Current Vote Count:
With 8 votes available, it takes 5 votes to hammer.
BigYoshiFan is V/LA until 1/12.
Countdown: (expired on 2017-01-21 21:00:00)
Ok, let me put it this way: There's a killer on the loose, and Math suspects them to be Ankamius. Tracking Ank would have given us conclusive info of whom he shot if he did at all. In other words, we would know for sure today i And did shoot CFJ or not. If he did he's confirmed Scum. If he didn't he's confirmed Town (given the current status of the game and the fact there was only one NK performed and it was most definitely committed by scum).In post 10148, BigYoshiFan wrote:Ehhh, I don't know if I agree with this.In post 10146, Almost50 wrote: Tell me something: Why did you track Nahdia and not Ank?? I mean, you did suspect him more, right? And he didn't hammer scum, so I would have tried to verify HIM over Nahdia if I were you.. (if I were TOWN!Yo, that is)
They would have a much better chance at confirming Nahdia than incriminating Ank in my opinion, even if they were more suspicious of Ank I think verifying Nahdia would make more sense.
Two things:In post 10152, Ankamius wrote:Just going to point out that to anyone in the neighborhood, my actions should not make any sense as scum.
I'm very curious to see if I'm getting designated mislynch today.
Tracking me is not a good idea because we've already shown that a no-result doesn't mean much of anything.In post 10151, Almost50 wrote:Ok, let me put it this way: There's a killer on the loose, and Math suspects them to be Ankamius. Tracking Ank would have given us conclusive info of whom he shot if he did at all. In other words, we would know for sure today i And did shoot CFJ or not. If he did he's confirmed Scum. If he didn't he's confirmed Town (given the current status of the game and the fact there was only one NK performed and it was most definitely committed by scum).In post 10148, BigYoshiFan wrote:Ehhh, I don't know if I agree with this.In post 10146, Almost50 wrote: Tell me something: Why did you track Nahdia and not Ank?? I mean, you did suspect him more, right? And he didn't hammer scum, so I would have tried to verify HIM over Nahdia if I were you.. (if I were TOWN!Yo, that is)
They would have a much better chance at confirming Nahdia than incriminating Ank in my opinion, even if they were more suspicious of Ank I think verifying Nahdia would make more sense.
Nahdia on the other hand was supposed to target someone with a night action to prove they still posses that JK ability, and confirmed themselves.
Now why confirm ONE when you can confirm TWO??
Please note they do share -at least- one PT to organize their action efficiently, and Math -being the brilliant tactician and mastermind of Mafia- would know better than to use their one shot power sub-optimally.
This gives me the heebie jeebies. Mentioned why in the hood.In post 10158, Almost50 wrote:So where is your voe on Math then? You supported a lynch there yesterday and today you say they're almost certainly scum, so I'd appreciate some support pushing them now and seeing where everybody else stands. I mean, you can retract your vote later and wait for the hammer if that's what you want, but at least give this wagon a jump start.
In post 10161, MathBlade wrote:This gives me the heebie jeebies. Mentioned why in the hood.In post 10158, Almost50 wrote:So where is your voe on Math then? You supported a lynch there yesterday and today you say they're almost certainly scum, so I'd appreciate some support pushing them now and seeing where everybody else stands. I mean, you can retract your vote later and wait for the hammer if that's what you want, but at least give this wagon a jump start.
VOTE: Almost50
I think Ank can only vote Town. That is my hunch. Going to check the game to confirm later. I think A50 is trying to play both sides and push Ank but at the same time get a mislynch on me.
@Almost50In post 10145, Almost50 wrote:That was Mathblade claiming BP to claim they were shot at thus earning town credit. Such claim (being shot at) was nullified by Yoshi's claim.In post 9372, callforjudgement wrote:I get the strong feeling that someone has overclaimed this game (i.e. claimed a stronger role than they actually have); such a player is highly likely to be scum.
CFJ was actually a loud voice opposing Math's schemes (mainly for lynching me, but also other moon-logic including Math being "Conf!Town" to which CFJ never gave in).
So I went back to look a Maxous' ISO, and sure enough .. I found what I wanted.
Bolded, underlined and put in Italic: The top two "Town" reads of Maxous were SirCakez and Creature (Creature is now Mathblade). These were the first two he targeted to recruit after his death (apparently he thought they would outlive many others and was proven right).In post 962, Maxous wrote:SirCakez is kinda town
Creature is town
I think Ankamius is town though admittedly i've been wrong about him a couple of times in the past so yeah.
SlySLy is town
Pepto is scum
Gamma Emerald is awkward as hell town that is easy to nitpick at (and a possible counter-wagon attempt from peptobislawl)
Nahdia is trying too hard to redeem Giga's slot. They ain't succeeding.
And here he is reasserting his Town read on Creature, and lining up lynches on Townies (Pepto was Narna's sot).In post 1248, Maxous wrote:...well that list is MY town-reads anyway (plus creature) so :dealwithit:
additonal note: if pepto does end flipping town, i'm prolly gonna lynch mcmenno
More defending of the Creature slot in particular.In post 2848, Maxous wrote:then just vote menno please.In post 2844, Not Chara wrote:also: McMenno is selectively responding, his latest contribution is entirely to complain that i've been taking potshots. i think he's even still voting Narna.
who is town here? probably Cakez, Nahdia, Narna.
multiball is likely, so Titus and McMenno can both be scum. zakk could be scum. Andrius and magna? i don't want to say both are scum, but one of them probably is.
you agreed with me 20 pages ago that a lynch needed to happen yet here we are.
creature is town but if you want to talk about him, holy hell we can talk about him Day 2.
That goes to all these 1~2 vote wagons.
I mean, he put my slot up there right below Titus at the very top bc most players were hard Town reading Gamma by that time, but look at where Creature is. I don't see ANYTHING to justify such a strong Town read on him by that time. Cakez is even relegated to a null/scum kind of read.In post 3313, Maxous wrote:Titus
Gamma Emerald
Creature
PeregrineV
-
SlySly
Leonshade
Narna
Yume
-
Ankamius
Andrius
zakk
MagnaofIllusion
Nahdia
-
Not Chara
-
SirCakez
Firebringer
massive
Shiro
-
Nosferatu
SnarkySnowman
McMenno
i think that's my current position in order from town => scum
i might be misremembering somebody because of the slog but w/e
Now somebody tell me this sequence ofSpoiler: 5 posts
makes any sense (other than it being for distancing when the VC get analyzed later out of their context).
I mean, naked vote then asking for an either/or then stating he wasn't happy about wagoning that slot??
Then this:
But -interestingly- it was Maxous who also claimed having blocked Creature, so which is it did he mean??
Also interestingly Creature wanted to end the game in a draw at about the same time Maxous had called for it, so -maybe- he was notified of having lost his ability?? Not too sure about that last part since I still believe the "Maxous Followers" faction was "created" after his lynch.
Anyway, I have this urge to vote Mathblade now. They seem to be the one person that would have been targeted by CFJ today after the Cakez flip, so they benefited the most from their death.
Their defense? Yeah sure they did push Max and got him lynched, only they didn't know they were to join his faction after his death (and I just said that I still believe that was the case. The faction was CREATED and the member only got notified AFTER the Maxous lynch had occurred).
VOTE: Mathblade
And you never voted Scum yet. Pre Or Post Maxous you have never voted scum or any kind. I don't like you.In post 10156, Ankamius wrote:My role functions exactly the same as it always has.
Mathblade is almost certainly scum. The meltdown last phase looks significantly worse after a SirCakez scum flip.
I specifically said in thread I wanted to confirm Nahdia could Jailkeep. The question is why the hell are you trying to paint me doing what I said I would as scummy. Especially when I had a plan to back it up.In post 10146, Almost50 wrote:Well, Ank would work for me too, but I want to hear you shouting and spewing your "brilliant" logic all over the place before I decide which one of you I want to lynch the most. Also funny that you should now confirm Nahdia of all players.
Tell me something: Why did you track Nahdia and not Ank?? I mean, you did suspect him more, right? And he didn't hammer scum, so I would have tried to verify HIM over Nahdia if I were you.. (if I were TOWN!Yo, that is)
VOTE: MathbladeIn post 10164, MathBlade wrote: @Almost50
One ) Most of your posts are pre Maxous death. Based on SorCakez's flip it is likely that people changed alignments during that weird night 5 thing.
Two SirCakez was still an inventor in his flip. He did not seem to gain any misdirection modifiers.
Three I claimed BP pre Maxous flip.
Four Therefore if I am godfather and BP like you are hypothesizing then I would have had god father Pre Maxous flip.
Five If I would have had godfather preMaxojs flip this would make me not Town the entire game as a town Godfather is just Town.
Six If I was scum the entire game why would I point out Maxous was lying there? It makes no sense.
Seven Ergo I am not godfather.
Eight ergo Nahdia JaeReed and I are Town block.
Stop trying to brute force a confirmed gamestate, it's not going to make you look any less like scum.In post 10169, MathBlade wrote:That is not helpful. Please explain how you think I can be Town preMaxous flip, not inherit Godfather, and still be scum with SirCakez.