Scummies 2008 Nominations! (Deadline: 1/15)

Guardian · Post Post #22 (isolation #0) » Tue Jan 15, 2008 1:01 pm

nominate: Thok

for best performance as a replacement in Open 19: Nightless.

I think that's a good category to have, and Thok's play fits perfectly there. If we are unwilling to have that category, I think he merits consideration for best performance, town.

Guardian · Post Post #61 (isolation #1) » Sun Feb 17, 2008 7:39 am

viewtopic.php?p=936562#936562

Nominate Xyl for Rebels in the Palace -- Best Setup of 2008.

Guardian · Post Post #63 (isolation #2) » Sun Feb 17, 2008 8:57 am

It is the best setup of 2008. Hands down.

Guardian · Post Post #101 (isolation #3) » Mon Mar 03, 2008 12:10 pm

viewtopic.php?t=6663

Pooky maked good setup.

I nominate him for best setup

. I was wrong, this was even better than Rebels in the Palace. It changes how you must think for this mafias game.

Guardian · Post Post #108 (isolation #4) » Fri Mar 07, 2008 8:44 am

Mr. Flay wrote:I think it would be best if Best Performance ("Oscar") went to a group effort, now that we have both the Paragon of Mafia Hunters and Don Corleone awards (plus Best SK). So far, I've organized nominations that way, to avoid too much repetition...

I disagree completely. Best Performance and Paragon/Don C are completely different to me. Best Performance equate to a flash a brilliance for one game. The other two equate to a good year.

Guardian · Post Post #110 (isolation #5) » Fri Mar 07, 2008 8:46 am

Flay, I really don't like how you organized the awards. Your view of what the awards mean is very different from mine

.

Done Corleone and Paragon shouldn't go to anyone for one game!

Guardian · Post Post #112 (isolation #6) » Fri Mar 07, 2008 8:49 am

We could have (best performance group -town) and best performance single -town),

but i really think don corleone and paragon should go to individuals with a great track record all year

Guardian · Post Post #114 (isolation #7) » Fri Mar 07, 2008 9:01 am

I agree with 113

.

Guardian · Post Post #128 (isolation #8) » Mon Mar 10, 2008 5:44 am

His replacing was contraversial, but

nominate Glork

for best replacement, he replaced as a tree stump in Thok's tree stump game, and won the game for town.

viewtopic.php?t=6526

award theory:

I think we should have two categories:
Best replacement (e.g., person who replaces often over the year, general do-godder).
And Best performance as a replacement (which all the current nominations have gone to).

Guardian · Post Post #131 (isolation #9) » Mon Mar 10, 2008 5:58 am

mith wrote:I'll
second
that (Glork, Tree Stump), though I dislike the implication that he "won the game" for us.

Sowwy, he certainly helped out a lot, though!

(Wouldn't that fall under "Best Performance: Replacement", though?)

Yes, if my two-tier system were implemented. Right now, there is a one-tier system in Flay's post, so I thought I'd nominate it as best replacement, to avoid confusion...

seems I created some x).

Guardian · Post Post #135 (isolation #10) » Mon Mar 10, 2008 6:35 am

Also, did Pooky get "some award" for marathon day last year? He should have

Maybe this year we can have a "best marathon day" and call it the pooky award.

Guardian · Post Post #149 (isolation #11) » Mon Mar 17, 2008 12:45 pm

Mastermind of Sin wrote:
Nominate: cicero

Award: Best Performance in a Losing Effort

Game: Lost Boys Mafia

cicero replaced into this game (which ended up being 182 pages long) and really put a lot of effort into playing. As a completely vanilla role whose real claim probably would've gotten him lynched, cicero copied someone else's claim to save himself and then aggressively set to hunting the cult. Although the cult ended up winning, I feel that cicero's effort was amazing, and he really helped the town as much as he possibly could by himself. Even as a replacement, he ended up with more posts than anyone else in the game.

second

Guardian · Post Post #154 (isolation #12) » Wed Mar 19, 2008 1:56 pm

Adel for funniest scummer

viewtopic.php?p=979331#979331

I'm sure there have been and will be more.

Guardian · Post Post #190 (isolation #13) » Thu Apr 03, 2008 6:18 pm

viewtopic.php?p=1006137#1006137

That post made me want to

nominate Pie_is_good for funniest scummer

.

This post too: http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... ht=#998731

ed: this too viewtopic.php?p=1011042#1011042

ed2: this too viewtopic.php?t=8126

ed3: viewtopic.php?p=1029234#1029234

Guardian · Post Post #194 (isolation #14) » Sun Apr 06, 2008 10:58 am

What? I thought it was legitimately really funny...

Guardian · Post Post #243 (isolation #15) » Thu May 15, 2008 8:07 am

Reading over past games...

Nominate: Mr. Stoofer

Award: Best Role

Role: Sigmund Freud (Lie Detector)

Guardian · Post Post #245 (isolation #16) » Thu May 15, 2008 9:24 am

Nominations and seconds so far:

Player Awards:
Best Role Claim
- "Johnny Cochrane" Award
- clammy in NG 586, nominated by DizzyIzzyB13, seconded by Aergor, thirded by Dean Harper, etc.
Funniest Role Claim
- "George W Bush" Award
- Greasy Spot in Open 61 - nominated by The Fonz, seconded by farside22, thirded by Killah Nine
- Awesome Pants in Newbie 516 - nominated by destructor, seconded by gorckat, thirded by Incognito, etc.
- Albert B. Rampage in Countdown of the Illuminati - nominated by dahill.
Best Performance by a Team
- "Goodfellas" Award

Can go to either a Pro-Town or Anti-Town group
- The Town of Open 58 - nominated by Incognito (self-nom)
- The Newbies of NG 520 - Nominated by farside22 (self-nom), seconded by PokerFace, thirded by Adel, fourthed by Lawrencelot
- The Town of NG 563 - Nominated by Arafax.
- The Town of Mini 542 - Nominated by Rogueben.
Best Performance by an Individual (Pro-Town)
- "Oscar" Award
- VitaminR in Open 19 - nominated by Simenon
- Albert B. Rampage in Mafia 72 - nominated by Mastermind of Sin
- curiouskarmadog in Mafia 69 - nominated by cicero, seconded by Dead Rikimaru, thirded by ZONEACE
Best Performance by an Individual (Scum)
- "Oscar" Award
- Y in Newbie 546 - nominated by Scigatt, seconded by Hjallti, thirded by PokerFace
- Crub in Mini 534 - nominated by gorckat
- Peers in Mafia 69 - nominated by Mr. Flay
- Shy Guy in AITP 2 - nominated by Zindaras, seconded by Cogito Ergo Scum, thirded by armlx, etc.
- shaft.ed in House Mafia - nominated by armlx, seconded by Erg0.
- clammy in NG 586, nominated by DizzyIzzyB13, seconded by Aergor, thirded by Dean Harper, etc.
Best SK
- "Hannibal Lector" Award

Possibly superseded by Best Performance by an Individual (Scum)?
- mikeburnfire in Mini 532, Nominated by Skruffs, seconded by bird1111, thirded by shaft.ed, etc.
- Battle Mage in Food Fight Mafia, Nominated by The Fonz, seconded by Erg0
Best New Player

should have joined the site no later than ~Oct. 2007
- Mizzy in Newbie 520 - Nominated by farside22, seconded by AShadowedHeart
- Jitsu for Mini 518 - nominated by Mr. Flay, seconded by Adel, thirded by curiouskarmadog
Best Mafia Catcher
- "Paragon of Mafia Hunters" Award
Most Cunning Manipulation
- "The Don Corleone" Award
Most Improved Player
- Xtoxm, nominated by DrippingGoofBall, seconded by Oman.
Moderator
Awards:
Best Role
(new or adaptation) - "Flying Pumpkin That Shoots Lazers Out Of Its Ass" Award
- Mr. Stoofer for Sigmund Freud (Lie Detector) - nominated by Guardian.
Most Enjoyable Game
(Large [free market/normal])
- Dead Rikimaru for Mafia 69 - nominated by Mr Stoofer, seconded by Hjallti, thirded by ooba
- Scruffs (replacement mod) for Mafia 71 - nominated by Porochaz
- Mr. Stoofer for Pirates vs. Ninjas! - Nominated by ooba, seconded by Thok, thirded by hasdgfas, etc.
Most Enjoyable Game
(Mini [theme/normal])
- Guardian for iPick, nominated by shaft.ed, seconded by hasdgfas, thirded by xyzzy, etc.
Best Flavor Text
- "Paperback Writer" Award

formerly Best Night Scene(s)
- NabokovNabokov for Mini 518 - nominated by Mr. Flay, seconded by Jitsu, thirded by Oman
- undo for Mini 501 - nominated by Hjallti, seconded by DrippingGoofball, thirded by Oman
- Dead Rikimaru for Mafia 69 - nominated by Claus, seconded by ooba, thirded by curiouskarmadog, etc.
Best Setup
- 'Rebels in the Palace' by Xylthixlm - nominated by Guardian (setup has not been run yet, as of March 2008)
- 'Masons & Mafia' by PookyTheMagicalBear - nominated by Guardian, seconded by TheSweatpantsNinja, thirded by Thesp
- 'Contagion' by Skruffs - nominated by Battle Mage
Best Performance in a Losing Cause/Cassandra Award
??
New Award proposal - nominated by Sarcastro, seconded by Maz Medias, thirded by Glork, etc.
- cicero in Lost Boys Mafia, nominated by Mastermind of Sin, seconded by Guardian, thirded by Adel, etc.
Best Replacement
??
New Award proposal - nominated by Guardian
- Thok in Open 19 - nominated by Guardian, seconded by Adel, thirded by Marmalade, etc.
- Scruffs (replacement mod) for Mafia 71 - nominated by Porochaz, seconded by Mr. Flay
- Glork in Mini 517 - nominated by Guardian, seconded by mith
- cicero in Lost Boys Mafia, nominated by Mastermind of Sin.
Best Performance by a Newbie
??
New Award proposal - nominated by The Fonz, was seconded, thirded, etc.

Non-Game

Awards:

Funniest Player
- "The Coffee on the Monitor" Award
- Thestatusquo for this post (among others) - nominated by Mr Stoofer, seconded by Mr. Flay
- DrippingGoofball for this post (among others) - nominated by Mr. Flay, seconded by Marmalade, thirded by Battle Mage, additional info by shaft.ed, etc..
- Anthesis for this post (among others) - nominated by Battle Mage, seconded by JordanA24
- Adel for this post (among others) - nominated by Guardian, seconded by neko2086, thirded by Oman, etc.
- Pie_is_good for this post (among others) - nominated by Guardian, seconded by Mastermind of Sin.
- Battle Mage (for no specific post), nominated by JordanA24.
Behind the Scenes
- "Name Should Be In Orange" Award
- Mr. Flay, nominated by Mr Stoofer.
Best Contribution to Mafia Discusion
- "Professor Mafia" Award
???

Guardian · Post Post #246 (isolation #17) » Thu May 15, 2008 9:25 am

The above is not complete; there were a few nominations I wasn't sure were serious, or that I wasn't sure where to put. Also, some nominations might need to be re-organized into the newly nominated categories, such as "best performance by a newbie".

In any event, I hope that saves whomever updates in next some times. Whew!

ps: took about an hour!!

Guardian · Post Post #247 (isolation #18) » Thu May 15, 2008 9:29 am

And with that, I'll make it outdated

.

Nominate: Kison

for

Best Performance in a Losing Cause

iPick.

By all rights he should have won; the setup *twist* that no one figured out hosed him ^_^.

Guardian · Post Post #324 (isolation #19) » Tue Jul 08, 2008 3:03 pm

nominate SSF for best setup/enjoyable game mini normal

had a good balanced setup, well mod-ed from what I could see, all around solid job.

viewtopic.php?t=8224

Guardian · Post Post #399 (isolation #20) » Mon Aug 11, 2008 10:36 am

Mr. Flay wrote:
Claus wrote:Hmmm, I just noticed that the first page needs some updating - there are a lot of missing nominations there.
Yeah, this thread has been WAY Down on my list of priorities; if somebody wants to quote and update the first post, I'll be glad to post it back to the first page, but I don't have time right now.

Post 245 I mostly updated it. So that is a good start///you could paste that to page 1.

Guardian · Post Post #636 (isolation #21) » Wed Dec 10, 2008 11:03 am

Thestatusquo wrote:I meant guardian. Equally shocking. I don't know why oman popped out of my fingers.

lies.

Guardian · Post Post #638 (isolation #22) » Thu Dec 11, 2008 4:57 pm

Nominate Skruffs for best flavor text in Contagion Mafia.

Second Skruffs for best setup in Contagion Mafia.

A game I wish I had played in.

Third shaft.ed for most cunning manipulator; his performance in Adel's nightmare is representative.
Second Kison for most cunning manipulator; his performance in iPick is representative.

Guardian · Post Post #695 (isolation #23) » Fri Jan 02, 2009 2:11 am

If we're being technical, the game ending hammer happened @ Wed Dec 31, 2008 10:40 pm.