I have not yet seen any good reason for the votes on me, other than my attacking the "playstyle" of mariyta, or that I haven't claimed. I now claimed, as I'm at -2. I don't think I've really played with mariyta before, so I, at that point, didn't know how her playstyle was. I was attacking her because I thought she wasn't contributing and she seemed scummy to me.
Nightfall
has not been playing as well as I think he usually does. He's been immune the 'whole' game, and he hasn't been
too
clear on where he stands, or at least, why he stands where he does. He seems to be wavering between me and mari, but I don't see much from his reasons on mari other than "she seems to be pretty confrontational when it comes to the chances that she might be scum."
Ibby
should probably be replaced. She's not posted for a month, and we know it's not her fault, but I think a month is too much for a fairly active mini like this one. She had some beginning suspicions on zodiac, but the only reasons known were essentially lost in the crash.
Milkman
seems kinda scummy. He asked about zodiac's posts, and when no one was able to answer his question, and even got confused about what he was asking, he basically answered the question for himself.
milkman wrote:<snip>
Ok, I'm not sure where I said Zodiac was scummy. I don't see much wrong with zodiac's posting, just that his style is really lazy. I know one of his pre-crash posts was something along the lines of:
Post 44,ibaesha wrote:]I find his vote on Mari ironic/hypocritical since
he voted someone before for voting without a reason and said votes of that nature are always scummy (obviously this was deleted, but I didn't forget).
Otherwise it's just OMGUS, which isn't inherently scummy, but it isn't exactly productive either
A post like that doesn't seem all that scummy. If his other post was really scummy then I want to know why. Really I just want the information I missed.
Mod you missed my vote, but that's ok because
unvote
.
After that there was some discussion of what we should do at final 3, which I don't think was ever resolved, and then a bit of suspicion on me, and the zodiac voters.
Sherlock
has posted almost nothing this game, so I can't say anything.
ThAdmiral
seems ok. After zodiac/milkman's discussion, he said "It seems to me to be an obvious misunderstanding, and we've devoted a whole page to it!" He's opposed to mariyta, but that's about all I can get. " don't like how mariyta seems to have taken for granted both that fact klebian is scum, and that we should trust that she is town." Not much more from him so far.
Nightson
is a bit scummy. He's been switching from one person to another, and has not told at all why he doesn't want mari lynched, and he's been pretty sure about that (for that matter, raj hasn't either, and he's been pro-mari the whole game).
Nightson wrote:klebian wrote:what? And is mariyta perfectly fine to you?
Perfectly fine? No, but of the three left I think she's the least scummy.
Well, there were 2 or 3 posts earlier that had no suspicion on mari at all. He switched from zodiac to me to zodiac and then finally back to me in suspicions. His initial vote on me was because there was no point in voting zodiac (zodiac was guaranteed not to have immunity), but said he would support getting behind someone and being sure of lynching them before we reached the final 3. He later said he decided he would stick with a vote on me, but this oculd be trying to make up for earlier posts.
Thoughts on inhim/ctd later.
Edit at seeing nightfall's latest post. Is my role considered 'power' then? I don't really consider it so because where I started playing mafia, power roles are considered those with night actions. Is a power role just any role not a vanilla townie?
