Open 80 - Double Day Mafia (Game Over!)

[SpyreX]

Arm - for the list (I thought it was kinda clear): FaerieLord, Firestarter, K7

I WANT MY BABY BACK BABY BACK BABY BACK...

killa seven - 5 (Knight of Cydonia, SpyreX, Corinthian, orangepenguin, Joubert)
Corinthian - 4 (StrangerCoug, LlamaFluff, Firestarter, TheSweatpantsNinja)
Manito - 2 (FaerieLord, killa seven)
Firestarter - 2 (armlx, CF Riot)
FaerieLord - 1 (Manito)
armlx - 1 (LaptopGun)

15 alive, 8 to lynch, 5 at deadline.

-Mod

[FaerieLord]

My list? - Corin, Manito, Firestarter

[LaptopGun]

So arm, you're just going to deny that my belief applies to you? Sounds an awful lot like Corin and Joubert. ANd I don't see how you can say that. You can say whatever you want to think about K7 right now because that's not required to throw him under the bus later. You indicate he's worth some scrutiny, "only later."

[Corinthian]

All right, here's my list:

K7, FaerieLord, Firestarter

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

I'd say we should be very careful in deciding who we lynch based on the list. I mean, this is not a difficult thing for scum to manipulate.

That said:
1. Corinthian
2. Firestarter
3. K7

[LlamaFluff]

armlx -> Firestarter, CF Riot, K7
Joubert
killa seven
FaerieLord -> Corin, Manito, Firestarter
SpyreX -> FaerieLord, Firestarter, K7
LlamaFluff -> Corin, Manito, KoC
Firestarter
CF Riot
Corinthian - K7, FaerieLord, Firestarter
LaptopGun -> armlx, Corin, Joubert/KoC
Knight of Cydonia
TheSweatpantsNinja -> Corin, Firestarter, K7
orangepenguin -> killa7, FaerieLord, KoC/Corin
Manito
StrangerCoug -> Corinthian, killa seven, FaerieLord

Six more people to go

[armlx]

So arm, you're just going to deny that my belief applies to you? Sounds an awful lot like Corin and Joubert. ANd I don't see how you can say that. You can say whatever you want to think about K7 right now because that's not required to throw him under the bus later. You indicate he's worth some scrutiny, "only later."

No, I'm proving your premises wrong and therefore showing your theory does not apply.

Your last sentences also make it look like whatever I say, its scummy based on actions I have yet to even come close to making.

[Firestarter]

armlx -> Firestarter, CF Riot, K7
Joubert
killa seven
FaerieLord -> Corin, Manito, Firestarter
SpyreX -> FaerieLord, Firestarter, K7
LlamaFluff -> Corin, Manito, KoC

Firestarter -> Corin, K7, Manito

CF Riot
Corinthian - K7, FaerieLord, Firestarter
LaptopGun -> armlx, Corin, Joubert/KoC
Knight of Cydonia
TheSweatpantsNinja -> Corin, Firestarter, K7
orangepenguin -> killa7, FaerieLord, KoC/Corin
Manito
StrangerCoug -> Corinthian, killa seven, FaerieLord

I would have had armlx in 3rd place a week back, but there are other fish to fry before him, imo.

Oh, and apologies on my last post, tooooo many people are in the same games as me

[armlx]

I'd say we should be very careful in deciding who we lynch based on the list. I mean, this is not a difficult thing for scum to manipulate.

This is true, this list should be in no way used to directly lynch anyone, only to see who we should question.

[CF Riot]

armlx -> Firestarter, CF Riot, K7
Joubert
killa seven
FaerieLord -> Corin, Manito, Firestarter
SpyreX -> FaerieLord, Firestarter, K7
LlamaFluff -> Corin, Manito, KoC
Firestarter -> Corin, K7, Manito

CF Riot -> KoC, Firestarter, Manito

Corinthian - K7, FaerieLord, Firestarter
LaptopGun -> armlx, Corin, Joubert/KoC
Knight of Cydonia
TheSweatpantsNinja -> Corin, Firestarter, K7
orangepenguin -> K7, FaerieLord, KoC/Corin
Manito
StrangerCoug -> Corinthian, killa seven, FaerieLord

Brilliant idea. 4 left.

[Joubert]

If you're looking for a top-3, here...

1. K7
2. FaerieLord
3. KoC

[Manito]

armlx -> Firestarter, CF Riot, K7
Joubert
killa seven
FaerieLord -> Corin, Manito, Firestarter
SpyreX -> FaerieLord, Firestarter, K7
LlamaFluff -> Corin, Manito, KoC
Firestarter -> Corin, K7, Manito

CF Riot -> KoC, Firestarter, Manito

Corinthian - K7, FaerieLord, Firestarter
LaptopGun -> armlx, Corin, Joubert/KoC
Knight of Cydonia
TheSweatpantsNinja -> Corin, Firestarter, K7
orangepenguin -> K7, FaerieLord, KoC/Corin

Manito -> FaerieLord, Joubert or K7

StrangerCoug -> Corinthian, killa seven, FaerieLord

I'm ambivalent about Joubert and K7, the primary reason they are up there on my list is general attitude and lurking without purpose. They are both my "#2" pick. Can I get some sort of clarification as to why everyone has KoC on their list??? I must have missed something major for everyone to have him on their scum radar...

[Manito]

Meh, forgot to take the bold tags out of CF's quote...sorry.

[StrangerCoug]

And Joubert is suspicious of killa seven, FaerieLord, and Knights of Cydonia in that order, so it should be:

armlx -> Firestarter, CF Riot, K7
Joubert -> K7, FaerieLord, KoC
killa seven
FaerieLord -> Corin, Manito, Firestarter
SpyreX -> FaerieLord, Firestarter, K7
LlamaFluff -> Corin, Manito, KoC
Firestarter -> Corin, K7, Manito
CF Riot -> KoC, Firestarter, Manito
Corinthian - K7, FaerieLord, Firestarter
LaptopGun -> armlx, Corin, Joubert/KoC
Knight of Cydonia
TheSweatpantsNinja -> Corin, Firestarter, K7
orangepenguin -> K7, FaerieLord, KoC/Corin
Manito -> FaerieLord, Joubert or K7
StrangerCoug -> Corinthian, killa seven, FaerieLord

[orangepenguin]

All we need now is killa 7 (who is on the list for more than half of the players for nine) and KoC (who is just for four).

[LaptopGun]

I hardly understand how you're disproving it, arm.

[LlamaFluff]

armlx -> Firestarter, CF Riot, K7
Joubert -> K7, FaerieLord, KoC
killa seven
FaerieLord -> Corin, Manito, Firestarter
SpyreX -> FaerieLord, Firestarter, K7
LlamaFluff -> Corin, Manito, KoC
Firestarter -> Corin, K7, Manito
CF Riot -> KoC, Firestarter, Manito
Corinthian - K7, FaerieLord, Firestarter
LaptopGun -> armlx, Corin, Joubert/KoC
Knight of Cydonia
TheSweatpantsNinja -> Corin, Firestarter, K7
orangepenguin -> K7, FaerieLord, KoC/Corin
Manito -> FaerieLord, Joubert or K7
StrangerCoug -> Corinthian, killa seven, FaerieLord

KoC is gone for now but I expect K7, Faerie, Corin from him
K7 looks like KoC, Corin, manito but I cant read him too well

For those of you keeping score right now we have

K7 (10+1?) (armlx, Joubert, spyrex, firestarter, CF Riot, Corin, TSN, mantio, penguin, SC, KoC (?))

Corin (7+2?) (FaerieLord, Llama, Firestarter, Laptopgun, TSN, SC, penguin, KoC?, K7?)

Firestarter (6) (arlmx, FaerieLord, spyrex, CF Riot, Corin, TSN)

KoC (5+1?) (Joubert, Llama, CF Riot, Laptopgun, penguin, K7?)

FaerieLord (5+1?) (Joubert, spyrex, Corin, penguin, manito, KoC?)

Manito (4+1?) (FaerieLord, Llama, CF Riot, Firestarter, K7?)

Joubert (2) (manito, laptopgun)

CF Riot (1) arlmx

arlmx (1) laptopgun

[armlx]

I don't think the score thing is good as in this scenario it can only lead to purely numbers wagons.

What I want to hear is a strong case on KoC from those attacking him.

[LlamaFluff]

I don't think the score thing is good as in this scenario it can only lead to purely numbers wagons.

Then what is the point of making the list? I dont think with what was collected we are going to run out and do a quicklynch of one of the top suspects, but this forced everyone to put out three documented FoSs basically. I dont understand why tallying them up is considered a bad thing.

What I want to hear is a strong case on KoC from those attacking him.

Posts 471, 492, 602 and 644 from me are points against him. In this situation Corin and mantio are my 1 and 2 by a decent margin, but if people refuse to lynch either of them KoC is my next suspect.

[armlx]

Then what is the point of making the list? I dont think with what was collected we are going to run out and do a quicklynch of one of the top suspects, but this forced everyone to put out three documented FoSs basically. I dont understand why tallying them up is considered a bad thing.

I was mainly looking at it to see if there was a distinct overlap in a lower target that would be worth looking into. And wagons that are just based on those numbers (ie A has more then B) allow for a lot of shameless hopping.

[StrangerCoug]

If anybody wants to get on my case for my deciding to

unvote: Corinthian

and

vote: killa seven

just because I suspect him along with nine other people, please do so now, as I'm tired of the waiting game and I'm not known for my patience anyway. 11:13 PM is not the time to muster up the willpower to go back and check what everybody said about the latter anyway.

[LlamaFluff]

Then what is the point of making the list? I dont think with what was collected we are going to run out and do a quicklynch of one of the top suspects, but this forced everyone to put out three documented FoSs basically. I dont understand why tallying them up is considered a bad thing.

I was mainly looking at it to see if there was a distinct overlap in a lower target that would be worth looking into. And

wagons that are just based on those numbers (ie A has more then B) allow for a lot of shameless hopping

.

Given that last post from SC I actually loled after reading this. I also see your point.

What "overlap in lower targets" are you talking about? Cases like KoC, FL and manito?

[CF Riot]

You put me on there 4 times. The erroneous vote is on K7, putting him in actuality at 9(+1).

KoC states in post 745 he is suspicious of Firestarter, which is not reflected in your guess votes. He appears to be pro-town on Corin.

SC's vote flop is noted, although I don't know what I think about it.

[armlx]

Cases like KoC, FL and manito?

Yup.

If it comes to deadline it will be good in figuring out who we can actually lynch, but until then we should not decide who to wagon based on it and only use it as a basis for questioning people who are under the radar yet thought scummy, as well as questioning people's choices.

[somestrangeflea]

My internet's down, so I have to make these posts on the move. Normal service should resume on Friday.

I don't have access to the votecount or activity status.

FaerieLord has been prodded by request.