Open 555 - Pick Your Poison (Game Over!)

[RachMarie]

SG do you have to be NKed for that power to work? or does it work if you are lynched. It is a strange claim, though we had something similar in a game I played on my Twin Flames hydra with NS, however that was a very strange setup and was bastard.

Also to whom do you popcorn?

[Knell]

Ummmmmmmm

[Knell]

Rach you do realize you talked about the set up and know it quite well. So why the change in level of ignorance?

[RachMarie]

uggh wrong game

sorry not been awake for long when I posted that?

[Knell]

Why's that a question?

[RachMarie]

VOTE: SG

That is not a role in this game setup

[Knell]

[Knell]

Claim: Cutest necromancer that I ever did see

I have the ability to, by dying, talk to the dead.

Some people call this VT - but I'm a rebel.

Okay, with Red cleared, that pretty much takes me to AGar,

Neil

, Victor, Rach, Sharpest as my scumpool (others may adjust as needed) I don't think

Neil

or Victor are it. Like, I really don't. I find Cxin pretty good too, as described earlier. Wasn't really a counter, but...it felt like a flip that Neil was okay with. I really don't actually think it's Sharpest, but will admit my reasons for clearing him are not as solid as the other three so maybe I'm wrong.

uggh wrong game

sorry not been awake for long when I posted that?

Why's that a question?

[Knell]

Why is this the wrong game? It looks like the right one to me.

[AGar]

VOTE: SG

That is not a role in this game setup

Ok yeah.

VOTE: RachMarie

[reinoe]

uggh wrong game

You and Sharpest are hilarious OMG.

[RachMarie]

I thought she was true claiming because I am in theme games a lot. Then I realized wrong game because this is Pick your Poison setup, duh.

There is no necromancer role in this setup.

[VictorDeAngelo]

I'm claiming vt. No clue where the order is but frankly if there's a cc for Red or anyone else they can just say. Given how dumb it would be for scum to cc at stage I reckon not. Red, Knell, Reinoe for town. That leaves close to winning.

As dumb as what Rach did, I don't see that as the kind of derp move scum would make. I'm moving towards lynching Skot today.

VOTE: Sharest-Knife-On-Tree

[Knell]

I thought she was true claiming because I am in theme games a lot. Then I realized wrong game because this is Pick your Poison setup, duh.

There is no necromancer role in this setup.

Yes. She claimed VT in the bolded section of my quote wall. She was claiming necromancer as a joke, it was related to her dying and being sent to the dead quick topic where both town and scum are sent to actually. But town are sent there too so no biggy. You don't seem very serious about your vote anyway.

[Knell]

I'm claiming vt. No clue where the order is but frankly if there's a cc for Red or anyone else they can just say. Given how dumb it would be for scum to cc at stage I reckon not. Red, Knell, Reinoe for town. That leaves close to winning.

As dumb as what Rach did, I don't see that as the kind of derp move scum would make. I'm moving towards lynching Skot today.

VOTE: Sharest-Knife-On-Tree

So you think scum wouldn't try to fake not knowing the set up and when called out on it say they were confused and thought it was a different game. Then, continuing on in their misinterpretation of the player's original post, act as they think town would act and vote Squirrel because she claimed a role that didn't exist in an open set up (which is open to squirrel girl too) without thinking it through entirely?

Because I recall the other two scum stating if we lynched two people it would be "GG" as a lazy town slip. Nothing in Rach's post indicates she thinks we won here. Though, I did want to ask RC if she were open to discussing who he would vig tonight.

[VictorDeAngelo]

I know scum fake townslips but I can't really see scum faking like that. It's attention grabbing and reckless and I think scum might not try anything too risky in this position. I also think scum would be quicker to back down in this situations and try and instead Rach followed with a vote.

[singersigner]

Votecount

RachMarie (3) - Knell, Sharpest-Knife-On-Tree, AGar
Squirrel Girl (2) - RedCoyote, RachMarie
Sharpest-Knife-On-Tree (1) - VictorDeAngelo


not voting (2) - reinoe, Squirrel Girl

With 8 alive it takes 5 to lynch.

[Squirrel Girl]

@AGar - you're all like 'Neil would fear a PR claim from Rach' but...like, what? Scum knew what the PRs were.

They knew what, not who.

It's literally just the smartest play given what the claims said. If scum wanted to out the cop, Neil would have claimed cop from the get-go. That way, the actual cop counterclaims, and they get to kill him. Kill two birds with one stone - no confirmed innocent outside of the IC. Neil's claim was completely survival motivated. 3 scum lived. They wanted to get the easiest win possible. You don't do that by risking a claim being torn apart by a result claim gone awry.

This making sense, SG?

Maybe, except clearly the goal was survival, but there was limited risk in the investigation, and, worst case, it would be the same as claiming cop. Pretty good odds, really.

As a counter point - it would be highly likely for a cop claim Day 2, paired with a Vig and Neil's claim - any claim was really just an attempt to buy a day or two at *best*.

[Squirrel Girl]

VOTE: SG

That is not a role in this game setup

You are correct, it is not. I still don't understand what you're doing though.

[AGar]

@AGar - you're all like 'Neil would fear a PR claim from Rach' but...like, what? Scum knew what the PRs were.

They knew what, not who.

It's literally just the smartest play given what the claims said. If scum wanted to out the cop, Neil would have claimed cop from the get-go. That way, the actual cop counterclaims, and they get to kill him. Kill two birds with one stone - no confirmed innocent outside of the IC. Neil's claim was completely survival motivated. 3 scum lived. They wanted to get the easiest win possible. You don't do that by risking a claim being torn apart by a result claim gone awry.

This making sense, SG?

Maybe, except clearly the goal was survival, but there was limited risk in the investigation, and, worst case, it would be the same as claiming cop. Pretty good odds, really.

As a counter point - it would be highly likely for a cop claim Day 2, paired with a Vig and Neil's claim - any claim was really just an attempt to buy a day or two at *best*.

Serious questions:

How many games as scum have you played on site?
How many of those have you won?

[Knell]

2 games. She's 1 for 1

[Squirrel Girl]

How many games as scum have you played on site?
How many of those have you won?

Serious answer - I doubt this actually answers my question to you.

[AGar]

It actually helps me answer your question.

[Squirrel Girl]

The question was answered by someone else, also, as an alt, I don;'t care to discuss anything else about other account's history but I'll just say 'I've done okay as scum and have certainly enough experience playing as scum to not be considered a newb.'

Now can you answer my question?

[RedCoyote]

SG is funny. I love that claim. She has won me over.

UNVOTE: Squirrel Girl; VOTE: RachMarie