Mini 1856 - This Mafia Game is for pieguyn (Game Over)

[GuyInFreezer]

vc 1.02

Aeronaut (5):

Nahdia, pieguyn, beeboy, Wisdom, mhsmith0

pisskop (1):

SirCakez

Luna Fox (1):

Gamma Enerald

beeboy (1):

drealmerz7

drealmerz7 (2):

pisskop, Dwlee99

Not Voting:

Varsoon, Luna Fox, Aeronaut

With

13

alive,

7

to lynch.

The deadline is in (expired on 2016-12-09 11:09:14).

[Luna Fox]

WOW
FIREBRINGER CAN PISS OFF FOR MAKING ME THINK I CAUGHT A SLIP

I feel like townreading this.
No way a newbie scum player gets this excited about "catching a slip"

I don't buy it, scum players can get excited about catching people slipping as well. It isn't even necessarily faked he could legit be unhappy about something like that as scum.

So like
"Oh hey im dissapointed the player i was never going to mislynch anyway managed to get away"
pls.

[beeboy]

Your join date is still recent enough for being able to fake that certain type of excitement and fake excitement about catching a scum slip.
It is possible, but highly unlikely.
So yeah.
P-Edit @Gamma

What stops scum from getting excited about seeing a town mess up and eat rope for free?
I am not even stretching here what I am saying is incredibly reasonable, I sure would be happy if I thought I caught someone "scum slip" as scum.

Pedit: he thought he saw someone scum slip why wouldn't he think a mislynch is achievable.

[Luna Fox]

That's not the way a newbie player's mindset works ^^;;

[beeboy]

That's not the way a newbie player's mindset works ^^;;

He is a newbie not an idiot he is still trying to fake scum hunt

[beeboy]

If he is scum

[beeboy]

He also has 5000 on site posts your read couldn't be more misguided

[Gamma Emerald]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Mas Y Menos

Sheeping Comapring Realities

L-1

rb, this wagon isn't shit. Hop on.

WHAT
You pretty much doubled everyone's suspicions of you with that last line. You acknowledge L-1 AND THEN YOU TELL SOMEONE TO HAMMER?

This is the post I referred to from my first scum game.

[Varsoon]

Girls can be pieguys ~n.

Pie, on a scale of 0 to 10, how sure are you that there's actually no IC in this game and you got a bum role?

probably like a 9 or a 9 1/2.

where do you intend to go with this?

Trying to gauge what the setup is like based off of what's been claimed and what I know to be true.
Chances are, everything in this game is just some nonsense intended to rub Pie the wrong way.
Knowing that helps me sort out some things and will be very helpful in mid/late game when roles are more important to the outcome of things.

[Luna Fox]

Well literally anything is fakable if you think of it that way.
You're just gonna end up mislynching people a lot more often if you keep thinking that way.

[Gamma Emerald]

OK
Remember that was as scum

[drealmerz7]

If you all are curious I've completed probably 15 games over the course of a year+ or so ? handful of bastard games in there, a roulette, a lovers, an all mafia, and have hosted a large theme as well...

we play deep games, elaborate and unusual setups, with a lot of veteran/smart players who have been playing for ages

also played a bit in meat-world (regular werewolf with a seer only and then 1NightWerewolf a bunch too)

That's not the way a newbie player's mindset works ^^;;

woah don't disservice good players just because they're new

I have seen a new player roll scum and DESTROY town because they observered 2 games and knew what the fuck they were doing through and through - it's possibly a site culture thing though, less likely to happen here that often

[drealmerz7]

Well literally anything is fakable if you think of it that way.

absolutely!!! never doubt it

[beeboy]

Well literally anything is fakable if you think of it that way.
You're just gonna end up mislynching people a lot more often if you keep thinking that way.

/shrug it is almost as if I said him being upset like that as scum doesn't even need to be faked as losing out on a mislynch is bad for scum and he isn't a newbie either as he has 5000 on site posts.
I don't even think you are thinking about what I am saying.

w/e I don't care

[Luna Fox]

I have seen a new player roll scum and DESTROY town because they observered 2 games and knew what the fuck they were doing through and through

1 out of how many?
A good player that happened to manage to do that deserves the win, since they managed to fool everyone else.
I go by what's the norm behaviour i see from town and scum and try to incorporate a player's supposed experience into the mix + experiencial meta that i have with them if any.
In this way i can make better calls to find town and then just remove who's leftover.

[beeboy]

Tfw Gamma still isn't a new player

[Varsoon]

Instead of talking about this fargone hardly-game-related external nonsense,
let's get to the meat of the thing:

Drealmerz. Are you scum?
This is your one chance to answer truthfully.

[Nahdia]

VOTE: Varsoon

[Gamma Emerald]

I have seen a new player roll scum and DESTROY town because they observered 2 games and knew what the fuck they were doing through and through

1 out of how many?
A good player that happened to manage to do that deserves the win, since they managed to fool everyone else.
I go by what's the norm behaviour i see from town and scum and try to incorporate a player's supposed experience into the mix + experiencial meta that i have with them if any.
In this way i can make better calls to find town and then just remove who's leftover.

BTW this actually answered a question I posed earlier

[Luna Fox]

BTW this actually answered a question I posed earlier

What question?

[drealmerz7]

I have seen a new player roll scum and DESTROY town because they observered 2 games and knew what the fuck they were doing through and through

1 out of how many?
A good player that happened to manage to do that deserves the win, since they managed to fool everyone else.
I go by what's the norm behaviour i see from town and scum and try to incorporate a player's supposed experience into the mix + experiencial meta that i have with them if any.
In this way i can make better calls to find town and then just remove who's leftover.

I see very good noob players on my HS often, put a couple games in them and they are fighting with the 'big boys' head on no problem. It's not like we get new players that often, but in the past 6 months we've actually had several new players and all of them have done well. A couple of them have come in crazyyy exceptional players. One should be making his way around here sooner or later...I'm excited...

[Gamma Emerald]

hoi Luna. what do your reads currently look like?

I saw 62, but that was about it.

Somewhere where im townreading everyone except you, drealmers, gamma, aero, dwlee (?) <- pending thing about the masons, Varsoon, Nahdia (she claimed not town so welp), and Wisdom.
And the Cakez townread is more of trusting bee's read.
I think that's about it.

Maybe if i posted my townreads in the usual pretty fashion would've looked less like rollon text.

Serious evaluation attempt:
she names 8/12 of the not-her players as possible scum, which looks really odd for this type of post.

This one, though I didn't phrase it as a question.
It was basically "why are you posting with this phraseology when the content doesn't fit?" but your explanation of your playstyle made it clear

[drealmerz7]

I find that if I try to gauge a player by their newness I'm likely underestimating and doing myself a disservice. Sure, keep the things in mind, but, don't let it guide you or you'll end up duped more often than is good.

[Luna Fox]

Oh you could've had that answered by clicking on my wiki ^^;;

[beeboy]

I almost forgot!
Nahdia why in the world is Wisdom town?