Mini 1429 - Hunt in the Dungeon - Game Over

[don_johnson]

good game town! looks like the power roles made all the right moves. i was thinking that the vig kill sunk us. or at least me. but Mac wrapped the rest of it up nicely. oh well. i don't think we really made many mistakes, just a well played town game. nice job.

[Deltabacon]

Well played Town.

[mozamis]

woohoo a rare town win! Looks like a tough set up for scum, but since the game seems to waited against town anyway, maybe it was well balanced.
Thought Delta played well, looked v town until mac invesitgated him.
Thought scum should have least mentioned that a gunsmith's investigation is NOT AT ALL like a cops. Town has guns too...

[mozamis]

*seems to BE waited...
blinding performance (after day 1) by Mac though

[Deltabacon]

Yeah, kudos to Mac for hitting all 3 scum and getting us lynched, although I dare say that my defense wasn't particularly amazing. Was anyone actually unconvinced by Mac at any point?

[Bacde]

Yeah, kudos to Mac for hitting all 3 scum and getting us lynched, although I dare say that my defense wasn't particularly amazing. Was anyone actually unconvinced by Mac at any point?

I was reading and I considered you being town as a possibility

but it made more sense to lynch you first to test Mac's claim

[Slandaar]

Sorry Rev I confirmation bias too hard sometimes; I see where I went wrong though.

I like the setup and it seems fine balance wise; BG/Gunsmith/1shot vig with gunsmith getting 'guilty' results on both the other PR is nice.

also; I knew limo wasn't a watcher lol; I did assume Ztife was doc fake claiming VT in the end but eh; declan BG is same thing.

[Remembrance]

yay~ Good game guys.

[Remembrance]

Sorry for being wrong on Ztife and Limo. I tend to think fake doc soft claiming is scummy because I hold too hard to the wiki, curse of the newbie.

[Superdeclan]

whoo! well done freinds. setup seemed kind of unbalenced but hitting mafia on 3 days in a row is good

[Superdeclan]

delta played well too and was unlucky

[Deltabacon]

In retrospect I should have read the wiki and tried to find a legitimate gun-owning role to claim, but that'd have been limited in it's success given that there was already a claimed & confirmed Vig. Oh well, Kudos to everyone except Mac, methinks. Confirmation bias is a terrible, terrible thing. <3

[Mac]

As soon as Remembrance claimed bog, I knew i'd be alright for any guilties I got to be honest. Didn't expect a PGO or Cop, but in fairness Delta, once you claimed VT there was nothing you could do.

Also: Slandaar I was convinced you were scum, at the last moment I decided to inv. KBW. You suffer from terrible confirmation bias, dude

[Remembrance]

I had the opposite problem.

I had my shot set on Delta N1, then changed my mind because I meta'd him.

[Remembrance]

Yeah, kudos to Mac for hitting all 3 scum and getting us lynched, although I dare say that my defense wasn't particularly amazing. Was anyone actually unconvinced by Mac at any point?

I Isoed you to see if Mac was bullshiting me. Ultimately, I just went back to before Slandaar convinced me otherwise.

You definitely did the most convincing job of being town out of the scum team though.

[Superdeclan]

DJ doing a SK slip as mad was quite funny though

[Superdeclan]

ebwop mad = mafia

[Ztife]

GG =D

[Remembrance]

@The experienced players:

Usually, I don't ask this, but is there anything I can do to improve my scum hunting? I know this isn't a newbie game, so you don't have to give advice, but I want to get better.

[Bacde]

tbh I thought you played pretty well

The twitch vig kill might have been a mistake (compared to killing delta which you almost did), but without that twitch kill I wouldn't have been so confident that there was a vig in the game, which caused me to easily realize you were telling the truth, and that don_johnson was hiding something

So the scumhunting was decent imo, but our ability to form a powerful town bloc this game was ridiculously good

[Superdeclan]

tbh I thought you played pretty well

The twitch vig kill might have been a mistake (compared to killing delta which you almost did), but without that twitch kill I wouldn't have been so confident that there was a vig in the game, which caused me to easily realize you were telling the truth, and that don_johnson was hiding something

So the scumhunting was decent imo, but our ability to form a powerful town bloc this game was ridiculously good

The town block worked ridiculously well, I'm not experienced but I think you did well rem

[Revenus]

GG town


I'm still amazed that Slandaar is town.

[Slandaar]

Well I felt the same when you flipped it took me a while to see where I went wrong.

It might be good for you if you figure out why you were wrong on me (and no I do the intro stuff as scum also occasionally)

[Remembrance]

Thank you for the advice!

Do you guys (scum) mind if I read the scum chat?

[Deltabacon]

Go for it, I havent a problem with it. Has it been posted?