Mini 1625: Redemption (Game Over)

[Thor665]

Poor play in my opinion - you analyzed nothing, went on a stale case, and let Willow derp by for a second day running without actually backing up anything.
Lynch them tomorrow or prepare for further mocking in the Dead QT.

[GGG]

Poor play in my opinion - you analyzed nothing, went on a stale case, and let Willow derp by for a second day running without actually backing up anything.
Lynch them tomorrow or prepare for further mocking in the Dead QT.

Probably but the town has no motivation to do anything and talking to nothing when no one engages isn't exciting. I analyses several things. You and Munkir were off site for the entire night 2. This was better than your whomp refuses to put in a case case. Not as good as my CP is munkirs buddy case but you can't win them all.

[GGG]

Overall in this game for whatever reason this town is lazy and impatient

[Whomping Willow]

Poor play in my opinion - you analyzed nothing, went on a stale case, and let Willow derp by for a second day running without actually backing up anything.
Lynch them tomorrow or prepare for further mocking in the Dead QT.

Trolling

[GuyInFreezer]

VC 5.1

Thor665 (4):

Whomping Willow, TellTaleHeart, Flubbernugget, GGG

Whomping Willow (1):

Thor665

Not Voting:

crazypianist1116, Naomi-Tan

With 7 Alive, 4 to Lynch

The deadline is January 20, 12 PM EST.
Countdown: (expired on 2015-01-20 12:00:00)

[GuyInFreezer]

Thor665,

Mafia JoaT

, was lynched Day 5.

Whomping Willow,

Vanilla Townie

, survived and won.
TellTaleHeart,

Vanilla Townie

, survived and won.
GGG,

Vanilla Townie

, survived and won.
crazypianist1116,

Vanilla Townie

, survived and won.
Naomi-Tan,

Town 2-shot Watcher

, survived and won.
Flubbernugget,

Town Jailkeeper

, survived and won.

Town wins

[TierShift]

Hunh, the OC slot actually was scum :/
Poor reads, why was I even nightkilled?
Why were there so little kills, gif?

[GuyInFreezer]

N1 one of the shot was blocked by bulletproof.
N2 Mafia didn't kill.
N4 Thor purposefully didn't kill.

[Whomping Willow]

GG Scums. Thanks gif. PTs?

We almost never mislynched

[GGG]

Why the resistance to put up at.least a bit of a case?

The big give away was the lurker no kill day 2. But i was pretty sure munk was newb town.

Good watching N aiomi, i think we had dgb but Munk was a real good watch. What made you choose him

Munk was your play as newb town intentional?

[Thor665]

This was an uphill battle to replace into - I thought when some people actually started asking questions this Day phase that I might have had a chance to swing it - I feel mod owes me a replace in anytime I ask for one now

[droog]

lynching werewolf and getting the watch early made the difference
game was balanced against two scum factions
but town easily overpowered one

good game guys

[Thor665]

Why the resistance to put up at.least a bit of a case?

I second this (especially since I think I was right about the case not existing as you claimed it did) - I felt you gave me an opening to exploit. It ended up not helping, but with a more active town it might have managed to allow me an opening to manage your lynch and it would have been incredibly easy and pro-town of you to just shut me down. I didn't understand the play at all.

[Thor665]

lynching werewolf and getting the watch early made the difference
game was balanced against two scum factions
but town easily overpowered one

good game guys

And the other one didn't play for their wincon

[droog]

disappointed you killed me
> :

[Thor665]

In my defense I had to make that value call with about one hour of skimming and a silent partner available to me.
I killed you because you were active - no more, no less.

If I had been aware of the watcher claim I would have shot differently

[Whomping Willow]

Why the resistance to put up at.least a bit of a case?

I second this (especially since I think I was right about the case not existing as you claimed it did) - I felt you gave me an opening to exploit. It ended up not helping, but with a more active town it might have managed to allow me an opening to manage your lynch and it would have been incredibly easy and pro-town of you to just shut me down. I didn't understand the play at all.

I didn't want to engage you because I knew you'd probably come out of it better than me and that we had enough reads on that slot to just force the lynch through.

There was more, off the top of my head he had some bs push on me and droog, stoked on an oog argument then
Made a post about it beung anti town

[droog]

ftr thor
i think my case on awa
((werewolf lynched day 1))
is what willow kept giving you as incentive to read

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 5#p6419735

[Thor665]

I didn't want to engage you because I knew you'd probably come out of it better than me and that we had enough reads on that slot to just force the lynch through.

The thing is though, GGG lynched me more out of boredom, and you had two town players asking for the case - eh, I said some stuff about it in the scum QT, but frankly I think you probably could have got the lynch quicker with simply going 'here' and then refusing to debate me about it. Presenting a case and choosing not to debate it are two different things. One of them looks inherently scummy while the other doesn't. As I said, I think you gave me an opening you didn't need to. maybe I was wrong, your method did work - but I'd consider that in the future.

@Droog - now you're just trying to show off

[Flubbernugget]

Gg everyone. Thanks for modding gif

[GuyInFreezer]

Werewolf PT: http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=90&t=59808
Mafia PT: http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=90&t=59807
Neighbor PT: http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=90&t=59809
Spoilered Dead PT: http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=90&t=59805
Unspoilered Dead PT: http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=90&t=60057

[TellTaleHeart]

I logged in expecting to type up a Thor case. @_@

Oh well. Sorry about that Thorella. I knew you'd be irritated with me leaving an unexplained vote, but I'm currently pressed for time and was planning on talking about it later.

[Whomping Willow]

frankly I think you probably could have got the lynch quicker with simply going 'here' and then refusing to debate me about it. Presenting a case and choosing not to debate it are two different things. One of them looks inherently scummy while the other doesn't. As I said, I think you gave me an opening you didn't need to. maybe I was wrong, your method did work - but I'd consider that in the future.

You're probably right, but if you'd started deconstructing any case I'd likely have been reeled in, it just wasn't an avenue I felt like opening unless I needed to, if you've read Oc's iso you'll understand why your slot was unrecoverable.

[Thor665]

I did read that iso. For extra fun go read the scum QT.
That said - you could have spared me about 48 hours by just stating a case

[TierShift]

I'll start with TierShift because I don't like his avatar. The color clashes with my screen.

Lol