Micro 1083: Garlic Bread Heist Dead/Spectator PT

[DkKoba]

No Shea was actually angry

Oh I pointed out in thread that I figured out his anger was all focused on me as a person and not anything game related lol

Looked like he planned to guilty me based on his pivot last day but that really did set him up to slip lol

[anahit]

you forgot about me!

oh right! merlyn is in your slot not enchant which makes thestatusquo's claim pretty impossible, yeah?

because he is clearing you so from merlyn's perspective the game would have to be

1 1-shot bp
1 jailkeeper
1 rolecop
4 vt
1 goon
1 1-shot strongman

for thestatusquo to be truthful? which makes the already ??? setup from before into a very unlikely one

[DkKoba]

And in retrospect when reading his frustration- it is solely aimed at me as a person rather than actually feeling concerned for sheep(like if shea is town here he played day 1 in an extremely level 0 way and I believe he is above that)

[Ausuka]

I think jailkeeper + BP Vs rolecop is fine and balanced shrug

oh i certainly do not think that is unbalanced! i was just thinking about player expectation and how datisi's expectation differed from mine/others in that game and how that might apply to this (similar) situation

i do think

1 jailkeeper
1 rolecop
5 vt
1 goon
1 1-shot strongman

would be kinda ???

but like skygazer said impossible to tell exact how much knowing the alignments is weighing on my thinking with regards to this

I haven't thought about it but my instinct as a reviewer would be this looks balanced (with BP probably townsided)

I don't think I'd design it as a mod though I don't really see why you would go this route as a designer

[DkKoba]

it is 4 am here now, if you're town you'll read day 1 and find me.

If I go today the last scum is almost certainly in dunn xof hb with an extremely small chance of GB because their positioning today from what I can glean from the last few pages seems kind of alarming to me.

I am helping clean the airbnb tomorrow and then driving back to chicago so its unclear to me how much time I'll have to check in in depth again so these are my dying thoughts if I'm the lim.

good luck y'all.

This post + his claim is just a gigantic blunder

[anahit]

merlyn's perspective

which would then also be from hellbooks perspective as well because merlyn confirmed by the 1v1 to her aussi

[Ausuka]

I don't think he was planning to guilty you? I imagine the claim thing is just a brainfart

Who knows maybe he'll be able to explain it away, I think town wins though. If I'm in Shea's position I always claim VT

[DkKoba]

I don't think he was planning to guilty you? I imagine the claim thing is just a brainfart

Who knows maybe he'll be able to explain it away, I think town wins though. If I'm in Shea's position I always claim VT

The shift in shading me I think implies he wants that 1v1, although could be a brainfart too.

[DkKoba]

ya claiming VT makes it enchant vs hellbooks most likely

[VP Baltar]

I will be very interested in the post game thoughts from brooks

[DkKoba]

sad part is I'm p sure merlyn will buy this

[DkKoba]

so many obvious questions to ask oneself that implicate shea here

[Ausuka]

(he did, in fact, check tris to see if she was a BP) I

[DkKoba]

(he did, in fact, check tris to see if she was a BP) I

I don't doubt it

[VP Baltar]

sad part is I'm p sure merlyn will buy this

I agree. I think it was a good, if risky play

[DkKoba]

it was objectively a bad play but good for the lazy townies in this f4

[Ausuka]

The plot twist is that everyone replaces out again and suddenly Shea is stuck with a bunch of randos who don't like the rolecop claim

[anahit]

oo enchant doing the thing! exciting!!

[Ausuka]

Enchant will hard carry and then everyone will be forced to apologise for their enchant slander

[DkKoba]

Calling a JK an investigative is a huge stretch. Sometimes it can function as that, but its pretty weak at doing that and can stop me from investigating as well and the BP exists which means you can't always assume that the JK stopped the kill even if you flip all the roles.

Role cop is an incredibly weak investigative role.

Again I know these are the arguments you have to make but they're not very strong.

hope someone points out how poor of an argument this is when the scumteam has a supposed always guilty rolecop role(strongman)

[DkKoba]

Holy shit enchant pulled the newbie game argument lol

[DkKoba]

very cross with how discrediting hellbooks is of me when yes I obviously died for a reason ???

[Ausuka]

Garlic bread claimed ausuka's mod meta is townsided setups

koba talking shit about me is going to make town lose the game, you love to see it

[Ausuka]

Ok well maybe it's not a massive factor or really much of one at all but I will take satisfaction from it anyways

[Skygazer]

every time i see 'vc' i'm like oh shit it's the viet cong