are you kidding broIn post 1294, Dunnstral wrote:Alright, you've shown that thinkbig's read on Alisae has been changing. Now show how that's scummy, or did you have some other point?
His read isn't "changing" it's completely made up.
are you kidding broIn post 1294, Dunnstral wrote:Alright, you've shown that thinkbig's read on Alisae has been changing. Now show how that's scummy, or did you have some other point?
Why are you just glossing over this? That isn't a normal progression at all!!!In post 1299, Regfan wrote:Realeo - TB did state his reads and where he was at before stating intent to hammer, I'd like reasoning behind some of his reads but he's stated he's willing to get to those when he's at a computer next which is reasonable. As for Alisea, his read has been changing on them throughout the game (Which is natural to happen for townies), he had them as a strong town read early on, scum read her for the fake hammer thing and then moved them to null which seems like a fair placement overall given his stance on them; he'll be getting around to going through their ISO shortly and we can judge him based on it then.
How did you think Traitor played beforehand? Surely if you thought the mafia knew who the traitor was, there would be no difference between the two roles (beyond Traitor not being able to communicate).In post 1255, Kop wrote:I think I may have misread the whole Mafia PM's.In post 1148, Dunnstral wrote:Uh, Antihero was traitor? not a good?
Surely if the two of you are suggesting that thinkbig moved off of antihero because he knew he was the traitor, you can point to where thinkbig would have known that antihero was a traitor? Some kind of tell, or soft, or the way Ah acted?
Coming out hard on a maf buddy doesn't scream "traitor" to me.
So on that said, thinkbig may be town after all. After rereading the PM's set out in first page, I don't forsee a traitor coming out that hard, now that I know the traitor only knows who the the mafia are, but mafia don't know who the traitor is.
I know that you've linked me the game, but can you explain in simple simple terms how the mafia traitor role was different to the mafia traitor role in this game?In post 1258, Kop wrote:I totally forgot that I had already researched this point and got side drawn from it.In post 1256, Regfan wrote:I find that hard to believe Kop given you've played this exact setup before and made the following comment in this post:
But scum don't know who the traitor is though? There is the chance that they could end up night killing him, which is a risk because it doesn't help them that way though.
I know I was a mafia traitor on another site, but ended up getting night killed by my own team mates day one, they didn't know I was the traitor.
Yes whilst I agree I have played as a traitor before, however it wasn't in this exact setup. This setup is slightly different to the one I participated on another site.
Why?
yo Desperado, you're not really trying very hard to convince people. If Regfan is right, and ThinkBig did act as town, who would you want to lynch? It is likely that by the end of the day the ThinkBig wagon will not be as viable as the beginning of the day, and you'll be forced to choose a new wagon, if so who would you want to lynch?In post 1327, Desperado wrote:I don't care, reg. I want this dead.
Hmm?In post 1332, ThinkBig wrote:Going back through kop, I have a difficult time believing his roleblocker claim for the following reasons:
- His dumbtell is demonstrated to be probably false. He has played this set-up before and has clearly demonstrated a knowledge of how the mafia traitor works.
- I can brush off forgetting about playing this past setup. I cannot, however, look past an experienced player not knowing how a role is supposed to work, especially when you can easily see it in the sample PMs.
It's really convenient that the person that he claimed to have RB was the person who was NK'd (and who flipped vanilla town).
Regfan doesn't agree the the argument that it was a display of Scum Theatre.In post 1324, Desperado wrote:If your town read on ThinkBig boils down to "He isn't good at this game" then I feel comfortable not sheeping you on himIn post 1273, Regfan wrote:/Headdesk. Majority of players don't alter their reads because their town reads have them, especially someone that's as inexperienced as ThingBig. This is pretty bad point given who you're talking about.