon as he knew I wasn't scum, which from town-him's perspective would have been as soon as I didn't quick-hammer him after Maenara's vote. Not three days later as an afterthought.

Maenara, if you're scum, a hearty well-played to you.

VOTE: JacobSavage

[Maenara]

so unimpressed

but so in awe

♪ ♫ ♪

such a saint

but such a whore

♪ ♫ ♪

so self-aware

so full of shit

♪ ♫ ♪

so indecisive

so adamant

...

I'm contemplating thinking about thinking

it's overrated

just get another drink in

Watch me come undone,

They're selling razor-blades and mirrors in the street

(Come Undone)

I pray, that when I'm coming down, you'll be asleep

(Come Undone)

If I ever hurt you, your revenge would be so sweet

Because

I'm scum!

And... I'm your... son?



I come undone.

[penguin_alien]

Damn it, well-played.

[Maenara]

I've been waiting

so

long to post that song.

Thanks for saving my New Years.

[Maenara]

Seriously, though, this

is

why we need to lynch lurkers. It was incredibly frustrating to play against as scum, true, but it was also our ticket to victory.

[Nobody Special]

Votecount 8.02

JacobSavage - 2 - Maenara, penguin_alien

Maenara - 1 - JacobSavage

Not Voting: ...

With 3 alive, it takes 2 to lynch.

Deadline: (expired on 2014-01-16 22:22:27)

[Nobody Special]

JacobSavage, Vanilla Townie,

has been lynched.

THE MAFIA HAVE WON THE GAME !!!

Spoiler: Night Actions

Night One Actions:

Mafia kills: Skelda
Serial Killer (don_johnson) kills: mastin2
Town Cop (Loranthaceae) investigates: Rainbowdash RESULT: Not Guilty
Town Doc (Skullduggery) protects: Evil Regals


Night Two Actions:

Mafia kills: Evil Regals
Serial Killer (don_johnson) kills: Wake88
Town Cop (Loranthaceae) investigates: RachMarie RESULT: Guilty
Town Doc (Skullduggery) protects: Maenara


Night Three Actions:

Mafia kills: Skullduggery
Serial Killer (don_johnson) kills: Skullduggery
Town Cop (Loranthaceae) investigates: Svenskt Stål RESULT: Not Guilty
Town Doc (Skullduggery) protects: Loranthaceae


Night Four Actions:

Mafia kills: Loranthaceae
Serial Killer (don_johnson) kills: Rainbowdash
Town Cop (Loranthaceae) investigates: JacobSavage RESULT: Dead (Not Guilty)


Night Five Actions:

Mafia kills: Titus
Serial Killer (don_johnson) kills: Titus


Night Six Actions:

Mafia kills: aptil


Night Seven Actions:

Mafia kills: ArcAngel9

MafQT --> http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/KuaAeFhD2JV

Dead thread --> http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/RLSNk5uN2QG

[Skullduggery]

Not even upset. Maenara played like a champ.

[JacobSavage]

Damn it

[Maenara]

Oh gods, our night actions were terrible, and I had absolutely no reads.

This is why I like to play Mafia; if I'd been Town, I'd've been so dead. Much easier to scumhunt when you already know who you want to target ^_^

[Wake1]

I enjoyed Maenara's performance.