Mafia 107 - Christmas Time Mafia (Game over)

[Tarballs]

Thread of the Dead, where dead people discussed about the game. Mafia and neighbors can post their QTs too, if they want to.

Night actions:

Night 1:

InflatablePie kills Fugitive
NavyCherub roleblocks RichardGHP
Flareonage protects pman5595
Konowa kills Flareonage
RichardGHP investigates Nicodemus (Blocked, so no result)
DizzyIzzy tracks NavyCherub (Visited RichardGHP)
CryMeARiver jails sorasgoof
Parama watches Nicodemus (No one did anything to him)

Night 2:

pman5595 kills Parama
Konowa kills Nicodemus
RichardGHP commutes
ready2rock kills DragonsofSummer
DizzyIzzy tracks DragonsofSummer (No visit)
CryMeARiver jails TheLonging
Nicodemus guards DizzyIzzyB13
Parama watches DizzyIzzyB13 (Someone guarded him)

Night 3:

Amished kills CryMeARiver
Konowa kills Amished
RichardGHP protects DizzyIzzyB13
DizzyIzzyB13 tracks sorasgoof (No visit)
CryMeARiver jails ready2rock

Night 4:

pman5595 kills DizzyIzzyB13
Konowa kills pman5595
RichardGHP roleblocks ready2rock
ready2rock kills CCARaven4 (Blocked)
DizzyIzzyB13 tracks DocPotter (No visit)

Night 5:

Konowa kills sorasgoof

[Konowa]

Yes. You were right about it. /gloat

CMAR's breadcrumb was also pretty obv too.

[Amished]

EBWOP: Honestly, I still don't see how TL was lynched. If I were him; I'd bring up how he got rung up to L-1 within the first 5 pages of a large normal; and say that scum don't buss that early and that scum had to be there (I think 3 out of the 4 were there and all of us had pretty crappy reasons) if anybody wanted to look back for their own experience and seeing scum in action.

I was gonna bring up wagon analysis, but I was on so many of them in conspicuous spots that I was afraid I'd implicate myself.

[Amished]

So why didn't you go after him? I was assuming that you'd be more afraid of either Dizzy or CMAR since you can't delegate other kills to other people and avoid a tracker in that manner. Dizzy especially I thought you'd be worried about.

[Konowa]

I was hoping that because of how obv it was you guys would do it for me
I know I ran a risk by not killing Dizzy, but I thought I was town enough that she would not track me.

[Amished]

Well, you need somebody looking for them to really notice, I forgot about it until I looked at the player list again. Pman missed it, and I don't think anybody else really caught it (or if they did they didn't say anything).

[curiouskarmadog]

the only thing I did do correctly in the game was nail the SK in the clutch...I was wrong about most everything else.

[Konowa]

Love you too ckd.

Amished, he actually made two breadcrumbs. The first was something like "no, don't protect Dizzy tonight" talking to Richard. The second was "go ahead protect Dizzy and hope someone protects you". I figured that since you were mafia you would have easily spotted it and would kill him.

[curiouskarmadog]

lol, read the thread of the dead.

didnt have too many fans in that bunch....think the entire thread thought I was the SK

[Amished]

That's all you needed to do to win though, so it works.

[Konowa]

Twas also my first large and the tactics behind it are a little different than mini's.

I saw. I also noticed Amished's love for me in there.

[curiouskarmadog]

started to get suspcious a couple of days back when I noted that noone I openly suspected in the neighbor thread was being night killed....

Kon did my aggressiveness + opened suspicion affect your kills at all?

[Amished]

It's the same in any multi-scum setup though as scum; you lynch scum and shoot town. I can understand (barely) pman/flare; but when you "knew" I was scum just push a lynch on me. I assume you're un-nkable (or at least bulletproof) which is why you were hoping for r2r to try to shoot you tonight and would've taken another day; but I doubt that would've mattered much.

I don't understand why you got to be in the neighbor group but the mafia couldn't. That was another hangup of mine.

Tar: Mod thoughts/setup design thoughts?

@ckd: I didn't think you were the SK! Course, I have some experience with you in LOST so I can filter out your playstyle. When I play with you I figure whoever you're adamant about I can ignore since they're town

[sorasgoof]

Yay, my first ever mafia win! How do you guys think I did?

[Amished]

Soras, you didn't do too bad for your first time. I was actually not that disappointed with anybody's play except maybe diddin; cause I really don't have a lot of regard for D1 town lynches. You're actually in the sweet spot that I'm trying to get my playstyle to at the moment. You're scummy enough not to get that much attention; but pro-town enough not to get lynched.

[curiouskarmadog]

@ckd: I didn't think you were the SK! Course, I have some experience with you in LOST so I can filter out your playstyle. When I play with you I figure whoever you're adamant about I can ignore since they're town

lol, in my defense....I had a point with some of my suspicions.

I am a much better scum player....

[curiouskarmadog]

too paranoid and angry as town...shit, even though Dizzy tracked scum, I still wasnt positive that she was town.

[pman5595]

would anyone have believed a cop claim from me? I tried breadcrumbing.

I would have investigated Richard N1, Soras N2, and Amished N3

[sorasgoof]

EBWOP: When I say my first ever mafia win, I mean my first ever win in a mafia game, not as a mafioso. :p

[Amished]

Well CKD, I wish you would've been on my scumteam <3

[Konowa]

Not that I noticed ckd. I do not remember ever thinking it, but it is possible.

I am un-nk-able, Amished. Was hoping they would let r2r try shoot me so I could have shot ckd. To be truthful Amished, I did not have the energy at that point to try and push a lynch on you.

Also, I am going to policy lynch Richard in any game I am with him now.

[Amished]

Haha, I'm intimidating as scum! RAWR!!!! lol

[Parama]

Konowa gets the "Honorary Town Vig" status for this game.
GJ guys, also I suck at day 1 reads it seems.

[Konowa]

Well, the only time I purposefully shot mafia, was when I shot Amished. I can not help it that my bullets like mafiablood.

[Amished]

Just so you know you shouldn't have shot me; and carry that onto later games is all I ask for.