Mini 1424: Mafibleh - GAME OVER

[Jun]

In my opinion, the evidence against TCS amounts to much more than the evidence against Bacde. There is consistent evidence for TCS scum over the course of the whole entire game, whereas Bacde's slot seems remarkably consistent with his town macho cop claim despite multiple replacements.

There's more stuff I didn't include in my list, but these are the big things to me. When the best argument against Bacde is that the guy who he replaced said he's good at finding town and the best argument against TCS is that he had incriminating vote patterns surrounding YOLO/kashoodles AND the best argument for Bacde town is hammering mafia while the best argument for TCS town is that someone is framing TCS, I'm forced to conclude that it is, in fact TCS.

I now feel comfortable voting for TCS. Seeing that Thor665 has unvoted, I shall cast my vote and wait for his return. TCS feel free to respond to the reasons why I found you scummy aside from the implausibility argument that you are so fond of.

VOTE: The Central Scrutinizer

[Jun]

Hello? Is anybody here?

[Thor665]

Vote: TCS

Back.

[The Central Scrutinizer]

Yeah, I thought it would be fun to try to flip Jun instead of playing the "NO JUN IS SCUM" game, but I stopped caring when Thor finally got smart.

GG anyway.

[Bacde]

YUSS

I have no idea how scum managed to win here

[Bacde]

jk I'm trolling I'm town

gg guys

[Thor665]

Yeah, the setup made more sense that way - but the fakeclaim really hurt my head.

Jun won it for town by reminding me of HD's terribad self hammer, which then painted Bacde as strong town in retrospect once I looked at it again knowing HD was town.

[Bacde]

yeah whatever thor

I will say that my faith in you is restored partially

[Thor665]

Whatever?

Nice.

Why don't you go sheep a town who is proven to not be reading and act like that's brilliant pro-town play and then critique me again...oh, wait

[Bacde]

Whatever?

Nice.

Why don't you go sheep a town who is proven to not be reading and act like that's brilliant pro-town play and then critique me again...oh, wait

nice

Keep acting like voting for the guy who led the lynch on scum, is the doctor, and was cop cleared was an awesomesauce read

lol we both have big egos this won't work out for us

[Thor665]

1. He didn't lead the vote. Drummer did.
2. I was supposed to know he was the Doc? That's meaningless.
3. I was supposed to know he was cop cleared? That's meaningless.
4. He was provably not reading the game and pushing a case based on that.

:shrug:

[Thor665]

Heck, it's even fairly clear I was townreading him up until I realized he wasn't reading the game and pushing a case based on that - and then I had issues with him.
Y'know, because that's highly unusual to do.

[TraceyLyn11]

VC 4.3 - Final VC of day four:
The Central Scrutinizer (

LYNCH

)- Bacde, Jun, Thor665
Bacde (L-2)- The Central Scrutinizer

Not Voting:

With 4 alive, it takes 3 to lynch.

[TraceyLyn11]

GAME OVER!

The Central Scrutinizer,

Mafia Goon

, was lynched day four.

Jun,

Vanilla Townie

, survived.

Bacde,

Macho Cop

, survived.

Thor665,

Vanilla Townie

, survived.

~TOWN WINS~

Mafia QT
Dead QT
Setup Review/Roles QT

[TraceyLyn11]

Whoosh. Finally.

So.

Couple things.

A) For those who are curious, SKrew disappeared, so I had to take over. He came back just yesterday, but considering he was gone for almost the entire game and it was ending soon, he said it was no longer his game.

B) There was a bit of a hiccup during the first night. I accidentally sent TheReverend the Mafia QT because Macho Cop registered as Mafia Macho Cop for whatever reason in my mind. After a lot of freaking out on my part, I decided to ask a few people what they thought I should do to fix it (I didn't really want to modkill him). They suggested that if Rev was okay with it, I should say he requested replacement and explain at the end of the game. He did agree to it (because he's

awesome

), so that's what I'm doing now! So, yeah, thank you so so so much for being so amazingly understanding, Rev, and thank you Bacde for replacing into the slot, and sorry to everyone else for the random replacement in the middle of the night phase.

C) THIS GAME TOOK FOREVER.

D) Congrats to the town for winning! And good job, scum, you did really awesome, too.

[Wisdom]

CONGRATS ON BEING WISDOM

>.< Is that a thing now?

[Kerberos]

I still say Drummer is scum.

I think I got the scum team early, but all the noise started distracting me and I couldn't figure out if it was scum noise or anti-town noise.

This game was fun, but it was suuuuper long, I didn't think it would ever end.

thanks for saving the game Tracey <3

[Bacde]

WISDOM!!

You read this game!

I didn't mean it as an insult--you are an excellent player. I just meant that thor was basically doing the same thing that you were in that previous newbie game.

Good game guys

[Bacde]

B) There was a bit of a hiccup during the first night. I accidentally sent TheReverend the Mafia QT because Macho Cop registered as Mafia Macho Cop for whatever reason in my mind. After a lot of freaking out on my part, I decided to ask a few people what they thought I should do to fix it (I didn't really want to modkill him). They suggested that if Rev was okay with it, I should say he requested replacement and explain at the end of the game. He did agree to it (because he's awesome), so that's what I'm doing now! So, yeah, thank you so so so much for being so amazingly understanding, Rev, and thank you Bacde for replacing into the slot, and sorry to everyone else for the random replacement in the middle of the night phase.

I WAS WONDERING WHY THEREVEREND REPLACED OUT!

He did such a great job with the awesome slot, and was obviously interested in the game, it made NO SENSE to me that he replaced out

[Kerberos]

Bacde, you were terrible this game. like, I might have even thought you were scum too.

oh, that's Obv Mara and so is this

[TraceyLyn11]

B) There was a bit of a hiccup during the first night. I accidentally sent TheReverend the Mafia QT because Macho Cop registered as Mafia Macho Cop for whatever reason in my mind. After a lot of freaking out on my part, I decided to ask a few people what they thought I should do to fix it (I didn't really want to modkill him). They suggested that if Rev was okay with it, I should say he requested replacement and explain at the end of the game. He did agree to it (because he's awesome), so that's what I'm doing now! So, yeah, thank you so so so much for being so amazingly understanding, Rev, and thank you Bacde for replacing into the slot, and sorry to everyone else for the random replacement in the middle of the night phase.

I WAS WONDERING WHY THEREVEREND REPLACED OUT!

He did such a great job with the awesome slot, and was obviously interested in the game, it made NO SENSE to me that he replaced out

Yeah, I felt so bad. >_> He seemed like the player with the most invested in the game at the time, too, dugdugydgduyg. And I really hated to make it out as though he requested it but had I said that there was a mod error, it would have implied that he was town.

[Thor665]

"Dear Diary,

Thor is frustrated."

Yeah, that about sums it up.

@Rev - my answer would be 'I wouldn't play intentionally badly to get run up, fakeclaim, and then hope to avoid the nightkill that way.' I've never understood or agreed with that strategy as it always leaves town having to question the PR claim later, and then it became even worse with the replace out situation.

[Bacde]

Bacde, you were terrible this game. like, I might have even thought you were scum too.

oh, that's Obv Mara and so is this

nope

[Drummer]

Yeah, we dragged every single day out as long as possible. The only person I really give props to is Jun. Nice call from the beginning.

[TheReverend]

Seriously don't worry about the mistake, it happens. Maybe I'd have just investigated TCS and finished the game right there, which would be no fun! I enjoyed watching this one, well played thor jun and bcade, I thought jun in particular was excellent, and well played to TCS too, you were up against it, I was rooting for you in the end!