No Effort Mafia 2.1 (Game Over)

[Regfan]

Scum Hunting

Original Roll String: 3d6

3 6-Sided Dice: (3, 5, 1) = 9

Persuasion

Original Roll String: 3d6

3 6-Sided Dice: (2, 2, 5) = 9

Towniness as Town

Original Roll String: 2d6

2 6-Sided Dice: (3, 3) = 6

Towniness as Scum

Original Roll String: 2d6

2 6-Sided Dice: (5, 2) = 7

Nemesis: Pieguyn

[Regfan]

Think I've got Pie beat here.

Hoping CMM doesn't draw scum, he just wins if he does.

[Regfan]

N getting all the persuasion in the family I see, some things never change.

[Regfan]

Firebringer is as god as confirmed mafia ftr.

[Regfan]

Firebringer(4) N Bins Regfan ConManMick

N has 15 scumhunting, Bins 10, I have 13 and CMM has 11

[Regfan]

ConnorJC ( 7 ) Zoraster Dwlee99 Something_Smart Shadoweh randomidget TheRealGin-N-Tonic Aronis

[Regfan]

Connor is almost certainly scum too, all names that were voting him there have 10+ Scumhunting.

Connor + Firebringer so far.

[Regfan]

Two leading wagons are scum and I' voting Bulge who's spewed town.

Sad.

[Regfan]

Do we know the size of the scum team to submit guess for?

[Regfan]

Eh, not sold on PP being scum.

I think Equinox may be sleeper scum here.

XY and Bulge both look very much like spewed town.

[Regfan]

Went for an early submission of Creature+Connor+Fire+Equi+Transcend+Midget

[Regfan]

The Bulge ( 3 ) Creature ConnorJC Something_Smart

Welcome to lock town.

[Regfan]

xyzzy ( 9 ) Zoraster gigabyteTroubadour

ConnorJC Firebringer

Ser Arthur Dayne randomidget Transcend TheRealGin-N-Tonic PenguinPower

This is scum trying to stop it being SvS wagons and push a townie, I expect another 2 cum inside here.

[Regfan]

SomthingSmart & Bins are also effectively clears.

[Regfan]

MTD is also very close to clear. Shadoweh looks okayish I guess.

[Regfan]

T-Bone looks good outside of his N vote.

Fro99er has a very reasonable chance of being mafia.

[Regfan]

Haha.

Gin could be scum here. And I think we might just flat out lose to ConManMick.

[Regfan]

can i spoil the whole team? its not like any of us are playing.

Rather you didn't.

[Regfan]

So I've got it as xyzzy, The Bulge, SS, Bins and MTD are almost certainly town. Shadoweh/T-Bone/Beeboy/Majjify look town enough that I'd let them be for now.

[Regfan]

if Implosion doesn't become a wagon tomorrow he's almost certainly scum, him getting (2) as town but only ever getting a maximum of 4 votes in comparison to the 23 that Wisdom got with the same stat is a big red flag.

[Regfan]

Yeah actually Implosion is just scum regardless I think, he got 12 for scumhunting but has been on almost all of the flipped town and very rarely has been on scum; the votes off wagon for the most part are on my town reads too, none of the flipped scum have voted him either and stronger town players like N have voted him.

[Regfan]

My guy voted for implosion, so he's confirmed scum

I've got your back.

[Regfan]

@Implosion it's possible that the rolls just haven't generated enough persuasion to have you properly wagoned yet but the fact the votes you did get were from mostly high scuhunting players is suspect as is your voting history. I also think as town you likely take up a vig shot due to your number hasn't happened yet, fits more with you being scum.

Regfan what about me

Just because I'm garbage right now and voting literally 1 vote people :/ I'm trying my best! The mafia PRODIGY will shine through.

I believe in you! But in all seriousness I didn't bother giving read on you because there's some votes that look objectively bad for you but I kind of town read your in thread comments (lol) so I'll hold off on that.

[Regfan]

implosion ( 4 ) MTD Something_Smart Transcend Aronis

MTD has 13, SS has 12, Transcend has 12, Aronis has 12.

Think we're dealing with Implosion + Frogger + 1?

[Regfan]

for a game called no effort mafia, there sure are quite a few people putting effort.
i suggest mod killing them for going against the spirit of this game.

Cruel!

(but i promise im town)

With the data provided so far you're one of the towniest people in the room.

[Regfan]

Some more votes to Implosion please!

[Regfan]

Looking at the persuasiveness numbers and the current votes I think the day ends in a SAD lynch.

[Regfan]

Yeah, at this point I think Implosions just outed mafia, how can they not see it???? Why am I voting SS, he's super likely town here.

Agree with the CMM wagon being scum driven.

[Regfan]

RIP SAD.

I submitted my second guess btw; Frogger+Equinox+Implosion.

[Regfan]

Something Special probably scum.

He's consistently voted scum all game (All 3 of them) and has a "S" of 4 with no wagon ever really forming on him (Whereas a "T" of 8), super unlikely he's scum.

[Regfan]

My new best friend Implosion says this con man is a con, seems legit

I didn't want to be the bearer of bad news but uhhhh your friend kind of murders people at night.

[Regfan]

SAD if you mslynch me here there will be words.

[Regfan]

But you started my wagon :/ I'm just OMGUSing.

This is true. Truce? Lets join the glorious Implosion wagon that's appeared.

[Regfan]

xyzzy murdered Zoraster to prevent his own mslynch from being posted!

[Regfan]

Not even Equibot is this competent as scum!

This is true.

I WOULD NEVER HAVE FUCKING LYNCHED XYZZY THIS IS RIGGED THEY WERE SO FUCKING OBVTOWN THIS GAME THIS TOWN IS FUCKING AWFUL

Haha he was a scum pushed wagon on D2 to attempt to deal with three heavily pressured wagons on scum (Creature/Connor/Fire), he was as close to clear as could be. We dun goofed. Implosion is still scum, Frogger also has a decently high chance of being so too. Last one could be one of like 10 people.

[Regfan]

Shit, I'm caught.

Spoiler:

Post 216 -> Post 218

But the only stances I'm confident based on what we're been given is that Implosion is scum and Bulge/SS/Bins/MTD are town. I'd like to think Shadoweh/T-Bone/Beeboy/Majjify are town too but it's based on weaker reasoning.

[Regfan]

Lets take a chance; I'm going to call all of MTD, Bulge, SS, Bins, Shadoweh, T-Bone, Beeboy, Majjify, CMM, Giga, Radiant, Nahdia, random Transcend, Equinox and Zoraster town. 16 town reads ain't bad.

That leaves a scum pool of Implosion + 2 of [Frogger, Kuro, McMenno, Gin, Penguin, SAD]

[Regfan]

If CMM is scum he's p much unlynchable...

Not untrue but he's voting a

lot

of scum, almost N level accuracy and the sheer number of times that CMM has been wagoned points towards his T (6) being the case instead of his S (11) especially since he's mostly been wagoned by scum or weaker players. I've submitted my new guess and probably final (Probably won't be around tomorrow when Zor finishes the game) as Implosion/Penguin/Gin. Would love to hear your guess.

[Regfan]

How do y'all get town reads?

Combination of factors -- one being the case alone is fairly weak but several of them happening for a particular player increase the odds of them being town quite significantly; frequency of voting scum, frequency of scum voting said player which is obviously strengthened in situations where it looks like scum are trying to find a counterwagon. Analysis of Town v Scum number, low scum number and high town number and never being wagoned is a fairly big indication of being town, similarly high scum number and low town number and being wagoned a lot is another indication of being town. Never being voted by any town players with a high scumhunting rating is another one too.

[Regfan]

Lol SAD, glad I kept you in my scum pool.

[Regfan]

When are we going to lynch the obvscum that is implosion?

[Regfan]

how has implosion not died yet

No idea, I highly doubt he endgames us though.

[Regfan]

You're not aware which of the kills are yours are you Shadoweh? If you shot N I'll be sad. He only voted 5 players throughout D1 and D2 and 4 of them were mafia.

[Regfan]

Hmm, I'm willing to let the N (And CMM) kills slide if you really did vig Pie, did the whole game a big favour there.

[Regfan]

Lets take a chance; I'm going to call all of

MTD, Bulge, SS, Bins, Shadoweh, T-Bone, Beeboy, Majjify, CMM, Giga, Radiant, Nahdia, random Transcend, Equinox and Zoraster

town. 16 town reads ain't bad.

That leaves a scum pool of

Implosion

+ 2 of [

Frogger, Kuro, McMenno, Gin,

Penguin, SAD

]

Fairly happy with my town reads and ergo scum pool via PoE.

[Regfan]

Sad that Implosion got me mslynched before going down.

Day 10: RegFan the Vanilla Townie was lynched

I win, bitch.

At least I voted scum and didn't get vigged!