PIRATES v. NINJAS! Game Over!

[Primate]

Stoof took your kill, eh?

[Mr Stoofer]

Vote Count

No-lynch: 2 (ooba, Primate)

Not voting: 2 (The Fonz, Lawrencelot)

3 to lynch!

[The Fonz]

Stoof took your kill, eh?

He may have done. Even if he DID take tonight's kill away from me, it doesn't change matters. You kill me, the town will win.

[Primate]

Oh, it's not me, I just think it's funny.

[The Fonz]

It clearly IS you, Primate. Lawrence's pirate protector claim makes so much more sense than yours.

Anyhow, ball's in your court. Remember, nightkill me, and you WILL lose.

Vote: No-lynch

[Mr Stoofer]

Vote Count

No-lynch: 3 (ooba, Primate, The Fonz)

Not voting: 1 (Lawrencelot)

[Mr Stoofer]

Blah blah blah

Is it Mafia to repeatedly no-lynch? I think not.

Night 9: choices ASAP, please

[Mr Stoofer]

Unhappy Days

Oh no! Fonzie is dead!

---

The Fonz - Great Goblin - killed Night 8

Day 9: 3 alive means 2 votes to lynch!

[ooba]

Well Well Well .. Poor Fonzie .. Be right back with my vote ..

[Primate]

huh. ITT town majority. ^5

Vote Lawrencelot

mainly because he claims he's a pirate protector.

I can make a big case against him covering everything if you think it's a decision, but, even hypothetically, he's the guy who hasn't commented on or even mentioned any of the ninja all game.

[Lawrencelot]

Vote: Primate

. Man, my brains hurt.

[Mr Stoofer]

Vote Count

Lawrencelot: 1 (Primate)
Primate: 1 (Lawrencelot)

Not voting: 1 (ooba)

2 votes to lynch!

[ooba]

Bilbo Baggins (Goblin Finder) - Gandalf (Goblin Protector)
Bruce Lee (Ninja Protector) - Sonny Chiba (Ninja Finder)
Jack Aubrey (Pirate Finder) - ??

Stephen Maturin
Cutler Beckett

Which fits better?

You've slipped up. You're a ninja, aren't you?

[ooba]

Vote : Primate

[Primate]

One is connected, the other isn't. It's your call there.

And if I lose the game based on a smart ass comment Mgm made in the early game, then I won't be happy.

[Primate]

arfghhhhhh

[Primate]

GJ ninja

[Mr Stoofer]

Vote Count

Primate: 2 (Lawrencelot, ooba)

Lawrencelot: 1 (Primate)

[Mr Stoofer]

Game Over - Town wins!

After the last few torrid hours I am too exhausted to say anything but:

Primate (replaced JordanA24) - Kamakura - lynched Day 9

The Survivors

:

• Lawrencelot - Stephen Maturin (Pirate Protector)
  
• ooba - Harry Houdini (Escapologist) - not lynched Day 1

[Mr Stoofer]

Scum Role PMs

Ninja

The Ninjas are:

ibaesha

Primate (Kamakura), Erg0 (Joe Armstrong, American Ninja),

Samruc

Cogito Ergo Sum (Master Splinter)

Your goal is to defeat the Pirates and prove the superiority of the deadly Ninjas! At night you may talk to each other and can send me the name of someone that you want to kill. (The person who sends me the name will be the killer.)

Any group of bad guys that tries to kill you will fail at their first attempt.

You win when all the Pirates (and everyone else) are dead – provided at least one Ninja survives.

Safe claim: any character from Doctor Who (including the Doctor).

Please confirm in the thread.

Pirate

The Pirates are:

Thestatusquo

Rogueben (Blackbeard), KaleiÐoscøpe (Dread Pirate Roberts), Skruffs (Jack Sparrow)

Your goal is to defeat the Ninjas and prove the superiority of the brave Pirates! At night you may talk to each other and can send me the name of someone that you want to kill. (The person who sends me the name will be the killer.)

Any group of bad guys that tries to kill you will fail at their first attempt.

You win when all the Ninjas (and everyone else) are dead – provided at least one Pirate survives.

Safe claim: any past or present American President or UK Prime Minister.

Please confirm in the thread.

Goblin

The Goblins are: Guardian (Redcloak), The Fonz (The Great Goblin), cicero (Rumplestiltskin).

The three of you are on a Goblin rampage! At night you may talk to each other and can send me the name of someone that you want to kill. (The person who sends me the name will be the killer.)

Any group of bad guys that tries to kill you will fail at their first attempt.

You win when everyone else is dead – provided at least one Goblin survives.

Safe Claim: any character from the Harry Potter books (including Harry Potter).

Please confirm in the thread.

[Mr Stoofer]

Town Role PMs

All investigators are Sane, apart from (1) Joe MacCarthy always gets "Communist" (2) Everyone gets a bad guys result for Darth Vader.

MGM

Sonny Chiba (Ninja Finder)

In this game you must use your martial arts skills to destroy all Ninjas! Each night you may PM me the name of one player and I will tell you whether they are a Ninja.

You are a good guy and win when all the bad guys are dead.

Please confirm in the thread.

XTOXM (REPLACED SIR TORNADO)

Bruce Lee (Ninja Protector)

In this game you must use your martial arts skills to destroy all Ninjas! Each night you may PM me the name of one player whom you will protect from Ninja attack. You can protect yourself once in this game.

You are a good guy and win when all the bad guys are dead.

Please confirm in the thread.

DRIPPINGGOOFBALL

Jack Aubrey (Pirate Finder)

Your latest mission is to hunt down and destroy Pirates! Each night you may PM me the name of one player and I will tell you whether they are a Pirate.

You are a good guy and win when all the bad guys are dead.

Please confirm in the thread.

LAWRENCELOT (REPLACED FLAMEAXE)

Stephen Maturin (Pirate Protector)

You must use your medical skills to confound the Pirates. Each night you may PM me the name of one player whom you will protect from Pirate attack. You can protect yourself once in this game.

You are a good guy and win when all the bad guys are dead.

Please confirm in the thread.

TWOMZ

Bilbo Baggins (Goblin Finder)

You must use your trusty sword Sting to find and destroy the Goblins. Each night you may PM me the name of one player and I will tell you whether they are a Goblin.

You are a good guy and win when all the bad guys are dead.

Please confirm in the thread.

THOK

Gandalf (Goblin Protector)

Despite being a powerful Wizard, in this game you have only one power: each night you may PM me the name of one player whom you will protect from Goblin attack. You can protect yourself once in this game.

You are a good guy and win when all the bad guys are dead.

Please confirm in the thread.

MRBUDDYLEE

Luke Skywalker (Vigilante)

Use the Force to defeat the bad guys! Each night you may send me the name of one player whom you wish to kill.

You are a good guy and win when all the bad guys are dead.

Please confirm in the thread.

ULTIMAAVALON

Darth Vader (Miller)

In this game you are a good guy and win when all the bad guys are dead.

Your strength in the Force does mean that if anyone attacks you, you will kill them (although you will also die).

However, the Dark Side is so powerful with you that you will appear to be a bad guy to any investigative roles.

Please confirm in the thread.

THESP

Sanada Yukimura, Samurai Warrior (Day Vig)

You are a noble Samurai Warrior, sworn to destroy evil. Once during this game, you may kill another player by posting Kill: Player in the thread. However, if that player is revealed to be a good guy you will immediately commit seppuku out of shame. Either way, the day will end when you use your power.

You are a good guy and win when all the bad guys are dead.

Please confirm in the thread.

FRITZLER

Victor Frankenstein (Resurrector)

You have discovered the secret of resurrection! At any time during the day, you may resurrect a dead player by posting Resurrect: Player in the thread. You may only do this once and, I am afraid, it will cost you your life – you will live until the day ends and then die.

You are a good guy and win when all the bad guys are dead.

Please confirm in the thread.

IAMMARS

Abraham Van Helsing (Vampire Finder)

You are continuing your hunt for Vampires. Each night you may PM me the name of one player and I will tell you whether they are a Vampire.

You are a good guy and win when all the bad guys are dead.

Please confirm in the thread.

CLAUS

Senator Joe McCarthy (Communist Finder)

You are continuing your hunt for Commie Scum. Each night you may PM me the name of one player and I will tell you whether they are a Communist.

You are a good guy and win when all the bad guys are dead.

Please confirm in the thread.

MIKEBURNFIRE

Sigmund Freud (Lie Detector)

As a skilled psychiatrist, each night you may find out if one statement made by a player in this game was a lie. Send me a quotation (1 sentence maximum) from the previous day and tell me the number of the post in which it appears. I will tell you to the best of my ability whether or not they were lying when they made the post. BUT: your ability to detect lies only works if people don’t realise what you are doing. If your ability becomes public it will stop working.

You are a good guy and win when all the bad guys are dead.

Please confirm in the thread.

(HASDGFAS) REPLACED VIKINGFAN

Stan Laurel (Mason)

You have got Oliver Hardy (Gorrad) into another fine mess. At least you know that he is a good guy. The two of you may talk at night.

You are a good guy and win when all the bad guys are dead.

Please confirm in the thread.

GORRAD

Oliver Hardy (Mason)

Stan Laurel (

vikingfan

hasdgfas) has got you into another fine mess. At least you know that he is a good guy. The two of you may talk at night.

You are a good guy and win when all the bad guys are dead.

Please confirm in the thread.

OOBA (REPLACED ROSSO CARNE)

Harry Houdini (Escapologist)

If you are lynched you will be able to use your skills to escape from the noose and survive. The game will then go to night. If you are lynched a second time, the lynchers will be more careful and you will die.

You are a good guy and win when all the bad guys are dead.

Please confirm in the thread.

KISON

Harry Flashman (Townie)

You are a good guy and win when all the bad guys are dead.

Please confirm in the thread.

[Mr Stoofer]

Choices, etc

Night 1

:

Erg0 killed MrBuddyLee

Mgm investigated MrBuddyLee (not a Ninja)
Sir Tornado protected Thesp

KaleiÐoscøpe killed DrippingGoofball

DrippingGoofball investigated cicero (not a Pirate)
Flameaxe protected Thestatusquo

Guardian killed MrBuddyLee

Twomz investigated Fritzler (not a Goblin)
Thok protected JordanA24 (who replaced ibeasha pre-game)
MrBuddyLee chose not to kill
Iammars investigated JordanA24 (who replaced ibeasha pre-game) (not a Vampire)
Claus investigated cicero (Communist)
mikeburnfire analysed Thok's post 18 (true: Thok did want all the bad guys to be killed and all the good guys to survive)

Day 1

:

Xtoxm replaced Sir Tornado
Fritzler resurrected MrBuddyLee -- and died as a result
The Town tried but failed to lynch Rosso Carne

Night 2

:

Erg0 attempted to kill KaleiÐoscøpe (failed due to Rule [17])

Mgm investigated Claus (not a Ninja)
Xtoxm protected cicero
Rogueben replaced Thestatusquo

Skruffs killed hasdgfas

Flameaxe protected Thestatusquo

Guardian attempted to kill Erg0 (failed due to Rule [17])

Twomz investigated Guardian (Goblin)
Thok protected MrBuddyLee
MrBuddyLee killed Xtoxm
Iammars investigated ooba (not a Vampire)
Claus investigated Xtoxm (Communist)
mikeburnfire analysed Guardian's post 727, first line (untrue)
ooba replaced Rosso Carne

Day 2

:

The Town lynched Guardian

Night 3

:

Erg0 killed KaleiÐoscøpe

Mgm investigated Thok (not a Ninja)

Rogueben killed Mgm

Flameaxe protected Erg0

cicero killed Thok

Twomz investigated Skruffs (not a Goblin)
Thok protected Twomz
MrBuddyLee killed Thok
Iammars investigated Claus (not a Vampire)
Claus investigated KaleiÐoscøpe (Communist)
mikeburnfire analysed Guardian's post 1114 "we have two members" (untrue)

Day 3

:

Primate replaced JordanA24
Cogito Ergo Sum replaced Samruc
Thesp killed Erg0
Twomz figured out mikeburnfire' ability (post 1456) and so the ability was lost

Night 4

:

Primate killed Gorrad

Rogueben killed Claus

Flaemaxe protected Thesp

cicero killed Twomz

Twomz investigated Rogueben (not a Goblin)
MrBuddyLee killed Skruffs
Iammars investigated mikeburnfire (not a Vampire)
Claus investigated Kison (Communist)

Day 4

:

Lawrencelot replaced Flameaxe
The Town lynched Roguben

Night 5

:

Cogito Ergo Sum killed MrBuddyLee

Lawrencelot protected MrBuddyLee (although all the Pirates were dead anyway)

The Fonz killed mikeburnfire

MrBuddyLee killed Iammars
Iammars investigated Kison (not a Vampire)

Day 5

:

The Town lynched Ultima Avalon

Night 6

:

Cogito Ergo Sum killed Thesp

Lawrencelot protected Thesp

The Fonz killed Kison

Day 6

:

No lynch

Night 7

:

Cogito Ergo Sum attempted to kill cicero (failed due to Rule [17])

Lawrecelot protected ooba

cicero attempted to kill Cogito Ergo Sum (failed due to rule [17])

Day 7

:

No lynch

Night 8

:

Primate killed cicero

I didn't bother to wait for Lawrencelot's choice

cicero killed Cogito Ergo Sum

Day 8

:

For a serious violation of rule [08] by cicero, The Fonz lost his nightkill immunity

No lynch

Night 9

:

Primate killed The Fonz

I didn't bother to wait for Lawrencelot's choice

The Fonz chose not to kill

Day 9

:

The Town lynched Primate - the last bad guy - and won the game!

[Mr Stoofer]

I am afraid I don't have much time for comments now - I'll give nay insights I have on Monday. I should thank mith for help with the setup and all the players for making this what I hope was a really great game.

The one flaw in this game was that it could, I think, have been broken wide open by an early mass claim. In the end I figured that that just would not happen. Sure enough:

If you really think Stoofer would make a game that would be breakable by mass claiming, I'm sorry for you.

I was counting on that mentality.

[The Fonz]

Yeah, the fake nameclaims were useless since there was no role that could safely be claimed. This is why games need vanilla townies.

Also, Primate:

I told you you'd lose if you tried to kill me, didn't I?

[Mr Stoofer]

This is why games need vanilla townies.

I agree. That is why I said at the beginning of the game that there was at least one townie and gave the role PM.