Enough doubt was removed about the claim when I looked back that I was pretty confident.
Plus I was pretty sure we would instalose if I didn't anyway, since it was blindingly clear to me I would almost certainly be instawagoned if I didn't.
Amrun being a Vanilla Townie should have been a big read alarm notice to her. And to the Town. There is a Bodyguard Director... but the person who they direct is marked as a Vanilla Townie, not a Bodyguard? How does that work?
Amrun dying over Reck with Town Reck made sense, though--because Amrun didn't die over Reck per se, Amrun died while protecting Venmar, who was the one "dying" over Reck.
NOTE: Being of House Bolton, he is immune to the Frey Cop.
Spoiler: Generic
Spoiler: tsunami
Spoiler: Venmar
Spoiler: CDB
Spoiler: Nachomamma8
NOTE: Died simultaneously with Roslin Frey.
NOTE: Mafia Encryptor enabled their DayTalk too.
Spoiler: AurorusVox
NOTE: Dies simultaneously with Edmure Tully.
NOTE: Investigates as a member of House Frey to the Frey Cop.
Spoiler: Tamuz
Spoiler: inHimshallibe
Spoiler: Nexus
Spoiler: Cabd
Spoiler: Amrun
Spoiler: macmollie
NOTE: Sane alignment investigation, not a House Cop.
Spoiler: Ankamius
Spoiler: Metal Sonic
Spoiler: Dekes
NOTES:
-Overall it was a good batch, but there were a couple issues. I thought there might be problems since some of the earlier Role PMs (Brynden, the Lovers, Cat) had a bit MORE for their abilities than simple CUT AND DRY that the others (Dog, Flint) did.
-I changed the color of inHim's flip upon his lynch so it wouldn't look like the Tully blue.
N1 Resolutions:
Venmar receives 'CDB is not a member of House Frey'
macmollie receives 'Nacho is aligned with House Stark'
Desperado Commutes and cannot do so N2
Nacho and AV kick the can
No, it didn't make sense because why would scum ATTEMPT to kill Venmar if Reck was town? It's not what scum would do.
And that's precisely why I didn't worry about it -- nights sort that out. But I guess I should have been more explicit because I was the only one it occurred to?
But honestly idk why I wasn't more suspicious of Reck's claim at the time. I lamented over it to Andy. X.X
It took forever to sell you and mollie that I was town. She was so wanting me to be scum D1
it was more mollie over me. i sorta took the backseat and let her dictate for a while. during n1 i told her i thought nacho was town but was at a festival and she stilled looked at him </3 so i took authority on n2 and vigged the shit out of tierce.
In post 1992, Amrun wrote:No, it didn't make sense because why would scum ATTEMPT to kill Venmar if Reck was town? It's not what scum would do.
Why not? There was a Frey alive and Venmar could catch them. Worst case, they eliminate the Bodyguard--and many players will actually attempt to kill the Cop when they know there is a working Bodyguard, as there is no real way around it. In both cases, it would have taken two Nights to off Venmar, and with a Frey around, the scum needed to eliminate Venmar regardless of Reck's alignment.
Admittedly, killing Venmar off n the final Night over Reck WAS telling (since Venmar was no longer a threat), but not the initial choice of killing Venmar over him.