Newbie 424 - Murder in Kerplunkville - GAME OVER - Scum wins

[PJ.]

Oh wow. The IC was right? Check that goodness out. Mnowax was scum. Too bad booker had me fooled though. I was after Booker. Good Job Booker. Good Job though Tool. Way to vote pro town.

[toolenduso]

That was so ridiculous.

@Panzer: Sorry. But you were going way too fast. You could have been scum. I probably should have realized a scum hammer was evident, but then you could have been hammering as scum too.

[Kerplunk]

This is very likely the shortest newbie game evah. Made a new wiki-page: Records, and put us on it.

[PJ.]

lmao. Man All I know is I had this shit on lock. Mnowax was scum like wh0a.

[Booker]

As a random side-note, all my brain are belong to toolenduso. If you don't know what this means, click here.

[mnowax]

wow i check back and its over?

[mnowax]

I figured i was a goner today, so i was jsut hoping that booker could lay low and just push my lynch. who knew two townies would hop on in LYLO.

[toolenduso]

Lol. Well at least I scored some brains from this.

Panzer, I'm still confused. Could you please explain your method here?

[PJ.]

What townie would hammer Page 1? none. Mnowax hammers. Mnowax is scum. Lynch mnowax. Then discuss from there at 3-1/2-1 cause we have befuzzled the last mafia and it would be much easier to catch. Regardless of the last scum, we have caught one and we can pick up from there and be more productive then we were with 7.

[PJ.]

I generally feel more comfortable in a 3 or 4 person end game then a 7 person beginning game.

[Booker]

Except, in day two, the lynch would have been very quick if mnowax was the one to go down, which would make it a d3 with very little more evidence than at the start. And, when it came down to it, we all looked equally suspicious to my way of thinking.
Me and bearded lurked a bit, and thus could have won by doing little more than sitting there. (I guess part of why people dislike lurkers so much)
Panzerjager would have set himself up as a 'scum-slayer' at LYLO, despite in fact putting the town in a dangerous position, thus putting suspicion away from him even as the scum, to my mind, gain an advantage (Unless you get WIFOM-y and suggest that doing such a thing, due to my line of reasoning, he would have in fact known it would cast suspicion on him)
And Tool had an effective way of moving the suspicion elsewhere, defending his 'scum-buddy' without making himself look scummy. But who do you vote for of all those? (Well, three of those, considering there were no power-roles.)

...And yes, that was ridiculous.

[toolenduso]

Still, there were two others voting with you, so wouldn't they have looked suspicious?

[PJ.]

Two others pre -1L. A vote and a lynch are very different. Playing aggresive and/or weird is one of my favrite things to do, it give me reactions to things that I am familiar with, and in small games it allows you to kinda set things up. I was hoping Tool/Bearded would vote for Mnowax, not both of them to me.

[toolenduso]

Hmmm...interesting.

Well, I definitely see my mistake(s) now. Sorry.

[Mr. Flay]

Last post.