The only people I would consider lynching today are Oman and Guardian^2. Adel's a possibility also because of this: This thread.
It's really messing with my mind.
he case against Adel has intrigued me, and I've certainly been thinking about the possibility of her being scum more closely. I don't think she's today's lynch though.
3) Something else bothers me about Xylthixlm. I'm actually shocked that nobody called me out about this apparent contradiction. Previously I mentioned the following:
Incognito, in post 977, wrote: The case against Adel has intrigued me, and I've certainly been thinking about the possibility of her being scum more closely. I don't think she's today's lynch though.
Oman or Guardian^2 is today's lynch.
but about two posts later I placed a vote on Adel over something that was actually rather trivial. I did this for a few reasons:
a) A number of people seemed to criticize Adel for her actions (particularly Xylthixlm during Day 2) but prior to my vote, Adel had yet to receive a serious vote for the whole game.
b) I wanted to gauge reactions. The reactions I received were interesting: Matt_S followed suit out of nowhere with a vote on Adel and then probably more importantly Xylthixlm (a person who was giving Adel flak for most of Day 2) finally decided to place a vote on Adel as well! Why did he wait so long? Why did he have to wait until after two people voted to finally place a vote on a person he had such strong feelings against?
In short, I think Oman and Guardian^2 are scum. The scum partner of one of these two is a little less obvious but judging from some of Xylthixlm's reactions, I could see him being a possibility. And tbh, Matt_S's vote on Adel taints him a bit too. I might need to do another reread of him to see if I still receive the same feelings about him.
what is the scumtell here?I've been evaluating your Adel suspicions and should be able to put something together about her soon.
Ah but you don't even know what my opinion will be of you. What makes you think that I will suddenly lean in favor of believing you are scum? I mentioned that I've been evaluating your play through this game and will provide my thoughts when I get a chance to. I didn't state that I would lean towards the scummy end of the scale after I was done with my analysis. I still strongly believe that Guardian and Oman are scum.Adel wrote:1. making the bed. Scum players pretending to be scum hunting often broadcast their move before they make it. No sudden moves. the idea is to be consistent and to have a prior reason for placing a vote. Predictable voting behavior is the goal.
Good try, really. I presented my case on Oman awhile back when it was far from the majority opinion and have adamantly supported a lynch of either player. I wanted to lynch Chaos_Omega at the end of Day 1 until the point that he cop claimed, and my vote was on him at the start of Day 2 until I noticed the wagon progressing a bit too quickly for my tastes. I felt like more discussion was necessary before moving into Day 3.Adel wrote:2. Pushing the Guardian and Oman wagons, but not hard enough to stand out. Scum like to fit in with the majority opinion.