Mini 1492: Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets GAME OVER

[penguin_alien]

I guess I want to talk about this a little longer, but I think I'm alone in that.

You said you liked your town-Amrun read, IIRC. To the point where you'd put her as town above me, Nacho, and JW. Is there any combination of scum in that group of three that makes sense, given the claims?

That leaves you, JS, and RachMarie. What's your take on the tracker claim? Does it fit with one side or the other to you?

[fferyllt]

I guess I want to talk about this a little longer, but I think I'm alone in that.

You said you liked your town-Amrun read, IIRC. To the point where you'd put her as town above me, Nacho, and JW. Is there any combination of scum in that group of three that makes sense, given the claims?

That leaves you, JS, and RachMarie. What's your take on the tracker claim? Does it fit with one side or the other to you?

The three PR claims are cross validated. It's freaking me out a little balance-wise, though.

We know the scum team had a JOAT. I assume they have enough to counterbalance the town roles, including the potential for there to have been a treestump.

[fferyllt]

And I have no choice but to doubt my Amrun read now, unless one of the claimed PRs is scum.

[JacobSavage]

iN my view it has to be Rach, and Amrun personally,

[Nachomamma8]

Heh.

I think this is autowin, then.

The three PR claims are cross validated. It's freaking me out a little balance-wise, though.

And I have no choice but to doubt my Amrun read now, unless one of the claimed PRs is scum.

What on earth is this line of thought?

[Nachomamma8]

Half of me is kind of like it could easily be RM / Nacho but that doesn't really feel right.

The paranoid part says JW /Nacho.

iN my view it has to be Rach, and Amrun personally,

[Nexus]

Votecount 4.2:

JacobSavage (3)-

Nachomamma8, RachMarie, Amrun

Not voting (4)-

fferyllt, penguin_alien, JacobSavage, JasonWazza

With 7 alive it takes 4 to lynch. Deadline is at 9pm BST on Thursday 24th October 2013

Finding a replacement for JasonWazza.

[fferyllt]

Heh.

I think this is autowin, then.

The three PR claims are cross validated. It's freaking me out a little balance-wise, though.

And I have no choice but to doubt my Amrun read now, unless one of the claimed PRs is scum.

What on earth is this line of thought?

The sentiments in the first quote could be premature.

Otherwise I think it's pretty obvious.

Town: JasonWazza, Nacho, Rach, PA - by virtue of the PR claims and results.

Scum: JacobSavage and Amrun (and me, from your point of view)

Unless there is a problem with the first group.

What does this do you

your

Amrun read, and how comfortable are you with the town group?

[Nachomamma8]

The only thing that could possibly be accomplished is if there is some reason to doubt any of the PRs. Rach would have to be a scum tracker who followed me not once, but TWICE after she found me going nowhere the first time. This makes absolutely no sense.

Jason would have to be a scum Voyeur (unless Nexus gave the scumteam two Scum JOATS, which is a hell no type of situation), who ended up counterclaiming his partner after being run up immediately after him, and also had Stubbs claiming a strong JOAT while he claimed a more reasonable weak JOAT.

Nacho-scum requires me not using my rolecop N2 (while killing a fruit vendor) and partners not submitting it for me, then pretty much forcing myself to clear her and not looking for power roles anywhere else although we would be expecting a town more powerful than fruit vendor/JOAT. It also requires pseudo strongman and rolecop and scum JOAT against a three close to useless roles and a tracker, which seems like shitty balance to me.

PA is town unless the pseudo strongman is also a ninja, which is also ridiculously unbalanced.

[Nachomamma8]

What does this do you your Amrun read, and how comfortable are you with the town group?

My amrun townread is holding up better than my townread on you.
I'd expect you to be either A) confident in autowin and moving things along, or B) attacking the cleared group in a way that makes sense. You've been throwing vague suspicion around constantly, but nothing overly impressive/worrisome.

[fferyllt]

Ok. so it comes down to Amrun or me then. And from your perspective we're on autowin?

[Nachomamma8]

Yep.

[fferyllt]

Good.

VOTE: JacobSavage

[Nexus]

Votecount 4.3:

JacobSavage (4-LYNCH)-

Nachomamma8, RachMarie, Amrun, fferyllt

Not voting ()-

penguin_alien, JacobSavage, JasonWazza

With 7 alive it takes 4 to lynch. Deadline is at 9pm BST on Thursday 24th October 2013

Finding a replacement for JasonWazza.

JacobSavage - Penelope Clearwater - Hogwarts-aligned Townie - Lynched Day 4

Night 4 now begins. It will end in 48 hours, at 5pm BST on Monday 21st October 2013

[Nexus]

Lucky2u replaces JasonWazza

Deadline remains the same.

[Nexus]

RachMarie - Aragog - town-aligned Tracker - Petrified Night 4

Day 5 now begins. With 5 alive it takes 3 to lynch. Deadline ends at 3pm on Monday 4th November 2013

[Lucky2u]

Children out of bed! Children in the corridors! I'm getting my manacles and I will hang you kids by your thumbs!

[fferyllt]

Hi Lucky. Are you caught up?

[Lucky2u]

I skimmed, but just for fun (and so I can test the scummy waters) what's everyone's view of what's happened?

[Nachomamma8]

fferyllt is not a malfoy.
lucky:

The only thing that could possibly be accomplished is if there is some reason to doubt any of the PRs. Rach would have to be a scum tracker who followed me not once, but TWICE after she found me going nowhere the first time. This makes absolutely no sense.

Jason would have to be a scum Voyeur (unless Nexus gave the scumteam two Scum JOATS, which is a hell no type of situation), who ended up counterclaiming his partner after being run up immediately after him, and also had Stubbs claiming a strong JOAT while he claimed a more reasonable weak JOAT.

Nacho-scum requires me not using my rolecop N2 (while killing a fruit vendor) and partners not submitting it for me, then pretty much forcing myself to clear her and not looking for power roles anywhere else although we would be expecting a town more powerful than fruit vendor/JOAT. It also requires pseudo strongman and rolecop and scum JOAT against a three close to useless roles and a tracker, which seems like shitty balance to me.

PA is town unless the pseudo strongman is also a ninja, which is also ridiculously unbalanced.

the relevant bit is that pa/you/me are all pretty much confirmed town except in ridiculous scenarios, and amrun/fferyllt are the scumteam.

Vote: Amrun

and I think I'm going to lynch Amrun first so that I have more time to talk to ffery-scum who was probably amazed that I was reading her wrong this game.

[penguin_alien]

How do you feel about letting fferyllt-scum be amazed from the dead thread?

[Nachomamma8]

I feel perfectly fine about it.

[RachMarie]

Please read the rules next time. It's not difficult.

[penguin_alien]

I'm tempted to go for the autowin except that I'm not 100% on Nacho. Feeling paranoid, but Amrun must be a Malfoy, given the Draco claim that could be a fakeclaim for Lucius. If it's a specific cop for one Mafia member, with zero chances of a false positive, it's not a bad role.

Before RachMarie claimed Tracker, Nacho would have had three choices for lynches for town to follow from fferyllt, RachMarie, Amrun even today after getting JS strung up. If Nacho's scum and one of those is a partner, it makes it easy to direct the 5p LyLo lynch onto a target of his choosing. His willingness to change to fferyllt is encouraging. I need to sleep on this.

[Lucky2u]

It's not Amrun unless she is a ninja. I used my reporter last night on her and she was home so she wasn't out killing.