In post 1113, Adorable wrote:
I don't have confident town reads and players I think are town are Jingle and Cerb. Rest of the players are in my poe.
Adorable, can you talk to me about why you thought Cerb was town at the start of Day 2 after you suspected him on Day 1?
Cerb claimed Mario. When I got my role pm I was speculating in team chat what kind of roles there would be and I thought the town pr were Mario, Peach, Luigi and I thought the vt would be Goombas.
I'll reiterate that I believe wgeurts is the correct protection target, as the only zero information flip scum has available. Whether you choose to actually do that or not is up to you.
In the meantime, I'll be preparing to face my ghosts in hell tonight
Maybe the real Mafia was the friends we made along the way
In post 1904, Radical Rat wrote:
I'll reiterate that I believe wgeurts is the correct protection target, as the only zero information flip scum has available. Whether you choose to actually do that or not is up to you.
In the meantime, I'll be preparing to face my ghosts in hell tonight
adorable should be protecting hpe and hpe should be tracking me, end of story
so did you just give up on rereading the game or are those your conclusions
Last day I did but I'm giving it more time now, I'm not gonna lie I did not realise my vote was the hammer and won't be doing so until I have time to post not from mobile.
Titus didn't like Peta earlier and I had to decline the voices telling me to do that, but I'll ask her what she thinks now. I reckon game ends when we flip RR though.
Peta would be the kind of scum partner that would motivate cerb to actually try. No offence intended, but their playstyle would mesh. Also RR has literally no other option but to fish on HPE or Peta as scum. If RR somehow does flip town I think we take out Peta but that would be done a little more carefully.
In post 1904, Radical Rat wrote:
I'll reiterate that I believe wgeurts is the correct protection target, as the only zero information flip scum has available. Whether you choose to actually do that or not is up to you.
In the meantime, I'll be preparing to face my ghosts in hell tonight
adorable should be protecting hpe and hpe should be tracking me, end of story
that is beyond obvious
Why? You've said yourself you expect the tracker to do nothing because scum holsters. Did you change your mind about respecting the scumteam's intelligence? What benefit is there to keeping HPE alive over wgeurts otherwise?
Maybe the real Mafia was the friends we made along the way
In post 1904, Radical Rat wrote:
I'll reiterate that I believe wgeurts is the correct protection target, as the only zero information flip scum has available. Whether you choose to actually do that or not is up to you.
In the meantime, I'll be preparing to face my ghosts in hell tonight
adorable should be protecting hpe and hpe should be tracking me, end of story
that is beyond obvious
Why? You've said yourself you expect the tracker to do nothing because scum holsters. Did you change your mind about respecting the scumteam's intelligence? What benefit is there to keeping HPE alive over wgeurts otherwise?
in the event scum DOES submit a NK then HPE will have a result of no action on me, this is obviously good
if they don't submit a NK then we're at MELO and the actions won't matter
from my pov if adorable is protecting wgeurts and you're not scum it opens up the possibility of whoever is scum shooting hpe and taking me to a 1v1, and i actually do not want that
you're kind of talking in circles here, it's not hard - in the event that scum submits a kill, i want a 100% guarantee hpe has to claim a result on me
i'm signing off for the night but i just want to say
Radical Rat, I was way too harsh in my rhetoric toward you the previous game day. I shouldn't have gone there and I apologize, it was inappropriate.
if you're town, i got there on you being town, and i wish you could have done the same on me because it probably would have averted a loss. if you're scum gg you got me orson welles clap dot gif i should probably retire again lmao
In post 1904, Radical Rat wrote:
I'll reiterate that I believe wgeurts is the correct protection target, as the only zero information flip scum has available. Whether you choose to actually do that or not is up to you.
In the meantime, I'll be preparing to face my ghosts in hell tonight
adorable should be protecting hpe and hpe should be tracking me, end of story
that is beyond obvious
Why? You've said yourself you expect the tracker to do nothing because scum holsters. Did you change your mind about respecting the scumteam's intelligence? What benefit is there to keeping HPE alive over wgeurts otherwise?
in the event scum DOES submit a NK then HPE will have a result of no action on me, this is obviously good
if they don't submit a NK then we're at MELO and the actions won't matter
from my pov if adorable is protecting wgeurts and you're not scum it opens up the possibility of whoever is scum shooting hpe and taking me to a 1v1, and i actually do not want that
you're kind of talking in circles here, it's not hard - in the event that scum submits a kill, i want a 100% guarantee hpe has to claim a result on me
If HPE has a result on you, it's gonna be a guilty, and you're in that 1v1 anyway. But you've already made it clear that scum holstering is correct play, which means if you're scum you know that, and if you aren't, scum can read. The only way HPE gets a result tonight is if it's scum and is worried people might change their mind on you.
Keeping a conftown alive is infinitely more valuable than a dud track. And with HPE vulnerable, the question of whether scum should kill becomes an actual question.
Maybe the real Mafia was the friends we made along the way
Okay I really don't have a reason to drag this out.
VOTE: Radical Rat
No I haven't read all the pages, and I could have taken the time to give in-depth thoughts on the slots, but regardless of the result I'm always voting RR today. I'd rather get the result of this, base further analysis off the flip, and then talk to clean up the game from there.
Do the right thing tonight/tomorrow please. We're almost there, don't get complacent, think things through, but don't let scum talk you out of the truth either.
This is still very winnable
Maybe the real Mafia was the friends we made along the way
I agree, it's far more likely than not to be peta, with HPE as a secondary possibility. Adorable would probably be worst case scenario, but I don't really see her as scum here at all.
Maybe the real Mafia was the friends we made along the way
In post 1921, Radical Rat wrote:
I agree, it's far more likely than not to be peta, with HPE as a secondary possibility. Adorable would probably be worst case scenario, but I don't really see her as scum here at all.
Adorable is almost conf-town, Fate sought paranormal activity, this probably means the final scum is the ghost Boo. Being loved would make absolutely zero sense with the flavour, and Peach on the other hand with bodyguard makes much more sense. Also claiming Bodyguard as scum would be laughable.
Actually, I think there's a way to force the scum to kill someone too.
Adorable, I'm so confident you're town that I want you to randomly target either me or HPE. I need HPE to track adorable and claim who they targeted last night. If HPE doesn't call it correctly, we know they're fakeclaiming. Otherwise, Adorable dies tonight. Leaving three and just a minor possibility of a factor less.
