Open 170 - Bird C9 (Game Over)

[Yankee]

And why is that? Right now my suspicion is Hohum, be he is already being actively discussed so i dont want to bring more attention to that.

[Kdub]

Vote Count

Yankee (0)

-

Slepz (1)

- Netlava

hohum (2)

- Eldritch Lord, Snix

Snix (0)

-

Netlava (0)

-

Toro (1)

- Slepz

Eldritch Lord (1)

- hohum

No Lynch (0)

-

Not Voting (2)

- Toro, Yankee

7 players alive, 4 votes needed to lynch

Deadline: October 10, ~8:00 pm Pacific

[Netlava]

Because they're lurking of course.

[Netlava]

Lurker lynch, anyone?

[Kdub]

Toro has been prodded.

[Toro]

Lurker lynch, anyone?

GAME RELATED: Gah, not this crap again.

GAME UNRELATED: Sorry for not being more active, had a party to go to, had a dinner to go to, had to go to Chinatown, had homework, had work. Everything's looking clear schedule-wise now though.

[Eldritch Lord]

How do you feel about the entire situation since you've been gone between Hohum and I?

How do you feel about Netlava sitting on the outside making those comments?

Lurker lynch anyone?

Probably a good idea to put some pressure on them, but I'm not liking hohum at the moment.

FoS: Toro & Slepz

I'd like to see some more out of you guys.

[Netlava]

Toro, what are your thoughts?

[Toro]

How do you feel about the entire situation since you've been gone between Hohum and I?

How do you feel about Netlava sitting on the outside making those comments?

Lurker lynch anyone?

Probably a good idea to put some pressure on them, but I'm not liking hohum at the moment.

FoS: Toro & Slepz

I'd like to see some more out of you guys.

I'm FoS because I wasn't available for awhile? Jeez...

Toro, what are your thoughts?

I'll separate my thoughts per player...

Yankee

- Rather new to the mafiascum site, seems as if he's keeping a tad quiet lately. But so far at least for a noob he's asking questions and hanging in there.

THOUGHTS = Quiet but town.

Slepz

- Originally I thought it was fishy how he jumped on me during the RVS for voting for Hohum, but since then I've discarded it as RVS fodder. Since RVS he hasn't had much to say.

THOUGHTS = Needs to post more, neutral for now.

Hohum

- I definitely think it's fishy that a L-1 is fine with him for a 7 player game but not for a 9-12 player game. And the fact that he thinks "oh mislynches are fine" is wrong, what if a townie accidentally hammers? Take Netlava, he says that he could be one who would possibly hammer. So if that happened, town would probably die D1, a different townie would be offed N1, and then we'd all lynch Netlava on D2, resulting in us losing. I know I agreed with your fact before but now I view it as scummy. The fact that he claims that I'm scared to go and scumhunt is a very strange argument, and also in his 61 he says that he wants power roles to play more aggresively during posting hours, Rolefishing = Scum, especially in this small of a setup. He also says that anyone not reading deserves to be mislynched in 66, remember, 7 players, LoL in effect D2.

THOUGHTS = Scum

Sn

ix

- I think the exchange between him in 64 and Hohum in 65 is interesting, Snix claims that Hohum is playing a bad townmember, Hohum calls him a liar. Sort of points more to a Hohum lynch in this case. I feel that his vote at 91 is sort of jumping at the oppurtunity, why didn't he just vote on his 64? It's weird seeing how that after more and more townmembers jump on the wagon/offering their thoughts, he just tacks on a vote.

THOUGHTS = The only way to clear Snix is by way of Hohum lynch, if Hohum is town then I think Snix is town. If Hohum is scum, then Snix is scum.

Net

lava

- I still think that your 29 was strange when asking that we already need to post our thoughts (or in this case, just Yankee) based just on RVS. There was never much to go on during the RVS, just an L-1 from what I've read. Seems like you're ancy to go and find scum right out of the get-go, this I like. Although with that statement in mind it sounds fishy that you're just voting for Slepz just on a vibe, instead of digging deeper and hunting more. Your 85 comes off to me saying that you wouldn't be paying attention however, and your post after that shows that as you just randomly proceed to go after a player.

THOUGHTS = Change in playstyle from assertive scumhunter to sitting in the back, semi-scummy to me.

Eldritch Lord

- Have a feeling that scum wouldn't vote their own partner calling them out on rolefishing, also seems to disagree plenty with Hohum in this game so far which I don't think scum would be doing with this many players, (scum wouldn't be distancing themselves so much), so far agree with his points.

THOUGHTS = So far so good.

------------------------

In conclusion,

Vote: Hohum

[hohum]

unvote, vote, hohum

[Eldritch Lord]

Wow you better flip scum after this shit.

[Eldritch Lord]

TAKEN FROM Mini 817: Chosen (Game Over!)

Rules

1. While it is understandable that on occasion tempers may flare, please remeber that this is a game. Please

have fun, be respectful

of your fellow players and

try not to take anything personally.

Just something you might want to consider for your future games man.

[hohum]

TAKEN FROM Mini 817: Chosen (Game Over!)

Rules

1. While it is understandable that on occasion tempers may flare, please remeber that this is a game. Please

have fun, be respectful

of your fellow players and

try not to take anything personally.

Just something you might want to consider for your future games man.

It's not personal. If you want to run me up on a playstyle lynch over a game theory disagreement there's not much I can contribute to the game, and I'm not going to ask to be replaced because I'm firmly under the impression that you're manipulating this situation based on your alignment and not some misguided understanding of how to deal with people who have a different play style than you do. Time will tell if I am correct or not.

[hohum]

Except it didn't catch scum in that game, it got you lynched first. Perhaps you should re-think your play style.

You were wrong about me in that game too, perhaps you should take the hint.

[Eldritch Lord]

Even if you were right and you're town, you wouldn't be helping town by just offing yourself, itd just be a childish action so you could yell I told you so later.

It's not good to vote yourself, play to win, etc.

[hohum]

that's a lame excuse to justify the case you put together which is based almost exclusively on meta, playstyle and game theory. I only hope that everyone else can see right through you.

[Eldritch Lord]

I'm not going to keep arguing with you in twilight about self-hammering, what you did was dumb and doesn't help us at all unless you flip scum, and if you do, good riddance.

[hohum]

you were more than ready to argue with me a few pages ago. You don't want to argue any more because you know I'm right.

I don't really care if you or anyone else thinks what I did is childish.

I'm petty, and I don't mind punishing the rest of the town for going along with you.

If I'm wrong, I'll gladly apologize later.

[hohum]

This outrage of yours is very disingenuous and that's the reason you suddenly don't want to argue with me. You're secretly happy that I self-hammered because that's one less kill you and your scum partner need to worry about.

You should be happy.

Screw you town and go scum team!

[Eldritch Lord]

I don't want to argue with you because you're being childish about this. I hold that it was a dumb idea and anti-town.

[hohum]

A townie that would rather attack a player than listen to a well-reasoned argument (even if you don't necessarily agree) is just as anti-town as a townie that would self-hammer. Remember that next time you push a bullshit theory case on someone.

[Snix]

Holy Christ on a Christ sandwich with Christ sauce on top.

I am going to avoid you like the plague hohum, you are not fun to play with in any sense of the word.

Toro: I'll admit that it looks odd, but I had hope for him in 64 but he never came around so I voted him in hopes that he might get the hint. I was pretty sure he was town and wanted him to start acting like it.

[Yankee]

You say you were pretty sure he was town yet you still voted for him? and its funny that you say that you think he is town now when he self hammers. Very suspicious to me.

On a seperate note, What the heck, you can self hammer?!? why would anyone in their right mind, scum or town, do that?

[Kdub]

Vote Count

Yankee (0)

-

Slepz (1)

- Netlava

hohum (4)

- Eldritch Lord, Snix, Toro, hohum

Snix (0)

-

Netlava (0)

-

Toro (1)

- Slepz

Eldritch Lord (0)

-

No Lynch (0)

-

Not Voting (1)

- Yankee

hohum has been lynched. He was a

Vanilla Townie

.

It is now Night 1. Day 2 will begin in roughly 72 hours. Please submit night choices before then.

[Kdub]

As the sun rises, everyone gathers in the town square once more to discuss the mafia threat. Everyone except Slepz that is. You go to his home and find that he had been killed during the night. On his corpse, you find medical equipment and an ID that confirms his role.

Slepz has been killed. He was a

Doctor

.

Day 2 has officially begun.

Vote Count

Yankee (0)

-

Snix (0)

-

Netlava (0)

-

Toro (0)

-

Eldritch Lord (0)

-

No Lynch (0)

-

Not Voting (5)

- Yankee, Snix, Netlava, Toro, Eldritch Lord

5 players alive, 3 votes needed to lynch

Deadline: October 21, ~9:00 pm Pacific