Mini 1875: Pine's Death Trap Post Game - Town win!

[RadiantCowbells]

I think my cop claim is a distraction and I don't think that under any circumstances I will manage to eat two night kills to make my role actually relevant SO

have you figured it out yet?

[Vifam]

No I have no idea what you're getting at

[RadiantCowbells]

I wouldn't expect you to.

[Vifam]

@__@

[Transcend]

Why not join my forming bw then

[RadiantCowbells]

Because I am busy voting Vifam.

[Vifam]

So basically you're a modified cop but we've gotta go through two night phases to get an actual result

[Vifam]

Do I understand it now, sensei?

[mattblackguy]

Vifam's hammer doesn't make any sense from a townie's perspective. Vifam said he didn't think Gerry was scum, and that he didn't want to lynch Gerry because "I like him". Doesn't make sense to hammer him before he even gets a chance to claim then.

[Vifam]

You'd be surprised

[JarJarDrinks]

have you figured it out yet?

Yeah. Ur scum and making shit up to not get lynched.

Am I close?

[Grendel]

I think Transcend might be scum and that scum might have a role cop.

why do you say scum might have a rolecop?

I think he is saying that because if scum had a role cop who copped RC then they know that RC was a power role.

Which would make sense given that Trans is defending RC while simultaneously dismissing him.

@RC

That's what you're saying right?

[JarJarDrinks]

Vifam's hammer doesn't make any sense from a townie's perspective. Vifam said he didn't think Gerry was scum, and that he didn't want to lynch Gerry because "I like him". Doesn't make sense to hammer him before he even gets a chance to claim then.

This is all true. RC is still the lynch today.

[Grendel]

It weird, because I did think that RC said it was a reaction test yesterday.

Maybe I read something someone else said

[Cooperative Sheep]

I don't see much advantage to sitting around communally trying to figure out someone's PR at a point a surprising number of the people doing so aren't voting said slot. Like, if you don't think they're scum - what are you doing?

That's pretty much what I was thinking: but I think that on principle I have to lynch Zifam today.

No, we really don't. Especially if you present up the policy lynch angle. Was the play bad? Sure. Can you show me Vifam being brazen scum in other games? Because if you can't, then I don't see the value of the case.

The Transcend case has value - he is contributing nothing, and had suspect vote movement yesterday considering flips, and also is a slot that works within the confines of a 'don't jar the status quo' potential kill.

Did you all forget to to read Gerrys role?

He flipped cop, RC claimed cop. This isn't rocket science.

Considering that RC claimed 'a variety of cop' it actual isn't open and shut either. It's not a direct counter flip. If I scumread RC more independantly I'd have an issue - but I don't, so this case isn't overly compelling.

What's your take on Transcend's contributions to the game thus far?

Alisae is a weird kill seeing as most people had key widely townread, I don't remember anyone having any strong townreads from Alisae

Fear of Doc or a status quo kill would be my working theory.
What's yours?

[Transcend]

VOTE: sheep

[RadiantCowbells]

I am bulletproof and I claimed what I did to bait nightkills. I claimed the way I did to minimize the odds of being counterclaimed and it worked. I am actually pretty good at that.
If you don't believe it coming from today note the point where I said that there was no doc in the setup. I said that for a reason.

[Transcend]

i believe it

why are you guys so fucking dense lol

[Transcend]

Grendel wagon yesterday sucked and it contained {Keyser, matt, Sheep, JarJar, Vifam}

I bet at least 2 scum were here.

[JarJarDrinks]

Can you show me Vifam being brazen scum in other games? Because if you can't, then I don't see the value of the case.

I can show you RC fakeclaiming cop as scum in other games.

What's your take on Transcend's contributions to the game thus far?

I think they suck.

[Transcend]

JarJar's play today, although very aggressive and questionable, feels kinda towny.

I think matt is town as well

{Keyser, Sheep, Vifam} is a safe lynch pool for me today imo.

[Transcend]

I can show you RC fakeclaiming cop as scum in other games.

I bet he's done it as both alignments.

You guys really need to figure out what's NAI and what isn't.

[JarJarDrinks]

Lol he claims BP cause if he claims a cop role and doesn't get lynched today, he can explain why he wasn't night killed.

[RadiantCowbells]

JJD I realize that you are laser focused on the one game where I claimed cop as scum where I was actually scum cop but just stop.

[RadiantCowbells]

There's a reason everyone but you in this game treats me claiming things as NAI. The superficial similarities between this game and the NY game do not make me scum in this one.