Open 487: Hard Boiled Day 3: A sinister Murder

[hp [leaves]]

HD and Marangal, I'm sorry for getting lynched so quickly and my dumb first post. It was a very bad move on my part.

[Malakittens]

HP. Everyone did well. I just feel we have strong people on the PRs and with Dino getting the plan right off the bat made everything a lot more stronger. If Dino survived I wouldn't have crumbed.

I think if another player got hider rather then the hydra things could have been different.

[RachMarie]

Orc was clearly as Nacho would put it "town as fuck".

The scum team was handicapped by so much replacing especially early on when they were trying to get things together.

Dino's plan worked beautifully.

Mala and Mollie totally ROCK ♥

I was kinda meh...

I understand HD's frustration, and MM usually holds it together better than that.. So yeah I could see this going the other way, especially had hp, HD, and MM been together from the get go. So please dont be too upset scum team, it was a lot to overcome.

Love playing with you all and sorry for blowing it with my early PR claim... I shoulda double checked the votes first.

One caveat is Orc dont always tunnel so hard on me Take a deep breath and really read my posts lol. Still ♥ you though.

[The Acting Method]

Marangal is horrible when it comes to lying, no matter what alignment. In a Defy she fakeclaimed a certain sanity, then switched around mid day. I swear between her and the other townie (who did a more successful lie that was still terribad.) Town almost lost the game.

Also, for those who asked, Marangal's actions was the reason I was so pissed when putting up the lynch post Night 1.

Also, thank you to those of you who confirmed properly on the first try. I probably should have replaced Freshmaniscoolman sooner, but he had PM'ed me... But didn't follow the instructions in the Role PM on confirming I'm a stickler for that

I'm definitely going to make some alterations to my rulesets for future games for certain.

[Mathdino]

Well this is awkward. A lot of you are going to write me off as a VI for this... but I actually forgot to shoot.

But yeah, good game guys! I'm not really sure about the HB setup at this point, as others have said it's incredibly easy to break.

[Mathdino]

I knew I was done when I started randomly switching suspicions back there. That was me reading through Marangal's posts along with a few other players looking for connections. It got really obvious when I started being all secretive about why I was switching.

[RachMarie]

Still would love to play with you again sometime Dino

It is a learning process I have been playing on this site for a bit over a year and I STILL have tons to learn...

[Mr E Roll]

@Mathdino, I’m certainly not going to write you off as VI for not shooting

And I think you handled MsM’s claim just about perfect. If you had immediately counter claimed the conversation would have immediately shifted to a confrontation between you and her. Because you didn’t do that you allowed connections to be established that helped town quickly find the remaining scum.

You didn’t believe her because you knew she was fake claiming.

Hp and Hd didn’t believe her because they were her scum partners.

post_id=4859753 time=1365571987 user_id=10128 post_num=583]I get the vibes that you're not believing MM's claim here. Why is that? Why not lynch you and then vig RM?

Here Hp is rolefishing for the real tracker.

MM if you pick vig please don't vig me or anyone on my town list (which I plan to finish later today if I have time)

Here HD is trying to act like he believes her but it becomes obvious that he doesn’t when he never bothers to get around to finishing his town list since he knew MsM wouldn’t actually be vigging anybody.

[Mathdino]

I won't doubt that I kind of owned Day 1, but that night I completely derped out. Was gonna shoot Marangal but I basically fell asleep before the deadline.

Likewise, Rach. Probably enjoyed playing with you and Leaf most throughout.

Honestly, Marangal, if I were you, I'd have kept quiet about my being V/T, shot me at night and let yourself get lynched the next day. I was gonna follow the plan and go tracker if I had no reason to believe I'd be shot. In the end you basically gave us a few conftowns at the end of that day when I was making small talk. I was laughing so hard at when you were going all out WIFOM on starttransmission and Nekoko during twilight.

[The Acting Method]

Trust Me Mathdino, Marangal knows she was stupid with it. Marangal is Horrible when it comes to gambits like that.

[Piratecat]

It's fine Dino. You did well. <3

[The Acting Method]

Mathdino, I knew that was probably your plan while Marangal was pretending to have your role. I don't think I've yelled at her after so much since she fake claimed an investigation as town in a Dethy.

[RachMarie]

So do you two like know each other in RL?

[Ms Marangal]

... lol, no we don't I met him on another site and he brought me here

[The Acting Method]

What Marangal said, I mod the n00b games on said other site, and she was one of my n00bs. Though technically I think I dragged her into Mafia playing itself...

[LlamaFluff]

end