Mini 1741: Day 3

[Yimmy]

Garmr

was the lynch of

Day 2

.

He was a

Mafia goon

.

town wins and stuff

[Zoronos]

Yay we win town.

Yeah, that should have been rerolled. Kinda anticlimatic for my first game back after months.

[Yimmy]

I'm sorry about this. So when Lhix ruined everything I went over to N to figure out what to do, and he left it up to me. I really didn't want to abandon it, so I left it going. Later on I asked N again and he pointed out it was no worse at all. I've already requested for N to make a post explaining his decision, so that shojld happen soon
also you canxt reroll a closed setup

[Garmr]

That was bullshit i pretty much gave up. Also I wouldn't listen to N at all his one of the worst people to ask. Talk to jason about his experiences with N. This game was the worst mafia game I have played on the site so far.

[Garmr]

also that was horrible balancing with the mafia team you didn't give them a power role when town had a hider,bulletproof, and a watcher..

[Suzune]

Honestly, I did not like coming into the game into a slot that had cheated already. It placed such a bad flavour on the game and honestly if I had tricked everyone and the mafia won, it would have caused such an uproar. I have balance questions the town seemed so powerful and the mafia had no powers at all. I question the balance.

[Jake from State Farm]

also that was horrible balancing with the mafia team you didn't give them a power role when town had a hider,bulletproof, and a watcher..

Exact same setup was run and Mafia won so I disagree that it wasn't balanced.

forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=53&t=32114

[Jake from State Farm]

I still don't know how the exact same setup can be run. That should be prevented

[Suzune]

also that was horrible balancing with the mafia team you didn't give them a power role when town had a hider,bulletproof, and a watcher..

Exact same setup was run and Mafia won so I disagree that it wasn't balanced.

forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=53&t=32114

Perhaps the mafia team was at such a disadvantage this game because of the silly people we replaced in as. However, I find it questionable still.

[Jake from State Farm]

That was bullshit i pretty much gave up. Also I wouldn't listen to N at all his one of the worst people to ask. Talk to jason about his experiences with N. This game was the worst mafia game I have played on the site so far.

N is the list mod, he has no choice but to ask him

[Garmr]

Would of been nice for some acknowledgement of private messages like send a reply but instead you waited all till the end game to say anything. Suprised town didn't pick up on the fact I had mentioned private messages being sent to you a town member shouldn't know that and tbh I wouldn't care if they picked up on it. The way you handles things no pms to the scum team informing them whats happening with linx no response to pms poor job like even a sorry I can't take any action. You pretty much wasted my time.

[Garmr]

also that was horrible balancing with the mafia team you didn't give them a power role when town had a hider,bulletproof, and a watcher..

Exact same setup was run and Mafia won so I disagree that it wasn't balanced.

forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=53&t=32114

Just because a faction can win in a scenario doesn't mean it's balanced. That's like bringing a knife to a gun fight you can still kill the person with a knife but more than likely they will shoot you down first.

[Jake from State Farm]

The game is definitely balanced. The expected outcome of a hider isn't to successfully hide 3 times. You run this same setup multiple times and I bet Mafia still wins more. It's really easy to choose targets when 2/3 scum are exposed day 1

[Elyse]

Yeah this game was a shitshow

[RadiantCowbells]

why you kill me n1

WHY!?!?!?

[Garmr]

why you kill me n1

WHY!?!?!?

Because we thought you were the strongest player in the game at that point. Take it as a compliment.

[Garmr]

I was really tempted to call for mod action in the thread with keyser so the game would end but I was worried i'd get banned for it I really wish I did so I didn't have to go through this game. Replacing out would of been mean to the person replacing in. Should of terminated the game.

[RadiantCowbells]

I think you'd have been perfectly justified in doing so personally.

I do think I would have been on you super hard with Mathilda cleared because of your bizarre discrepancies day one

[Jake from State Farm]

So I want to know what happened with this mysteriously deleted post

[RadiantCowbells]

Also, have you seen my town play recently?

I'm doing awful nowadays.

[N]

Hello, Yimmy has asked me to come and speak about decision made during this game. At the time of TheLhix's banning, I was in discussion with Yimmy about whether to call the game off. He wanted to reroll, but as this is a closed setup that was unfeasible, so the two options he had were to abandon the game completely (and send me a new setup for review and be bumped to the head of the mini normal queue) or to continue. Yimmy's decision was to wait it out and see how the game progressed, although I gave him the go-ahead to call the game if he judged it to be too compromised.

Yimmy had a hard choice to make, and there would have been people complaining no matter what he chose.

[Jake from State Farm]

Nobody would have complained if he called it

[Suzune]

The trick became that it was near impossible to recover from the damage that was already created.

[Garmr]

Yeh I was just talking to other mods about it they would of all called it. Also no one would of complained if it ended due to linx exposing all his teammates (town didn't pick up on the expose on me but i sure did) Even alerted that to the mod in the pm.

[Garmr]

If linx is ever allowed back I will remember this game.