PIRATES v. NINJAS! Game Over!

[cicero]

I'm sure he does.

Just not this point.

/pat

/pat

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

I know. Peter Pan would never protect anyone from pirates.

It's not that Peter Pan doesn't do that, it's just that he's an extremely annoying brat who is only liked by little kiddies. And I should note that Stoofer is not a little kiddie. Peter Pan doesn't in any way begin to compare to, say, Luke Skywalker.

If you could pick any fictional character, why would you ever pick Peter Pan?

[cicero]

You have me there. I'm clearly obvscum. Your powers of deduction are immeasurable. /sarcasm off.

But let's humour you - I'm the same age as Stoofer... so, um, ONE person who is not a little kiddy picked it, CES. In this case, Stoofer.

[Primate]

Heheh, kind of saw this coming, but it's funny all the same. You look silly.

<- Cutler Beckett.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Except you just wanted to match the Pirate Protector. You had no interest in going for awesome roles.

[cicero]

Thok - Gandalf (Goblin Protector)
Bruce Lee (Ninja Protector)

See any doctors in there?
See any East India trading company antagonists?
No. You see characters who could actually protect someone from the bad guys.

[Lawrencelot]

Unvote, vote: CES.

Could someone explain in clear words why scum shouldn't be lynched? 'Cuz I didn't really get it.

[ooba]

Unvote, vote: CES.

Could someone explain in clear words why scum shouldn't be lynched? 'Cuz I didn't really get it.

It gives the town better odds at winning. Look at the table in the previous page. If no lynch occurs and both scum groups hit the same tonwie, then theres an extra chance for town win which wont occur in other scenarios.

Fake claiming Pirate protector was the optimal thing to do by the way .. Good job scum

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Unvote, vote: CES.

Could someone explain in clear words why scum shouldn't be lynched? 'Cuz I didn't really get it.

Because it will lead to the other scumgroup winning.

[Mr Stoofer]

Vote Count

No-lynch: 4 (ooba, Cogito Ergo Sum, Lawrencelot, cicero)

Not voting: 2 (The Fonz, Primate)

[Mr Stoofer]

At least you are safe from Pirates!

OK, please could Stephen Maturin, Peter Pan, the Doctor and Cutler Beckett all send me the name of the player you each want to protect from Pirates -- within 30 hours if possible. In the unlikely event that there are any bad guys out there, please could they also send in their kill in the same time frame.

Night 7: choices by Friday 5pm GMT if possible

[Mr Stoofer]

4 Docs = 0 kills

With 4 claimed docs, I am sure that it will be no surprise to any of you that there were no deaths overnight

Day 7: 6 alive means 4 votes to lynch!

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Vote: no lynch

[ooba]

Good going docs !!

Vote : no lynch

[Lawrencelot]

Vote: no lynch

?

[Primate]

vote no lynch

[Mr Stoofer]

Vote Count

No-lynch: 4 (Cogito Ergo Sum, ooba, Lawrencelot, Primate)

Not voting: 2 (The Fonz, cicero)

[Mr Stoofer]

Is this Mafia?

Is it Mafia to repeatedly no-lynch? I think not.

If you guys can get your nightchoices in to me within the next 3 hours, I can start a new day

!

Night 8: choices ASAP, please

[Mr Stoofer]

4 Docs = 2 kills

Well I guess that the four of you must have run out of medicines, since you could not prevent some long awaited carnage last night...

---

cicero - Rumplestiltskin - nunchak'd Night 8

Cogito Ergo Sum (replaced Samruc) - Master Splinter - shortsworded Night 8

Day 7: 4 alive means 3 votes to lynch!

[ooba]

Vote : No lynch

Tag corrected at ooba's request - Stoofer

[Primate]

vote no lynch

[cicero]

cicero

: you know that "Bah!" posts are not permitted in this game. Especially not ones that contain comment on the game.

I have thought seriously about modkilling someone on your team, but have decided to impose a lesser punishment.

Any further violations of this rule and I will modkill at random someone from the same team as the infringer.

- Mr Stoofer

[Mr Stoofer]

I have decided to impose a punishment on cicero's team for his violation of rule [08]. I am not going to say now what it is but I will make it clear at the end of the Game.

[Mr Stoofer]

I am also going to start a thread in the Mafia Discussion form when this game is over in an attempt to find out why players in my game seem unable to read and follow the few simple rules that I post in every game.

[The Fonz]

Dear last remaining ninja, (and don't think I don't know who you are)

here's the deal. I'm the last goblin.

I'm going to refuse to kill tonight. You can target me if you want, but that will mean a town win. I promise, with everyone in this thread as witnesses, that I will leave the site immediately if I am found to have submitted a nightkill tonight.

You have a choice.

You can no-kill as well, and we'll end up with a three-way ATLHEA.
Alternatively, you can kill off one of the town, and we'll lynch the remaining townie tomorrow. Then I will no-kill, because so long as you kill me, nothing I do matters- I can't win.

I'll leave it up to your conscience to determine whether you feel your ego needs the boost of being seen as the sole winner, or if you're willing to split, because to be honest I don't really care anymore. I think you deserve to win more than the town does anyway, so either way it's preferable to just carrying on this charade in the forlorn hope that either of us somehow fails to spot the obvious, and in the process handing the town the game.

Yours,

The Great Goblin