Mini 1578: Lord of the Rings!! - GaME OVeR

[Dr Pants]

Nice Dr. P, I see you've updated your wiki. We've got some impressive stats for a couple of newbs who don't know anything

our scum game is still probably the most fun I've had in a game

[RachMarie]

yeah I did not get that whole newbie thingy after all Toasty has been around longer than I have?

[ProHawk]

Thanks for the game guys! I guess someone has to be the N1 kill... haha

[RachMarie]

And I was looking forward to playing with you too, Hawk, hopefully next game together we might have more time together.

[Protogonos]

I honestly thought that after D1 bulba & aronis will be SPEEDFUCKINGLYNCHED. I couldn't believe how you guys ignored the fact that they got him to L-2 and 1 AFTER his powerful claim...

I was scumreading Bulb and Aronis kind off. But then I got sidetracked by 32M after the horrible Drew quicklynch. I would have pushed for Bulb hardcore Day 4 had he not been vigged.

[Protogonos]

And I still maintain that NLing was the right play both of those days.

[Guyett]

I disagree :shrug:

[Protogonos]

I am clearly more risk-averse than you are.

[Guyett]

[RachMarie]

i have to admit I generally go for NL in MYLO

[Guyett]

It was pointless NL in this case imo. There was a massclaim and no investigative roles in the game so no new information was to be found out over night.

[snscompt1]

Maaaan you got the quote wrong

And yeah, NLing in MyLo is good...unless you have someone who is conftown AND a doublevoter lol. Hm. Like Guyett maybe? No lynching wouldve been bad.

[Guyett]

lol woops

[shos]

NLing in that mylo would be entirely useless. you guys had just 1 conftown, which is guyett, and no PRs, so what benefit will it do? it'll just help scum quickhammer if any error is made, and give town one less thinking mind.

[Protogonos]

Except that additional players require good judgment to be positive utility. Fortunately, that was the case this game.

[Protogonos]

And clearly Guyett's conftown status was not enough to get him NKed after FH was lynched, so you never know. And we could have NLed instead of lynching FH. That would have been interesting as well.

[Guyett]

And clearly Guyett's conftown status was not enough to get him NKed after FH was lynched, so you never know. And we could have NLed instead of lynching FH. That would have been interesting as well.

NL with 4 left means I die and you go into tomorrow with {proto, aronis and rach}.... Its still the same decision that has to be made only you are delaying it for no reason

[Fail Hydra]

In hindsight we should have replaced out. I don't do scum games, and Piggy was done with this game by the end of day 1 with that terrible self-hammer before half the players even had a chance to speak. There was a moment -I think around day 3- where the two of us got into an argument over who should make the prod-dodge post, because neither of us even wanted to do

that

. This was an incredibly frustrating game where almost no one ever made cases, and the players that did make cases got blatantly ignored for more OMGUS and gut feeling and massive hard-on tunneling that just HAPPENED to be right this game.

[RachMarie]

oh I understand in this case, but I am glad you were the double voter and not me

[Fail Hydra]

And clearly Guyett's conftown status was not enough to get him NKed after FH was lynched, so you never know. And we could have NLed instead of lynching FH. That would have been interesting as well.

If you had NLed we would have vanillaized Guyett and probably no-killed, pending any conflicting thoughts from Aronis. Lynching us was the better choice.

[Drew-Sta]

Good game all.

Picked Aronis, thought guy was mafia (bad hunch) and fell for Bulba's play on Proto (fooled again).

1/3 ain't bad :p

[shos]

1/3 ain't bad :p

it kinda is

see, if you're in a 12p game as town, choosing randomly a player would result in 1/4...choosing a random 3 and getting 0/3 has chances of...21/55=38%...so basically, if you choose randomly at gamestart, your chances of getting 1/3 or better are 1.6 times larger than your chances to get worse............

so that's bad.

[Toogeloo]

Don't feel bad Drew. My only

slight

scum read was Fail Hydra.

In all honesty I would not have voted you had you not claimed the ability to change to Independent. Sometimes you shouldn't be totally truthful about your claim lol.

[Drew-Sta]

1/3 ain't bad :p

it kinda is

see, if you're in a 12p game as town, choosing randomly a player would result in 1/4...choosing a random 3 and getting 0/3 has chances of...21/55=38%...so basically, if you choose randomly at gamestart, your chances of getting 1/3 or better are 1.6 times larger than your chances to get worse............

so that's bad.

Way to make me feel shit. I might need to go grab a glass of Drambuie now

It was a good game for me to learn, TBH. Some fairly experienced players here who know how to play the game so I'm glad I had the experience of the game.

Don't feel bad Drew. My only

slight

scum read was Fail Hydra.

In all honesty I would not have voted you had you not claimed the ability to change to Independent. Sometimes you shouldn't be totally truthful about your claim lol.

True. That

was

a pretty stupid thing to do. Live and learn

[shos]

well, scum played pretty well up until the vigging, you shouldn't blame yourself
also town was very bad until that time too