Mini Normal 1850 | The Penguin Mafia | Endgame

[Road Kamelot]

Yes exactly
That was the first time
Why no second of thought that we're scum together
He goes straight to me-scum buddying you-town

[Gamma Emerald]

Not a typo. It's doubtful scum gamma would defend an idler for no reason that wasn't also scum. It's NAI for now but if gamma does flip scum then gerry looks much worse in my eyes. We can push people here all we want but ultimately with people not posting period were never going to figure things out. Gerry hasn't posted a single time so I just want him to start participating, over a 24 hour period you should have time to pop in and say hi at the beginning of the game at the absolute least. I don't care if he's scum, hes as useful to town as scum if he doesn't participate in discussion. I also know it hasn't been /that/ long and there's plenty of time left in day 1 for him to be active.

Your philosophy is backwards as hell
Scum whiteknight town
A Gerry scumflip would implicate me

[Joshz]

Yes, it would.

[Road Kamelot]

Not a typo. It's doubtful scum gamma would defend an idler for no reason that wasn't also scum. It's NAI for now but if gamma does flip scum then gerry looks much worse in my eyes. We can push people here all we want but ultimately with people not posting period were never going to figure things out. Gerry hasn't posted a single time so I just want him to start participating, over a 24 hour period you should have time to pop in and say hi at the beginning of the game at the absolute least. I don't care if he's scum, hes as useful to town as scum if he doesn't participate in discussion. I also know it hasn't been /that/ long and there's plenty of time left in day 1 for him to be active.

Mmk
Then push someone whos here until gerrys total absence is actually at a suspicious point
Theres plenty of content
If someone is entirely gone for a few days theyre either really busy or site flaked so wasting time on them doesnt get u anywhere

[Joshz]

I have no scum reads I really want to push right now but I absolutely do intend to. For now, might as well put my vote to use on gerry.

[Gamma Emerald]

Yes, it would.

Do you understand my defense of Gerry was NAI for Gerry?

[Joshz]

I understand you think it's NAI

[Gamma Emerald]

Whatever you're obviously new

[Road Kamelot]

Whatever you're obviously new

Didnt i remember you having a reputation for being mislynched newbtown earlier on
Are you normally this dismissive
Am i entirely misremembering

[Joshz]

It's not NAI for the reason you called it NAI. You call it whiteknighting -> you flip scum -> town assumes it was whiteknighting and gerry isn't under suspicion. Your reply is why it isn't NAI, if you had left it it would be NAI.

Comments like "Lol you're new" and "chill" do not make you look better.

[Gamma Emerald]

Whatever you're obviously new

Didnt i remember you having a reputation for being mislynched newbtown earlier on
Are you normally this dismissive
Am i entirely misremembering

What makes you say the first part

[Gamma Emerald]

As for me being dismissive: I'm the more experienced person here.
I think my playstyle will end up somewhat like rb

[Road Kamelot]

I really dont know tbh I dont have any completed games w you
But ive def read games w you
If im wrong just say so bc idk

I dont like you being dismissive i dont like anyone bein dismissive

[mykonian]

Can we get some more votes on gerryoak to pressure please he hasn't posted

no mate, your vote is bad and you should feel bad about it. Go play this game with us, don't just vote a lurker, discuss what's going on.

For those who dont get it what mykonian is doing is spinning Gammas actions as scummy when its just Gamma seeing something he agrees with and going w it, which is a rly standard newb thing and not even a newb thing its a thing a certian kind of person just tends to do in mafia
And its ignorng what mykonian noted himself namely Gamma being relatively new

actually, given that after 2 pages RK has gamma's personality pegged and has an explanation for his actions, this smells like buddying. So with that, and on top of that the apology, I feel better here:

vote Kamelot

First sign of myko townreading me

Correct. Well, in a way. I think Kamelot is more likely to be scum than you, and the argument for it implies you to be town, the interaction that makes her scummy makes no sense if you are scum as well (from a player of her stature). I'm happy to be proven wrong, but as of now I'm assuming you are town and Kamelot is scum, because of her overeager and very understanding defense of you (while a town would be at least somewhat worried about defending a scum by accident, have some reserve).

[Errantparabola]

sorry i'm on 2 hours of sleep right now, zero focus or motivation. you'll see me soon. today for sure.

[gerryoat]

posting. i'll read in a sec

[gerryoat]

I regret skimming the first few pages. all i see is

[MariaR]

Gerry flipped scum

[gerryoat]

Joshz I'm gonna need you to get an avi fam. Do you need one? I can make one for you so you can upload it.

[gerryoat]

Gerry flipped scum

ok

[MariaR]

Gerry flipped scum

ok

bad reaction
VOTE: Gerry

[gerryoat]

Gerry flipped scum

ok

bad reaction
VOTE: Gerry

ok

[Joshz]

Lol sh MariaR

I don't have a computer and it's too much effort uploading an avi from mobile, soz

[Gamma Emerald]

I have something I need to prepare.
Expect something from me soon.

[Gamma Emerald]

RQS Time!

1) What roles do you like? What roles do you not like?

2) What is a behavior you would lynch if the person who did it was a null read?

3) Who, if town, would you trust with your vote?

My answers:

1) I like Jailkeeper for its multiple uses. Don't like Bus Drivers or Ascetics.
2) I don't like people being inconsiderate.
3) MariaR or kraska, maybe EP or myko