Unfortunately Kison replaced in Night 2/Day 3, so he has only directly interacted with one of the two known scum.
His focus was on tubby from pretty much the beginning of the day, with a secondary line of questioning at Rage. The pressure on tubby before Day 3 had been almost non-existent, with only Adel calling him out, if I recall correctly, multiple times on the low contribution.
Kison wrote:I can't speak for others, but your defense of darkdude was what stood out most for me as I read the game.
Vote: Darkdude
(instead of Rage; corrected in next post)
This slip might be indicative of something; however I can't really figure out whether it's relevant at all. I can't really imagine scum confusing a scumpartner with an intended mislynch, but then again the only similarity between Rage and darkdude is the fact that they are both mentioned in the sentence before the vote. So nulltell or very vague towntell.
Kison points out that Adel unvotes tubby and votes IP ca. a hundred posts later, as an indication of Adel being connected to tubby; he tries casting suspicion in these two posts:
Kison wrote:insanepenguin02 wrote:Adel wrote:vote: insanepenguin02
the way you vote without reasoning is quite interesting. Setting up traps, continuing wagons, I don't know the reason behind this one, as I'm sure nobody else does either.
This is typical. See
this and
this.
afatchic wrote:Just an idea, but since right now it seems that tubby will be lynched, can everyone give their second suspect if:
a)Tubby is scum
b)Tubby is not scum
(A) Adel -> The second game I linked to above has Adel running her scumbuddy up to the verge of being lynched. When he (Surye) suddenly comes close to being lynched, she quickly jumps off and begins campaigning against someone else. (A) is the assumption that Tubby216 is scum, which would make :
Adel wrote:unvote
for unstated reasons.
a very familiar scene.
I would also go with Rage, because nothing about Tubby216 flipping scum really distinguishes my suspicion of him, but rather puts more on the table.
(B) Rage -> Tubby216 flipping town would land me back here.
The fact that Kison starts drawing the connection between tubby and Adel
after
I'd drawn attention to the possible pairing (I stated my theory in post 834, and Kison started making similar accusations in 836) implies slight opportunism at a chance to link a scumpartner to a townie--although the time zone difference may be the single reason for this. Going back through Kison's posts, on that day that both the mentioned posts were made (Jan 11, 2009) Kison's first post after my 834 is an hour later (my post: 9:17 PM GMT+1;
Kison's post: 10:07 PM GMT+1) and the last one before that is
seventeen hours before so there is nothing to imply that he'd been reading the forum before I had made that point--which doesn't mean that his accusation wasn't caused by my similar action. He also pushes the tubby-Adel theory with much more conviction after the tubby lynch than the day before.
--------------
This is tubby's final suspicion list:
tubby216 wrote:umm not sure i guess if i had to say
ip and thAdmiral
i think most pro town are adel and ecto
korts, rage and kison are pretty much middle of the road could go either way
Naturally his scumpartner isn't in the IP/ThAdmiral group of "suspected" scum; I would think tubby would put his remaining scupartner in the middle of the road more likely than as most pro-town after he'd consistently called darkdude a "confused townie" right up to darkdude's lynch. This, to me, implicates Kison slightly.
To be completely honest, there is very little to imply Kison as the last scum; his behaviour has been consistently pro-town and his interactions with tubby easily interpreted both ways. On the other hand, Adel's actions make me seriously doubt that she could be scum, therefore my choice is clear.
vote: Kison
Didn't really get anything done...
