Mini 458 - Game over!

[Per]

You post was well within the deadline, NabNab. Deadline has just passed now.

Vote Count at the DEADLINE

curiouskarmadog: 6 (Crub, NabakovNabakov, ThAdmiral, Numenorean7, pickemgenius, Mastermind of Sin)
ThAdmiral: 2 (curiouskarmadog, dylan41985)
Adel: 1 (Tarhalindur)
pickemgenius: 1 (Adel)

Not voting: 2 (molestargazer, Kate)


Curiouskarmadog was walking towards... Hey, this was supposed to be a non-flavoured game!

Curiouskarmadog, vanilla townie, has been lynched.

If you have a night ability, send in your choice before

10 August, same time (exactly 3 days from this post).

If all night choices reach me before that time, the topic will be opened immediately, so keep your eye on this game.

[Per]

So everyone woke up for a new day, after having lynched an innocent townie the evening before. Everyone was feeling rather uncomfortable. Everyone? No, Mastermind of Sin wasn't feeling uncomfortable. He wasn't feeling at all.

Mastermind of Sin, COP, has been killed.

Day 2 has now begun.

With 10 alive, it takes 6 votes to lynch.

[pickemgenius]

In Hawaii or the next 10 days, literally just about to be heading out.

Thought I'd be nice and let you know just in case you didn't see my sig.

[Adel]

I have no idea who to vote for, but Tar is not the lynch for today and that was an OMGUS vote, so

Unvote

I won't be able to post again today, but out of the three, I'd say curious is probably the scummiest. Everyone's said this already but when he's under pressure, he acts pretty scummy.

pickem is picking a good time to leave.

pickem, kate, and num7, and ThAdmiral make up my current suspect list. The wagon on ckd got really big really quickly. fueled by scum, no doubt.

I've been sucking as town lately- ckd and MoS were both town in this game, so my flawless record of suspecting townies of being scum across many games is still intact. not something to be proud of, at all.

[Mastermind of Sin]

OMFG

[Kate]

I have no idea who to vote for, but Tar is not the lynch for today and that was an OMGUS vote, so Unvote

I won't be able to post again today, but out of the three, I'd say curious is probably the scummiest. Everyone's said this already but when he's under pressure, he acts pretty scummy.

pickem is picking a good time to leave.

pickem, kate, and num7, and ThAdmiral make up my current suspect list. The wagon on ckd got really big really quickly. fueled by scum, no doubt.

I thought curious was scummy, and so did six other people. Curious did act very scum-like under pressure, and I don't see why I couldn't also agree that he was scummy.

[Adel]

Oh, and before someone takes the time to track down the post I made earlier- I am afraid that I may have tipped of the scum that MoS was the cop. I made a post where I said something to the effect of "I thought MoS was the Cop but now I think he is rolefishing". I hope that didn't clue the scum in, and they Nk'd MoS because he is MoS and not because of anything I said. I know this is WIFOM territory, but I thought I would just voice my own error and save everyone a little time. I would think that post of mine was a scumtell if I were another player.

vote:Kate

because pickem is on vacation, and I don't like how she coppied other people case against ckd almost word for word when she made her vote on him. i am convinced that there is scum on the ckd wagon. Totally convinced.

[Kate]

vote:Kate

because pickem is on vacation, and I don't like how she coppied other people case against ckd almost word for word when she made her vote on him. i am convinced that there is scum on the ckd wagon. Totally convinced.

I actally never voted him. All I said was that I thought he was scummy and a good lynch for day one.

[Adel]

unvote

sorry, how did I miss that? I

knew

you voted for him!

[Per]

(Info: Molestargazer isn't being replaced because he replied to his prod overnight, asking to not be replaced.)

[Adel]

I checked molestargazers' profile, and his last post anywhere was July 30. This is apparently his only active game. Does anyone know if he is an alt? Lurkers make me nervous.

[Numenorean7]

We've lost two of our more active players, both of whom were pro-town. I believe we should take a closer look at our lurkers.

Dylan jumped on almost every major wagon, but he was not on CKD's lynch. Coincidence?

FoS: Dylan

I have a few questions for MSG. Looking through your posts, I noticed that you haven't had a vote on anyone since you unvoted Dylan over a month ago. Why? Your last post was a day before the deadline was announced, and you said you were just back from vacation, and promised to catch up. Why didn't you contribute? How come you could respond to a PM during a 64-hour night, but you didn't post in the thead at all during the 1-week space before the deadline?

FoS: MSG

I'd like to know what ThAdmiral has to say about Adel, now that CKD has been lynched and came up pro-town. I never quite understood the reasoning behind, "If adel is lynched and comes up town I will go after ckd." Does he now conclude that Adel must be scum?

Adel, could you do another diagram like you did in 307 showing all the votes of D1? I know it would be a lot of work, but you say you like doing it, and I think a retrospective of the D1 votes would be very helpful.

[Adel]

Adel, could you do another diagram like you did in 307 showing all the votes of D1? I know it would be a lot of work, but you say you like doing it, and I think a retrospective of the D1 votes would be very helpful.

I need to do a reread anyway. 45 pages. Good lord. It will take me a while- several hours.

[Kate]

Good luck I think that would help us.

[Adel]

Adel, could you do another diagram like you did in 307 showing all the votes of D1? I know it would be a lot of work, but you say you like doing it, and I think a retrospective of the D1 votes would be very helpful.

I need to do a reread anyway. 45 pages. Good lord. It will take me a while- several hours.

It isn't going to happen today. Period, as much as I would like to finish. I'm about 20% done because some stuff came up. I'll be able to get back to it tomorrow, but I'm not promising that I'll finish tomorrow.

[NabakovNabakov]

Damnit. I'm just terrible when it comes to picking a candidate at deadline. Sorry CKD.

I told everybody Page 44 would be important. MoS, is dead, Pickem is semi-gone, so I'll

Vote: ThAdmiral

for dropping a last minute vote on the CKD wagon. I'd like to re-read sometime, but I need to hire a few sherpas first.

I'd also like MSG to be replaced if he doesn't start posting content lickity-split.

[Numenorean7]

The fact that MSG responded to the PM suggests he's still around. Yet he hasn't posted in the thread, not even saying, "hey, I'm still here but I'm behind. Give me a while to catch up." He just continued his inactivity. That means he is genuinely lurking.

Vote: MSG

[dylan41985]

I'm still conviced that ThAdmiral is behind this

vote: ThAdmiral

[Tarhalindur]

I'm back. I'm short on time, so I can't offer much, but this caught my eye:

We've lost two of our more active players, both of whom were pro-town. I believe we should take a closer look at our lurkers.

Dylan jumped on almost every major wagon, but he was not on CKD's lynch. Coincidence?

I have a few questions for MSG. Looking through your posts, I noticed that you haven't had a vote on anyone since you unvoted Dylan over a month ago. Why? Your last post was a day before the deadline was announced, and you said you were just back from vacation, and promised to catch up. Why didn't you contribute? How come you could respond to a PM during a 64-hour night, but you didn't post in the thead at all during the 1-week space before the deadline?

I'd like to know what ThAdmiral has to say about Adel, now that CKD has been lynched and came up pro-town. I never quite understood the reasoning behind, "If adel is lynched and comes up town I will go after ckd." Does he now conclude that Adel must be scum?

Adel, could you do another diagram like you did in 307 showing all the votes of D1? I know it would be a lot of work, but you say you like doing it, and I think a retrospective of the D1 votes would be very helpful.

So, you're asking questions instead of offering analysis, and advocating a lurker hunt to boot? That's seriously scummy.

Vote: Num7

[Numenorean7]

What's wrong with asking questions? For that matter, what's wrong with a lurker hunt? I don't want the active town to lynch each other off while the scum hide in shadows. We should at least look at the content-challenged among us more closely.

Prod: Crub and ThAdmiral

[ThAdmiral]

@ Num: I think I've already said this but I was going to go after ckd if adel turned up town because I already thought he was somewhat suspicious, and him being instrumental in the death of a townie would have pushed my suspicions of him over the line, so to speak. It's moot now anyway, because he's dead now. And yes I may go after Adel. Two confirmed towns thought she was scummy.

@ NabNab: I tried not to be too last minute, but it seemed like it was either me or him, and I chose me!

[Crub]

@Num : I'm here I find it amusing that with 45 pages of content you think the best play is to go after the lurkers?

[NabakovNabakov]

I really don't think this town has been all that inactive at all (especially when compared to other towns I've played in.) MSG has been shamlessly absent, but that's about it (and he's more of an inactive than a lurker).

@ThAdmiral: A fair point.

Unvote

, although the number of players who piled on to the competing wagon you selected might indicate that you actually are scum. I didn't notice that Num switched last minute too. I think Num and Pickem should probably be looked at with the most scrutiny (especially as Num is now trying desperately to lurker hunt rather than use the info at hand)

FOS: Numenorean7, Pickemgenius

[Kate]

I do't think we should really go after the lurkers, but I don't like mole's dissapearence. Answering a prod but still not saying anything is really wierd and I don't find Num scummy for wanting to go after him.

We've lost two of our more active players, both of whom were pro-town. I believe we should take a closer look at our lurkers.

Dylan jumped on almost every major wagon, but he was not on CKD's lynch. Coincidence?

I have a few questions for MSG. Looking through your posts, I noticed that you haven't had a vote on anyone since you unvoted Dylan over a month ago. Why? Your last post was a day before the deadline was announced, and you said you were just back from vacation, and promised to catch up. Why didn't you contribute? How come you could respond to a PM during a 64-hour night, but you didn't post in the thead at all during the 1-week space before the deadline?

I'd like to know what ThAdmiral has to say about Adel, now that CKD has been lynched and came up pro-town. I never quite understood the reasoning behind, "If adel is lynched and comes up town I will go after ckd." Does he now conclude that Adel must be scum?

Adel, could you do another diagram like you did in 307 showing all the votes of D1? I know it would be a lot of work, but you say you like doing it, and I think a retrospective of the D1 votes would be very helpful.

So, you're asking questions instead of offering analysis, and advocating a lurker hunt to boot? That's seriously scummy. Vote: Num7

What's wrog with asking questions? Aren't you supposed to ask questions in this game? I'm pretty sure someone told me I was anti-town for not asking questions.
Oh, and Happy Birthday Tar!

[ThAdmiral]

@ dylan: and still think you're scum too

@ tar: I agree that going lurker-hunting with as much information that we have is suspicious, but msg seems to be purposefully staying in the shadows for whatever reason. I would also like to hear what he has to say.

@ kate:

I actually never voted him. All I said was that I thought he was scummy and a good lynch for day one.

This to me is even more scummy than voting for him would have been.

Oh and -
@ crub: If your cow says anything again we now know to ignore it.