Mini 63 - The Family Reunion - Game over

[Untrod Tripod]

I'm not the only person voting for him, so apparently, other people think he's being scummy. So, it seemed to me that Tigris was claiming some kind of cop. Two cops? I think not.

[PolarBoy]

Unvote: Tigris

before anything else happens.

[PolarBoy]

Ok, hang on. Tigris only has two votes right now. Tripod and djinn. Tripod voted for him twice, so the panic there was somewhat undue. Any comment Tripod?

Ok so admittedly I didn't find Tigris' claim all that suspicious. A big part of my vote was just seeing what would happen if I made it.

[Untrod Tripod]

I voted him twice? I completely did not realize that.... Sorry to cause undue panic, I was just trying to get a better roleclaim from him.

[Kerplunk]

Vote Count

2

Tigris (Untrod Tripod, indentureddjinn)

Not voting: the rest.

5 to lynch.

[Tigris]

Okay, so to address a few things. Actually in retrospect, first off, yay, people are posting. ^_^

First off, serial killer role? Sorry, but I think we would have seen signs of it by now, unless of course they are the coldest-blooded SK I have ever seen. At which point I think they may very well deserve to win, just from the vantage point that I would be very impressed by their calm, but I doubt anyone in this game is that cold-blooded.

Second off, the name is part of my back-story, hence why I thought that most people would have received one, my mistake, but at least I am fairly sure that Boo is innocent because otherwise he likely would have claimed a name. Oh and I suppose I should point back to when I made my vote for r0ver, why did I not give him the leeway I give all other vigilantes? Because he claimed the name Nino, my name had my screen-name as part of it, and hence why the claim made no sense to me.

Thirdly,

fos: the masons

, I am very tempted to omgus vote for UT, but since we have more to discuss, I personally believe that the voting should hold off for now.

Fourthly, 'Trying to get a better role-claim out of 'him'?' Whatever, you say I am acting scummy, point to it. Prove it. Also, saying two cops in a mini is rare is false, even by UT's own admission (a whole 3-4 pages ago) there is little reason to suspect that and in the last game I played there were 4 cops.

Additionally, claiming a role like that with 5 people unclaimed would be tantamount to suicide for a mafia, when they can easily be counter-claimed and there was no reason for me to claim in the first place if I was mafia. To be honest I had scratched Gaspode's name off the potential list because I figured that he likely investigated me on night two after me being the final vote for r0ver, so when he voted for me I instantly crossed him off the potential cop list.

Anyhow, at this point you can lynch me or not, in the long run, it proves that there is a cop and that Gaspode is at least likely it, so either way I think the town wins. As to what Gaspode should do with his list, personally, I think it should be revealed and then if the doc has 1-2 people that were saved that were not on the list, he/she should come out, which would give us 5-6 likely and sure live innocents (assuming the 100% confirmed is Cadmium).

[Gaspode]

Well, the list couldn't hurt much, so here goes:

Boo--Innocent.

Checked him night 3 because I thought he might just be idiotic scum trying to get by on a dumb claim.

Cadmium--Innocent

(as we all know). Checked him night 1 because he's the most experienced player in the game.

Untrod Tripod--Innocent

. Checked him night 2 so that we'd have an extra confirmed innocent or scum. Unless I'm naive or he's the GF, we also know that indentureddjinn is innocent.

Things to think about: The role description says I don't know much about the business, so I'm only looking for CIA badges. That could mean one of three things: (1) I can't find non-CIA evil people like SK's, (2) I'm naive, or (3) nothing. Also, UT has seemed very scummy the entire game, so I'm somewhat worried about the godfather possibility.

[Untrod Tripod]

Well, since I was a confirmed innocent, I didn't really think I needed to be as careful. And having strong opinions definately makes you scum! (sarcasm).
I'll go with that logic though.

unvote Tigris

Excellent defense, Tigris.

[NEHI]

All of the claimed roles look legitimate to me. I'm now most suspicious of Quagmire and Yanqush, who have been very quiet. I'll go back to my

vote: Quagmire

since he hasn't followed up on his promise to "get back to [us] later".

[Kerplunk]

Vote Count

1

Quagmire (NEHI)

1

Tigris (indentureddjinn)

Not voting: the rest.

5 to lynch.

Quagmire has asked me to be replaced, I'm still seeking.

[indentureddjinn]

unvote:tigris

well back to square 1

[PolarBoy]

I can go with that NEHI,

Vote: Quagmire

.

[Untrod Tripod]

THE MOD SAID:

Quagmire has asked me to be replaced, I'm still seeking.

[Yanqush]

My theory on Gaspode's investigations......
Since he only look for CIA badges, chances are that the killer of the Don cannot be found guilty, since he dropped his CIA badge (first post).

[Untrod Tripod]

Excellent point, so you're saying that one of the CIA agents was a one-hit guy?

[Tigris]

I assume that that would be the 'godfather' mechanism. I had forgotten about that. Course that only applies to one of the mafia, so Gaspode can still find the other one (assuming there were 3 at the start).

[Kerplunk]

Vote Count

2

Quagmire (NEHI, PolarBoy)

Not voting: the rest.

5 to lynch.

Haven't found a replacement yet. As long as I haven't found one, I consider Quagmire still a player of this game.

[PolarBoy]

Ah, crap, forgot that Quagmire was being replaced. In that case

Unvote: Quagmire, Vote:Boo

.

[Gaspode]

Ahem.

Boo--Innocent. Checked him night 3 because I thought he might just be idiotic scum trying to get by on a dumb claim.

So should I check ID tonight in case of godfatherness, or someone else?

[NEHI]

Unvote: Quagmire

I think you should check ID. If he turns up innocent, we can be pretty sure they both are, and if he turns up guilty, we've got them both.

I was going to vote Yanqush, but then he gave us that nice theory about the badges, and then PolarBoy voted for Boo, and, well,

vote: PolarBoy.

[Yanqush]

Um... I do find the behaviour of Polarboy in these few pages rather "scum-ish" how he got the relations wrong(that brother/sister switch on the last page) , he votes Tigris-"just to see the reaction" and Quagmire-"I'll go with that"
therefore

Vote: Polarboy

[indentureddjinn]

check me and you'll see that im innocent Anyway we need doc protection on Gaspode and

vote:polarboy

[Untrod Tripod]

Why are we voting for PB, just curious?

[NEHI]

Well first of all, I don't think anybody else should vote him before he has a chance to defend himself. My reasons for voting him go like this:

This is who is left in the game:
Gaspode
indentureddjinn
NEHI
PolarBoy
Quagmire
Boo
Tigris
Untrod Tripod
Yanqush

Now, subtract the people who have claimed roles, and you have:
NEHI
PolarBoy
Quagmire
Yanqush

So, I'm looking at 3 people. Quagmire was my first choice, but now he's being replaced, which makes one uncomfortable about lynching him, since he can't defend himself. Yanqush was my next choice, but when he made such a useful post about the badges, it dissuaded me from voting him. PolarBoy is the last of this short list, and he had already made several mistakes (in my opinion), including putting the last vote on malaprop, and now voting Boo.

[Kerplunk]

Vote Count

3

PolarBoy (NEHI, Yangush, indentureddjinn)

1

Boo (PolarBoy)

Not voting: the rest.

9 alive, 5 to lynch.