GreyICE wrote:I've... I literally have nothing. My only thought is these are Mastin kills, since they're so fucking awful only Mastin would do this as non-town.
I'll have to do an ISO of myself to see what I've said on all the kills. This is all I could find in my Quicktopic.
Empking (Town Watcher) has died! <--Obv-vig. No scum player'd shoot Empking.
Hiraki (Townie) has died! <--Town enough, so has a fair chance of being the scum kill. It is, however, possibly a safe-SK kill.
NanookTheWolf (Townie) has died! <--Looks like a mercy-SK kill.
N1 wrote:hiplop (Townie) has died!
lewarcher82 (Mafia Goon) has died!
I personally wouldn't kill hiplop as scum--he was confirmed town to me, but as shown by the Maxous and Mal mislynches, confirmed town to ME is not confirmed town to the TOWN.
I obviously wouldn't have been able to shoot lew if I were the last scum, and as an SK, at this point in the game, I'd have no way of knowing there was a vig in the game, and therefore would shoot like one: AKA, I'd target one of my scum suspects N1. I believe the list was {Tomie, Edmund, GreyICE, ?, ?} (I don't remember who the other two were off the top of my head).
So, can't be the SK due to this, though I suppose you could go for the theoretical I-was-scum-who-shot-someone-that-was-confirmed-town-to-ME.
Empking (Town Watcher) has died!
Hiraki (Townie) has died!
NanookTheWolf (Townie) has died!
Even on day two, there was no way for me-as-scum or me-as-SK to know there were three NK's. I did speculate Day Two that scum kill was blocked, hiplop was an SK kill, and lew the vig kill, but this was the first actual proof of there being three killers. Hiraki was a town-read of mine; I would not have shot him as scum (he was primed as a GI-lead mislynch, if memory serves), nor would I have shot a townread as an SK. Meaning for me to be scum/SK, I'd have to shoot Empking (SK--no way would I shoot the guy I was intending to [mis]lynch the next day as scum!) or Nanook. Nanook would be a Mercy Kill regardless of SK or Scum, and would be a safe kill for either.
tl;dr, if I had a shooting power, I could only be scum if it were Nanook, though if I were the SK, it could be Nanook or Empking.
warriormode (Townie) has died!
zMuffinMan (Town Vigilante) has died!
Muffin's obviously a scum kill. I suppose this does fit with me-as-scum shooting Muffin, since Muffin was near the top of my town-reads. Warrior's either the SK or Vig kill. By now, the SK could kill whoever they want to, but they probably were aware by now that they couldn't get away with a vig claim, making this far more likely to be a vig shot than an SK-shot. Though Mastin-as-SK might have done it, anyway, since warrior was in my neutral list, perfect place to shoot.
hezlucky (Town Bodyguard) has died!
Amrun (Mafia Jailkeeper) has died!
I read this to mean that Hez died protecting someone and that he took Amrun down with him, not even thinking about the SK at the time. But it's probably more likely that Hez protected someone successfully, keeping them from death, and that this person was the scum NK. If Hez was simply shot instead of protecting someone as I assumed, well, then once more, it theoretically fits with me, since Hez was my strongest living townread at the time. Amrun obviously would be the SK-NK. Again, it does fit with mastin-as-SK shooting a neutral-leaning-scum-read, since the SK wanted scum dead just as much as town by that point.
sorgster (Townie) has died!
I can't see how sorgster could be a mastin-as-SK-kill. I can't rationalize it in any way. I'd still be aiming for scum, yet sorgster was one of only two people I knew wasn't. (The other being GreyICE.) If it were a Mastin-kill, it'd have to be Mastin-As-Scum, since I said it myself: Scum should be shooting for the SK, and the ONLY person cleared of being the SK was GreyICE, so even sorgster would be a suspect. Though that does beg the question as to why I wouldn't shoot CSL or chk (especially the latter), since they've both had far more questionable behavior than sorgster (especially the latter). I-as-scum obviously couldn't shoot either zdenek or edmund, since I-as-scum would be framing them as the last scum, preferably entering 3P lylo with one-or-both of them.
