Board Games Mafia -- Game Over!

[ShadowLurker]

I WIN!

[ShadowLurker]

wow good work guys! A great result!
I'm only disappointed that i only got to play for 1 day. I don't think i played badly-i feel i provided some good analysis, and i was correct with my number 1 suspicion (BM). On the other hand, Nightfall was way off my scumdar, so well done to him.

SL

[Ectomancer]

Nice job Thok!

Thanks for the game Glork, I enjoyed it for certain

[IH]

I played horribly.

I told you Monopoly wasn't scum!

Lets lynch im again just to make sure

Vote:Kison

[HackerHuck]

I'm more than a little saddened that Nightfall did me in to finish off the scum group. Someone sent me an image on night1 that gave me the ability to investigate someone. I had picked Nightfall and I got a guilty result. We had bandied about a few different scenarios for how to handle the info, but didn't get a chance to use it.

Good game town for pulling out a win. Nightfall hitting two scum definitely played into your hands. I was hoping that he would be more interested in killing town than scum, but he almost managed to pull it off.

[Mastermind of Sin]

I'm still mad at Glork for starting this game without me even after I told him I definitely wanted /in.

[Nightfall]

I thought once I claimed vig, if I went after someone I didnt think was scum or that had a more than obvious reason they were scum eyes would turn to me rather quickly.

[IH]

HH you should have claimed someone gave you an investigation. That would have been a great way to keep you alive, since you've just killed someone outside of your scumgroup.

[Zindaras]

Nightfall won the game for us, pretty much. He got really unlucky and was outconfirmed in the end.

The game was pretty balanced, overall. The town probably had a slight advantage. I don't really see the need for 3-kill immunity for the Battleship (since I seriously doubt anyone gets killed 4 times in a game), but I guess it was pretty flavourful. I'm just happy he didn't have anything against lynches either.

[Battle Mage]

well, i dont think my play in this game was anything to write home about. I do feel that my lynch was kind of pathetic. I never really had a chance to defend myself, so at the time, i felt a bit cheated. Even so, it was great to work with such an experienced scumteam. Even though we lost, i really felt that the others knew what they were doing, which is always pretty reassuring.
Definitely a group i would want to play with again, and a deserved win by the town all-in-all.

[IH]

I enjoy more proof that late vig claims are SKs

[HackerHuck]

HH you should have claimed someone gave you an investigation. That would have been a great way to keep you alive, since you've just killed someone outside of your scumgroup.

I had debated claiming backup cop, but we decided on the theory of using DoS as a tracker. Unfortunately, we didn't give him enough info to flesh out a decent claim and with Thesp turning up scum, that sealed DoS' fate. I didn't think that just telling the truth would get me very far since it didn't prove I wasn't scum.

It was rather painful for me to watch the game after I died, knowing that Nightfall was the SK. I was hoping you guys would catch him as vengeance for killing off half the scum team.

[CrashTextDummie]

Well done town.

My bitter feelings have mellowed, and I'm glad my modkill apparently didn't tip the balance much.

[DragonsofSummer]

Eh don't blame anyone but me for my botched claim HH... I took the basis of a very believable, claim that could have put me in endgame, and I botched it. I've been kicking myself ever since it happened.

I learned a lot from the mistakes I made in this game though, and hope that I won't repeat them in the future.

Anyway I just wanna say Great job nightfall on knocking out scum and almost winning that was very well played.

[IH]

I had debated claiming backup cop, but we decided on the theory of using DoS as a tracker. Unfortunately, we didn't give him enough info to flesh out a decent claim and with Thesp turning up scum, that sealed DoS' fate. I didn't think that just telling the truth would get me very far since it didn't prove I wasn't scum.

It was rather painful for me to watch the game after I died, knowing that Nightfall was the SK. I was hoping you guys would catch him as vengeance for killing off half the scum team.

Why didn't you just claim the truth? Inventor gave you an inspect? = \

[Kison]

well, i dont think my play in this game was anything to write home about. I do feel that my lynch was kind of pathetic. I never really had a chance to defend myself, so at the time, i felt a bit cheated. Even so, it was great to work with such an experienced scumteam. Even though we lost, i really felt that the others knew what they were doing, which is always pretty reassuring.
Definitely a group i would want to play with again, and a deserved win by the town all-in-all.

Was my fault. I accidentally hammered you.

[HackerHuck]

Why didn't you just claim the truth? Inventor gave you an inspect? = \

I thought the SK's kills would actually help us at first. When that backfired and Thesp died, we went to massclaim and I didn't have a good reason why I didn't claim the guilty result sooner.

[Thok]

For what it's worth, I probably would have gone back after HH once Ecto turned up dead, simply because everybody else was confirmed not mafia. You really needed to kill a mason (or possibly me) to cut down on the number of confirmed.

Nightfall was basically dead after the game reached 6 alive, 4 of them mostly confirmed. The only reason he lasted so long was because town (and by town, I probably should mean me) decided to take a bunch of safety plays.

[HackerHuck]

Yes, I will say that Ecto really blew this game open with his early game theory. At that point, I felt that a scum win was quite the long shot even though neither Thesp nor I seemed to be on anyone's suspicion list at the time.

[Ectomancer]

Yes, I will say that Ecto really blew this game open with his early game theory. At that point, I felt that a scum win was quite the long shot even though neither Thesp nor I seemed to be on anyone's suspicion list at the time.

I had to go back and look to see where you were talking about exactly. That's pretty funny. Post 1165 had the 3 remaining scum, plus the SK in a narrow list of 5, and what did I do? Vote Kison

[Nightfall]

I was hoping there was one more scum or traitor or maybe some real vig that would have added to the night kills. Something I could have passed off as the real bad guy.

[Glork]

Thanks for all of the input/feedback, guys. I had an absolute blast modding, and I hoped you all enjoyed it, too.



One question, Nightfall: Why did you choose to claim Battleship/Vig instead of (Something)/Townie?

[Nightfall]

Wow sorry about taking so long to answer this.
I claimed vig because I though otherwise It' would be a bit to hard to avoid being the one the kills were linked to. I strongly considered night immune, but thought that as with the point before it would greatly limit my abbillity to do anything with my night kills.

[Nightfall]

I was considering a last ditch play at the end of night killing Thesp and claiming that I truely targeted Zind, but when the point came I thought there was no way it would work so I just went with the flow.

[Nightfall]

Thesp = Thok *