Mini 532: Yaw's Split Open Mafia: (Game over)

[mikeburnfire]

If the mafia killed the cop but blocked somebody they THOUGHT was the SK, what would happen if nobody died the next day? Maybe they blocked the SK successfully, but maybe the SK targetted the cop, or maybe the SK didn't kill at all. They wouldn't know.

That's why it makes sense for the mafia to block the cop and try to kill the SK. They already know who the cop is and can keep him neutralized. Now they can try to find the SK, and they must have had a pretty strong hunch about Korlash.

[Holy]

^Maybe the mafia feared the SK more than the Cop (a proven Cop though). Moreover, if the mafia really have a roleblocker that explains this probability: the mafia prefer to block the Cop to prevents investigation, plus prevents the Cop-SK probability; and they chose to murder some other person that they suspect highly as the SK, i.e. they didn't consider MBF as one.

And gah! Sorry Sensfan, I misread. But I still think it wasn't a loaded question, if answered truthfully it's enough for me.

[Holy]

oops, my post meant to refer to Skruff's #724

[bird1111]

Vote Count:
Drunken Piper (1): Skruffs
kabenon007 (1): mikeburnfire
Holy (1): Drunken Piper

Not voting (4): Thanatos, SensFan, kabenon007, Holy

With 7 alive it is 4 to lynch

[Thanatos]

Simple. If they try to RB the SK, they have a fairly low chance of getting it. If it's me, it's a sure thing. Besides that, theymight have been counting on the possibility that the Doctor would be safe for a little while, as the SK might have assumed that the Mafia would kill the Doc.

[bird1111]

This game is dying. I do not like it when my games die. Fix this or be deadlined. Will try to prod anyone who needs it later today.

[mikeburnfire]

My vote is on kabenon, but I'll switch over to Holy if I need to.

I don't have anything else to say, really.

[Drunken Piper]

I also feel like my vote is fine,
as holy's vote and play seeps of mafia's wine.

[Holy]

Actually my current status should be: Not voting (since post #721). Well, who cares anyway -.-;

Fixed.

Unvote. Vote: kabenon007.

I didn't care how scummy am I, by asking questions I got responds, that's all I care. For me finding the last lone scum, i.e. SK is hard, they showed no particular connection to anybody just like a townie.

Out of Topic

@MBF: I love my death scene XD (on your Nightmare Mafia). Satisfying indeed. Lol!

[bird1111]

Skruffs, SensFan, and kabenon007 prodded.

[kabenon007]

I still don't see why I must be the last scum. I get the idea of the scum being roleblocker. That makes sense, but I can't see how I must have been Zhao's scum buddy. Apart from that, what makes you think I am the last scum?

[Skruffs]

I have decide, Korlash you will always be my scum, just help me, please, to lynch your scum mate, okay...

Oh I feel so special now <3

But in order for that to happen I would have to direct you towards a game in which I am actually scum... And not already dead... which... well a game like that does not exist at this moment... sad panda... T_T

But I will do my best to help you lynch Someone's scum mate this game

(Pssst... Phate! Who is your scum mate? Quick man, your making me look bad!)

Um... Well technically I have the power of a super awesome mind.. but other then that.. yeah I'm pretty worthless...

Also I too think the Role Switcher is king here. But the re-opener is kinda dull until people start dying you know. At this very second that player is kinda worthless. Then is we lynch an unpowered tonight they are worthless too. But yeah, later on they become useful.

Wouldn't it suck if we lynched the reopener today? XD

Vote: Korlash until he starts posting theories that can be disproven by Occam's Razor. Followed by a cinquian(nope, couldn't resist).

Hmmm... Occam's Razor... Ok...

How about instead of Phate's plan we instead don't out the unpowered, and just RANDOMLY assign it to a player hoping they were unpowered! Hmmm... Not really sure if that is accurate in this case. I am very bad at making theories I

want

to be disproven you know...

Cinquian
Misspelled theme
reading, writing, reciting
It's actually pronounced cinquain
Cinquain

>.>
<.<
<.>

Did you mean you are an unpowered scum? lol, j/k :p

I think Holy is on to something! Lynch DP! The unpowered scum! =D

Sorry for hte delay, had a long weekend. *yawn*

I am happy with either of the two main players Korlash hinted at above. Holy or The Role Reopener

Also getting vibes that in deed teh SK is the roleblocker, now, not the cop.

Would anyone like to CLAIM the former mason, and clear up any misconceptions we all may have about the role??

[Holy]

I still don't see why I must be the last scum. I get the idea of the scum being roleblocker. That makes sense, but I can't see how I must have been Zhao's scum buddy. Apart from that, what makes you think I am the last scum?

Not because I think that you were his mason-buddy, but because your fallacy feed attempt.

Here:

I see what Holy is saying. Instead of trying to determine from our two claimers which is cop, and possibly accidentally lynching our cop, we go after their claimed "confirmed scum."

Can't use Phate

, as that would defeat the purpose of the plan. But if we lynch QB and he is scum, then Phate wasn't lying and Thanatos is scum, and if QB is town, then Phate was lying and we lynch him.

I think it could work.

(on Day 2) Phate was one of the "confirmed scum" by Than. Why can't we use him?

[SensFan]

I'm here.

[kabenon007]

You took that post out of context, Holy. At that time, Phate was the lynch candidate, or the main one at least, and so I thought your plan could work, and so I said that for the plan to work, we shouldn't lynch Phate or Than. Context context context.

[mikeburnfire]

This game is going idle., but there's nothing I can do. I have already made my decision, as have Skruffs, DP, and Holy. Thanatos, SensFan, kabenon007, it's your move.

[SensFan]

Vote: kabenon

Let's get this game moving.

[kabenon007]

I'm waiting for Holy's response to my post, and then depending on her answer, I will cast my vote.

[Holy]

@kabenon007: My plan was to lynch either Phate or QB, just hadn't decide which.
The point is, I thought that you were trying to save your Phate-buddy, but felt hesitant because the town was more in favor with lynching Phate than QB-lynch although you said that plan could work, I thought you were just afraid appeared too scummy if you insist with it. Anyway both was scum, so of course you just followed the town, because you knew either way you would end-up lost a mate, chosing a Phate lynch was a save move for you (for the town eyes) although at the same time you did announced your "Can't use Phate" theory.

[bird1111]

Retractable deadline 2 weeks from now@12:00 PM EST.

[Skruffs]

Am I voting HOly? I think Holy is a good choice.

[Thanatos]

Yeah, I've reread D-3, and decided that of the 4 people who are potential targets, I agree with MBF. Kabenon is the most likely of the bunch to be the Scum RB, due largely to his attempt to derail the game into hunting the SK, when finding the scum is so much simpler.

Deadlined, I'm comfertable putting him at L-1.

Vote:kabenon007

[kabenon007]

And I'm gonna

unvote, vote Holy

, cuz I think her attack on me and her response was stupid. Hindsight is twenty-twenty, Holy. The only reason that looks suspicious on me is because I made a comment about Phate back then, he turned up scum, and now you are just finding coincidences to suit your accusations.

[Thanatos]

Yeah. Holy's my second most suspicious target right now.

[Skruffs]

Yeah, I've reread D-3, and decided that of the 4 people who are potential targets, I agree with MBF. Kabenon is the most likely of the bunch to be the Scum RB, due largely to his attempt to derail the game into hunting the SK, when finding the scum is so much simpler.

Deadlined, I'm comfertable putting him at L-1.

Vote:kabenon007

Why do people keep suggesting that the SK is not scum?
Scum is scum.