Mini 1500:Narnia- The Lion,the Witch,and the Wardrobe Mafia

[ArcAngel9]

I must say that Scum played well.. They made few strange choices but it worked well for them.
Best Example: Killing Broken Aquarium on Night 2 when they should be killing claimed cop projectmatt

Town played bit poor game, Starting with inactivity..and i really wish to know why peacebringer want to jail keep Rachmaire when he has a cop. he could have saved projectmatt on night 3

[Garmr]

@Chamber
No it's not i read my email and I couldn't figure it out. I even sent a pm to the mod ask who my partners were.

Its in your ROLE PM sweets

It was a well earned win anyway.

Also the silence was one shot from the joat. I see a lot of complaining

[ArcAngel9]

Garmr
10-16-2013
05:30 AM ET (US)
Fun fact for the first half of the day I didn't know who was scum or not because I didn't read my role mail fully. So i had a guess at the player i thought would scum and left them alone. I guessed right through I had three guess's

This is cheating....

nah, Garmr didn't read his role PM completely until mid of day 1 i guess.

Oh moz was the only one who could have won this for the town. He would have given us a run for our money, especially looking at the Dead QT.

Also, AA, I loved the flavor! Really well done on that, although I'm sure it was difficult for you.

thank you
it wasn't hard. i was quite occupied last month so got behind with it for couple of times.

[chamber]

Silencers are typically used in face to face games, where the 'joke' is to get people to have to play charades instead of communicating normally. Using them to completely remove communication is horrible. You can complain about me complaining when you've had it done to you. And I don't take cheating lightly.

[chamber]

nah, Garmr didn't read his role PM completely until mid of day 1 i guess.

Which is cheating.

[Garmr]

@Arc
killing BA was all planned from the start you gave us a lot of information from the town roles from the joat power.

The Joat had a strong man meaning we knew there was a doctor and he would most likely be protecting the inspector.
BA silence was to set up JKLM we planned to kill him during the night and waste a investigation from matt(We thought he had more). But the fact BA was doctor was a plus.

@chamber
If you felt like it was cheating sorry it was unintentional. Even through it's not cheating or against the rules.

[ArcAngel9]

nah, Garmr didn't read his role PM completely until mid of day 1 i guess.

Which is cheating.

Not really dear, if someone not paying attention to their role pm or QT, doesn't make them cheaters, it will make them lazy and it doesn't impact to the game in anyway.

[ArcAngel9]

@Arc
killing BA was all planned from the start you gave us a lot of information from the town roles from the joat power.

The Joat had a strong man meaning we knew there was a doctor and he would most likely be protecting the inspector.
BA silence was to set up JKLM we planned to kill him during the night and waste a investigation from matt(We thought he had more). But the fact BA was doctor was a plus.

@chamber
If you felt like it was cheating sorry it was unintentional. Even through it's not cheating or against the rules.

town had two protecting roles. odd night Jailkeeper and Doctor. 1 shot strongman may work for anyone of them.

[Skelda]

Chamber, it wasn't like he didn't know he was scum.

[Skelda]

Silencers are typically used in face to face games, where the 'joke' is to get people to have to play charades instead of communicating normally. Using them to completely remove communication is horrible. You can complain about me complaining when you've had it done to you. And I don't take cheating lightly.

Yeah, I'm sorry about that. Really must stink, actually.

I was sad that Hermy died so early. I would much rather Garmr or I had JOAT.

[Garmr]

I think role cop was vital through more so than joat

[Garmr]

Also me being protective over rachmarie was done for three reasons.

I wanted people to link me with her.
I actually felt sorry for her because she was busy and and was flaking undeserved scum reads.
I wanted to keep smarg alive with her as well. Both were convinced the other was scum and it must of been fraustrating to not see your scum read get lynched.

Also I voted skelda right off the bat to distance myself from him.

[Skelda]

I think role cop was vital through more so than joat

Yeah, knowing smarg was a Miller early on was useful.

[mozamis]

Would like to give a special mention to moz. He had me scared so I had to kill him .

Was it my last post that worried you? You're sudden sheeping of my read made me suspicious of you for the first time in the game. And then I was dead...I then ranted at you in the dead qt lol Sad to say though, I changed my mind, and in the end went for KJ and Skelda, and then Kj...arse.
But well played scum!
I guess it was as simple as "why the fudge would scum leave the tracker alive".

AND DAMNIT I KNEW THAT FIRST POST FROM SKELDA WAS FRIENDLY SCUM!

But yeah, you both played really well, congrats

Loved this game, I was really into it. Thanks ArcAngel

[mozamis]

Oh, and for the record I thought towns activity, especially the last day was pathetic. Sorry -you all seem nice people and all -but where was the questioning, the thinking , the debating.
Scum played well, but town could have tried a bit more.

[Garmr]

you know you could of verified smargs claim to some extent by her reaction to hermy claiming miller. Probably nailed skelda as well from his reaction to miller question from hermy. Also I crumbed in that I was rolecop and back up cop just in case I wanted to lynch smarg on the spot. Finding those things and linking them together would of gave town a win. Day 2 was a very vital day.

[mozamis]

Also I crumbed in that I was rolecop and back up cop just in case I wanted to lynch smarg on the spot

Er, I don't follow you, what do you mean?

But when all is said and done, Garmr, I think you played really, really well. Apart from late suspicion of you -which i changed anyway - i thought you looked very town all game. Well played damn you lol

[Skelda]

Moz, I really do like being friendly in first posts. But yeah... I agree, Garmr was amazing.

[mozamis]

@ Skelda - did you really not know that Matt claimed cop? I think it was around then that I lost suspicion of you. On the basis that scum wouldn't miss a PR claim...Did you miss it, or good acting from you?

[Skelda]

you know you could of verified smargs claim to some extent by her reaction to hermy claiming miller. Probably nailed skelda as well from his reaction to miller question from hermy. Also I crumbed in that I was rolecop and back up cop just in case I wanted to lynch smarg on the spot. Finding those things and linking them together would of gave town a win. Day 2 was a very vital day.

Haha, I'm confused by this. I doubt they would have bought a rolecop claim if there was a 1-shot Cop anyway.

[Skelda]

@ Skelda - did you really not know that Matt claimed cop? I think it was around then that I lost suspicion of you. On the basis that scum wouldn't miss a PR claim...Did you miss it, or good acting from you?

Nope, I genuinely missed it. But I did play it up once I realized I'd missed it.

[projectmatt]

Oh well. Thanks for modding ArcAngel. By the way, I didn't actually investigate Broken Aquarium (I was a 1-shot and I used it on Hermy) but it was just an attempt to have the scum think I was more powerful than I actually was and hopefully pave the way for any other power role still in play.

[ArcAngel9]

Thank you everyone!!!
My next theme is coming up soon. Its based on Duck Tales Series.
Hope to see you all again in Duck Tales

[RachMarie]

Sorry about the tunneling smarg

Seemed a tad unbalianced though. I did say Skelda was likely scum, I guess I should have pushed that read more, but it was more gut than solid logic

[Garmr]

Why be sorry for the tunneling I was encouraging it from both of you .