Mini Normal 1862 - Town win.

[Ircher]

Have you ever thought that Ircher is pretending to scumhunt?

Out of all the people you ask that.....

[Ircher]

Have you ever thought that Ircher is pretending to scumhunt?

Out of all the people you can ask that to, you ask it to the one who's most likely to have considered that.....

EBWOP

[Alisae]

I think this pony is town.

[Gamma Emerald]

krylea is left.

[-Grey-]

Have you ever thought that Ircher is pretending to scumhunt?

Out of all the people you can ask that to, you ask it to the one who's most likely to have considered that.....

EBWOP

Ikr fam

[Alisae]

Have you ever thought that Ircher is pretending to scumhunt?

Out of all the people you can ask that to, you ask it to the one who's most likely to have considered that.....

EBWOP

Really? In that case his arguement makes no sense to me.

[-Grey-]

Have you ever thought that Ircher is pretending to scumhunt?

Out of all the people you can ask that to, you ask it to the one who's most likely to have considered that.....

EBWOP

Really? In that case his arguement makes no sense to me.

Actually, the only way my read on you makes no sense is if I am not certain about Ircher's push being sincere.

[-Grey-]

Alisae needs more votes.

I found me a cautious scum.

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

Whew, caught up. Okay reads and then questions

Reads:
RainbowDash town as fuck$Still don't like her because I played a MLP themed game of Mafia and lost it because I sent a mafioso into a vet, ergo allowing an escape from a MyLo and loss of game. UGH
Human Sequencer screams town$mostly gut reaction from reading his posts

Grey leaning town$Very aggressive/slightly cocky.

Two-Face leaning town$Due to his first attack at 43 against Gamma asking why grey scumreading him was a bad thing.

FlubberNugget null$haven't paid much attention too
Alisea null$Haven't looked into deeply
Naomi-Tan null$relaxed when defending and very open play style, not worth a D1 lynch. Will mess up on their own later down the road.
All Alone null$Not much to go off of

Asphodel leaning scum$Opens up with a trust tell? Asphodel for some reason, doesn't want focused attention on Ircher, one that is being scum read. Post 236: questions why people would think Grey is town. It's hard to put into words what irks me about this post but it's like he's trying to push Grey and as scum, he's having a hard time convincing people to lynch a townie.

Gamma scum butt$Most, if not all posts are highly frivolous and are just fluff. Post 119 is using self-meta as a form of defense and I won't read it because that's bullshit. Anyone can copy and paste a personality D1.
Ircher Scum$Oh boy is he a mess. First off he WK's Gamma, in which gamma did nothing productive at that point, so the point in defending him is rather sparse in reasoning. Post 81 talks about win rates. I see it as an excuse to say "hey this is why I'm playing bad." It's not necessary as a townie, you just try your best. Post 90 reinforces the previous point and shows that Ircher is using the fact that Grey made a joke or two, scummy AF. Hits my bullshit meter pretty high. Then in post 165, he votes Grey because apparently Grey is "arguing semantics."

No-Read: Krylea hasn't posted at all?

Questions:
Ircher: Post 168, where the fuck is Gamma scum hunting?

lmao didn't have many questions as I thought I would

[Gamma Emerald]

119 is not self meta. Read the first five pages. If you are a good townie you'll know what my demands are.

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

Alisae needs more votes.

I found me a cautious scum.

I'm actually going to second this motion and will hop on that Oregon Trail wagon


VOTE: Alisea


P-Edit: I ain't reading shit that's not related to this game. Now you can go ahead and tell me what you're after but you're going to explain that here. I ain't your damn lapdog.

[-Grey-]

Gin, you think scum!Ircher would hard defend scum!Gamma at the opening of d1?

Gtfo of here with that noise. Welcome to my scumpile.

[Gamma Emerald]

Alisae needs more votes.

I found me a cautious scum.

I'm actually going to second this motion and will hop on that Oregon Trail wagon


VOTE: Alisea


P-Edit: I ain't reading shit that's not related to this game. Now you can go ahead and tell me what you're after but you're going to explain that here. I ain't your damn lapdog.

I can't say why but it is game related.

[Ircher]

Yeah, tbh, there's not as much scumhunting in Gamma's ISO as I thought originally.

Like, it did look like he was doing useful stuff but going back through, I'm not quite as certain that the slot's town anymore. (Still pretty sure on the premise that there is very little to complain about.)

[Gamma Emerald]

I'll start scumhunting once I get what I want.

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

Gin, you think scum!Ircher would hard defend scum!Gamma at the opening of d1?

Gtfo of here with that noise. Welcome to my scumpile.

Cool I'm scumread, was waiting for that to happen.

Also, I think we can actually come to the logical conclusion that if what Ircher is saying is true, in that he has a high loss rate, would it not be reasonable to seem him commit bad play as scum?

P-Edit: Ircher, why didn't you actually read his ISO before coming to the conclusion he was scumhunting or were you thinking no one would check on that?

P-Edit 2: I've been doing some nice scum hunting here sweetie, work with what ya got.

[Alisae]

Alisae needs more votes.

I found me a cautious scum.

I'm actually going to second this motion and will hop on that Oregon Trail wagon


VOTE: Alisea


P-Edit: I ain't reading shit that's not related to this game. Now you can go ahead and tell me what you're after but you're going to explain that here. I ain't your damn lapdog.

Have I done anything else to you that seemed scummy prior to grey's vote?

[Ircher]

@Gin - It was a more reactionary post at the time. I mean, I did check once, but I kinda skimmed through and was looking for certain things. The readslist I provided earlier prob. gives a more objective and supported perspective for where I am since I actually looked through the ISOs a bit more intently.

[-Grey-]

Also, I think we can actually come to the logical conclusion that if what Ircher is saying is true, in that he has a high loss rate, would it not be reasonable to seem him commit bad play as scum?

Considering his win rate as scum is 50%, I'm not so willing to write off his play as bad scum, no.

Granted, that 50% is a split off two games, but it's still better than his 6:20 town ratio.

Scum is easier to play than town, and the basics for avoiding looking scummy are far easier than the basics for finding scum.

[Alisae]

Also Tonic or whatever you expect people to call you, when you gave your reads, why didn't you vote the person you thought was the most scummy?
Like, I don't believe that you're actually scumhunting. In fact I find your vote very sheepy.

[Ircher]

Alisae needs more votes.

I found me a cautious scum.

I'm actually going to second this motion and will hop on that Oregon Trail wagon


VOTE: Alisea


P-Edit: I ain't reading shit that's not related to this game. Now you can go ahead and tell me what you're after but you're going to explain that here. I ain't your damn lapdog.

Have I done anything else to you that seemed scummy prior to grey's vote?

The answer to this fyi is yes. Granted, I found the first half of your ISO (when I made my readslist in other words) somewhat townish.

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

@Alisae, haven't checked much but it's more of a placeholder vote.

@Ircher, "looking for certain things" which would be?

BRB, finding some info and reading ISOs

P-Edit:
@Grey, then I guess we'll have to wait and see what he flips when he does.

P-Edit 2:
@Alisae, I don't feel like fucking voting?

[-Grey-]

Alisae needs more votes.

I found me a cautious scum.

I'm actually going to second this motion and will hop on that Oregon Trail wagon


VOTE: Alisea


P-Edit: I ain't reading shit that's not related to this game. Now you can go ahead and tell me what you're after but you're going to explain that here. I ain't your damn lapdog.

Have I done anything else to you that seemed scummy prior to grey's vote?

The answer to this fyi is yes. Granted, I found the first half of your ISO (when I made my readslist in other words) somewhat townish.

Why did you Garcia?

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

Also, I said it was a blatant sheep vote. What's not to get or are you trying to spin a story I've already explained?

[Ircher]

@Grey
8. Alisae (+50%) - 146 was a good question, even if literally, it seems like a useless question. Don't like 184 cuz it's a loaded question; 187 was better after I asked for it to be unbiased.