Mini 1650: Greatest Idea Mafia (Game Over)

[KittyCupCake]

kiwi, I'm not the same alignment as anyone.

[kiwieagle]

But you have to be otherwise people wont trust my prophecies


Im going to vibe people out and say who is scum give me until tomorrow

[kiwieagle]

Also as far as I am concerned I have not been targeted

[Dechs Kaison]

VOTE: Kitty

[Kaboose]

VOTE: Kitty

[Dechs Kaison]

If I could distract everyone for a moment.

Hey Needful, I told you I'm always right. Well, I was wrong about you, but everything else seems spot on. Not bad for day one reads, don't ya think?

Spoiler:

90% Scum:

NeedfulThings

- Defended WW, made a terrible push on SC, switched gears as soon as there was pressure back on it, and went after the most quiet lurker with nothing but a meta-case. Highly emotional wording, frequent use of hyperbole and general manipulative language. Look at the case he made on me and notice the outright lie in it among other failings.

Whomping Willow

- I feel like I've made my case on him well enough by now, but basically the timing of his transition from doing stuff to trolling us and how it lined up with pressure he received, then his complete non-cooperativeness and not giving a single reason for anything he's done. He's caught scum and he had to govern himself to delay his hanging.

100% Town:

Prawneater

- Newb tell right away, claiming the weak cop because he read a wiki page for how to behave as town.

90%Town:
Copper223 - Always had a town lean to him, but I started feeling this strongly about him after our back and forth.

SovietCrocolisk

- Many little reasons. I like how his second head has been behaving. I can tell his first head is a newbie and was just floundering early, honest mistake. Needful being my primary scum pushing the lynch on him. The way he was on my case even right after I started tearing apart the SC case Needful made. All together, I'm very sure he's town.

Special cases:
Kiwi - He's either town or some kind of survivor. I believe the role he claimed is genuine, but his play matches a survivor better.
Guyett - I really like him. I can tell he's a good player. He knows what questions to ask and who to start asking. His only interactions are with me so far, though, so I don't have enough to read his alignment. I don't like his push on the strategy I know I've used as scum in this setup. Be careful with him, but definitely follow his leads. If he's leading a charge and you hang a townie for it, that's when you should be looking very hard at him. Otherwise, listen to this guy.

Town lean:

Soren

- Seems rather inexperienced, but genuine in attempts to participate, learn, and find scum. Tends to be weak on the mechanics and makes incorrect assumptions at times, but the intent is good. Poor results from Soren (unlike from Guyette) just imply incompetence, not manipulation.

Ika

I can't say anything about. No posts and no response to our pressure. It's unsettling, but I don't think there's reason to say Ika is more likely scum than town, just totally inactive.
Kaboose's posts have been short and few between. I can't be sure one way or the other.
Kitty I haven't been paying attention to. We haven't had a lot of interaction. No read.

Guile

is a combo of Kitty and Kaboose reasons for not having a read.

[Dechs Kaison]

Fun fact: I didn't shoot Soren.

Also, I have no idea what is going on in this game.

Then why'd you say you were going to?

(I think I know, but I'd like to hear it anyway.)

[Guyett]

Another short day:/

[Dechs Kaison]

Would you have done anything different?

[Guyett]

I wanted more info from people. Also I wanted to hammer

[Dechs Kaison]

Oh. Ok then.

Are you happy with the Kitty lynch and the plan to Kaboose lynch tomorrow?

[Guyett]

fine with me

[Guyett]

If the game isn't over by then you'll have to go

[Guyett]

Because if you are an Underdog you're now a Werewolf

[Dechs Kaison]

So, if I get the setup right, with 13 people, at least seven had to be town. Not Judas, not Survivor, not anything funny. Just Town.

That means at most six people are not-towns. I'm one of them. WW was one of them, Ika was one of them, and Kitty was one of them.

That leaves two more. Sure would suck if they were both werewolves and I was really an underdog, wouldn't it?

[Guyett]

That's why I didn't want an auto hammer here. Kitty is scum but there could be a larger scum team here that can win with kitty dead

[Guyett]

Myself and guile are town.

kiwi and copper are variables

[Zaicon]

This is the second time I've opened the Day shortly before I head to sleep and I find out a lynch happened before I woke up.

[Zaicon]

Final Vote Count - Day 3

KittyCupCake (4):

guille2015, copper223, Dechs Kaison, Kaboose

No Vote (3):

KittyCupCake, kiwieagle, Guyett

KittyCupCake,

Serial Killer Roleblocker

, has been lynched!

[Zaicon]

Guyett,

Town 2-Shot Bulletproof

, has been endgamed!
guille2015,

Town Roleblocker

, has been endgamed!
kiwieagle,

Town 1-Shot PGO

, has been endgamed!

copper223,

Werewolf Cop

, wins the game!
Kaboose,

Werewolf Mason Doctor

, wins the game!
Dechs Kaison,

Underdog

, wins the game!
(Pirate Ika also wins the game.)

[Zaicon]

Night 1 Actions

guille2015 roleblocks KittyCupCake.
NeedfulThings tracks KittyCupCake.
prawneater hides behind guille2015.
Soren sniffs out KittyCupCake.
Soviet Crocolisk heals kiwieagle.

Whomping Willow kills Guyett.

copper223 Mafia-investigates Whomping Willow.
Kaboose protects copper223.
copper223 kills NeedfulThings.

KittyCupCake roleblocks Dechs Kaison.
KittyCupCake kills guille2015.

Night 2 Actions

guille2015 roleblocks KittyCupCake.
prawneater hides behind Kaboose.
Soren sniffs out Kaboose.

copper223 Mafia-investigates KittyCupCake.
Kaboose protects copper223.
copper223 kills Soren.

KittyCupCake roleblocks Soren.
KittyCupCake kills Dechs Kaison.

Werewolf Thread
Dead Thread

[Dechs Kaison]

So uh. How did I not die to Kitty?

[Zaicon]

Kitty was roleblocked both nights.

Edit: Oh, I missed putting that line in there. Fixed.

[Dechs Kaison]

Ah. You just missed the Guile blocking him Night 2.

[copper223]

Good game all, I really wanted to play as town cop but got only mafia cards...