Mini 1258: Marionette Mafia (Over)

[redtail896]

Yeah, the fact that we never lynched Delta astounds me.

Two townie fakeclaims. Wow.

[Parama]

Also charter:
Thank you for burning your old book of scumhunting and using a new one starting after this game, because you did pretty damn awful in this game.
P.S.: When I disagree with you, it's not a scumtell

[dank]

Dank: who were you going to kill tonight? My guess was vijay.

It was going to be a tough choice. I'd leave vijay actually. It would have been between Panda and Hiraki, probably Panda. The number one goal was to keep someone alive who would cast the one vote Delta and I needed. Panda could do vijay, but Hiraki had even more of a shot to vote you right out the gate again, and we could capitalize.

What made you start to suspect me? I tried to play very solid town until today, where I needed to try to do enough to squeeze a vote out of one townie. Wondering if I did anything earlier that made you suspect me.

[don_johnson]

wow. well played scum. imo, you guys were hella obvious.

[DeltaWave]

When you first claimed Tracker, RP, I was so glad you didn't track me because I sent in the NK every night.

[dank]

Nab was Mafia roleblocker and did not visit kdowns that night. Funny enough, i pm'd mod to ask if this was a mod error since delta made the kill that night, but he said that he could now answer that. I was wondering why =P

[RedPanda]

When I saw that Nab claimed Roleblocker And vijay and Redtail believing it - i was like Wtf they have to be scum.

[Parama]

I didn't believe RP when he claimed Tracker
But I believed Nabnab even less

And I was right that both were full of crap, because I know how game balance works in these normal games. Oh well.

[redtail896]

I suspected you because you weren't dead. Delta's distancing from you was vicious, and that whole exchange early D1 left everybody feeling that you and Nab were town. I put you as blue in my VCA to see if anyone fought it, and everybody just kept ignoring you. And you didn't die. In any decent scum playbook, you should've been dead last night or maybe the night before. Had you survived one more night, I would've switched from Delta to you. The thing that shook it was actually RP's last day play.

Also: Nab, was your analysis of Hermano's playstyle genuine?

[dank]

Yeah, that was the biggest obstacle to my "obv-town" strategy. I tried to play a bit scummier the next few days, but my super-town image was already set. I was hoping we could get enough obv-NKs like kdowns random claim to protect me, but when we had to do the no-lynch, there was just no reason anymore for me to be alive. Panda may have actually saved us the game, as Delta and I would have easily died afterwards had you pushed this.

[LlamaFluff]

Vote Count

RedPanda (4) - NabakovNabakov, redtail896, dank, DeltaWave
NabakovNabakov (2) - RedPanda, Hiraki

Not Voting (1) - vijay2vasandani

RedPanda - Vanilla Townie - Lynched Day Four
redtail896 - Vanilla Townie - Endgamed
Hiraki - Vanilla Townie - Endgamed
vijay2vasandani - Vanilla Townie - Endgamed

NabakovNabakov - Mafia Roleblocker - Survived
dank - Mafia Goon - Survived
DeltaWave - Mafia Goon - Survived

Mafia Win

[LlamaFluff]

~Night One~

kdowns protects dank
don_johnsons kills hermanobro

Nabakov blocks hermanobro
Delta kills DJ

~Night Two~

kdowns protects dank

Nabakov blocks Parama
Delta kills kdowns

~Night Three~

Nabakov blocks Hiraki
dank kills Parama

[redtail896]

I was confident we could get 2, but the third would've been harder. I suspected NabNab less than you, and legitimately thought at one point that RP could've been the third.

I never seriously suspected Hiraki, and only a little bit vijay, but thought that if you knew that I would die. And I felt like the only sane person in the asylum sometimes.

I did legitimately think JoNo and/or Hermano were scum though. That whole thing threw me for a loop.

[dank]

Oh, and here's the QT:

http://www.quicktopic.com/46/H/5UJ2MXxW9RkF

[LlamaFluff]

Obvious lesson on why fakeclaiming as town is bad is obvious.

Thanks to everyone for sticking in it through the modflake, if it ever happens again don't be afraid to contact Papa Zito or any of the normal review team, its what we are here for.

[dank]

I did legitimately think JoNo and/or Hermano were scum though. That whole thing threw me for a loop.

That turned out to just be unfortunate (or fortunate for us ) luck. If Jono hadn't been the wagon directly after Hermano, I don't think he would have claimed. Hermano would have probably rescinded his claim whenever Jono needed to claim (or just would have been NKd as a VT), and would have stayed alive.

[dank]

EBWOP: and Jono would have stayed alive.

[DeltaWave]

The first two days were awesome. I love the hyperbussing that went on with Dank vs. myself early on.

[don_johnson]

nabnab was obv from day one, if hermano hadn't pulled that bs i would have shot that slot. dank and delta were pretty well hidden, but dw's unvote in lylo followed by dank's fencesit just gave them away. redtail should have been refreshing the screen at a faster rate.

[dank]

Yeah :3 , funny how it (along with the vijay/panda trails) was never even needed.

[dank]

Yeah, the fencesit was pretty obvious today, but I really didn't have any reason to explain why I would still be alive tomorrow, so I really wanted the game to end today.

[DeltaWave]

Yeah :3 , funny how it (along with the vijay/panda trails) was never even needed.

At least it was fun setting down those trails.

This is mostly in reference to how I agreed with everything Panda said always, and I would change my vote to match Panda's at all times. Also, when VV suggested I was scum, I would insist he was town while I would simultaneously blow up at dank.

[Parama]

and yes scum are gonna try to lynch me in MyLo or LyLo

which is why Hiraki is confirmed town

Oh hey scum QT sup

[redtail896]

nabnab was obv from day one, if hermano hadn't pulled that bs i would have shot that slot. dank and delta were pretty well hidden, but dw's unvote in lylo followed by dank's fencesit just gave them away. redtail should have been refreshing the screen at a faster rate.

I was, but I don't think I could've done it. They were too close together. They both showed up in basically 1 cycle.

I don't see the obv NabNab on D1 though.

[redtail896]

My other problem was that it never occurred to me that RP would be a townie faking. I figured at least one of them

had

to be scum. And I just couldn't believe that there were 2 protective roles.