Micro 649: Normal Idea Mafia (Game Over)

[Leonshade]

You needed to look up what a weak modifier was?

Yeah.

I don't think scum would no-kill on two different nights, either.

[callforjudgement]

Catching up with this game now.

As we're in massclaim, claiming immediately: I'm a Jailkeeper, Gamma jailed itlepip Night 1 and Sgz13 Night 2, I jailed Sgz13 Night 3.

[callforjudgement]

I'm going to read the players who haven't claimed first in order to make a sensible decision about popcorning. (As it's massclaim, I'm going to hold off on making comments until after the claims are finished.)

[callforjudgement]

Popcorn to Heartache.

(I'm going to continue reading through some of the other players while the massclaim is going on.)

[McMenno]

now I'm very much inclined to lynch sgz again

[Leonshade]

Heartache's already roleclaimed, only their night actions remain (and we know they tracked McMenno N2).

[Leonshade]

Catching up with this game now.

As we're in massclaim, claiming immediately: I'm a Jailkeeper, Gamma jailed itlepip Night 1 and

Sgz13 Night 2, I jailed Sgz13 Night 3.

Interesting.

[Leonshade]

@Sgz13:

Why didn't you mention being JK'd?

[McMenno]

I mean he wouldn't know

[Leonshade]

Right, I got a PM back saying my night action failed, but a doc wouldn't know that. Hmm.

[Sgz13]

WIFOM I know but if I had gone for the kill and failed the first time I'd have the foresight to send my buddy to do the dirty work next time in case I was the reason it failed.

[Heartache]

n1 - light_ganski, visited mcmenno [reso's pick]
n2 - mcmenno, visited no one
n3 - leonshade, no result (??)

Huh, thought tere/1svt was the protective. Him next to claim, then.

[Sgz13]

So you werent completely ignoring me and the possibility I was scum because you had something that implied I was the protective? Really?

[1 Shot Vanilla Town]

I'm a non consecutive watcher
Night 1 my other body watched McMenno with no one visiting
Night 3 I watched heart with no one visiting...
So Heart wasn't blocked but got a no result.

[1 Shot Vanilla Town]

Sgz seems legit here.

[Sgz13]

Trying to make some sense out of all of this.

I still don't believe McMenno. If he has an ascetic modifier he can claim VT and be guaranteed to not get caught. Only thing that would explain the no kills would be that the new Gamma is flat out lying, which seems rather risky to me. I can see scum no killing last night, but the night before it seems like an odd line to take. Or that I was the N2 and/or N3 target, but that wouldn't be what I'd expect either.

[Leonshade]

n1 - light_ganski, visited mcmenno [reso's pick]

I'm a non consecutive watcher
Night 1 my other body watched McMenno with no one visiting

Gotcha.

[Leonshade]

Wait, I'm dumb nvm

[Sgz13]

Lmao I did the same thing in my head

[Leonshade]

Someone has to be lying, as both I and Heartache have had failed investigations, with the only JK claim claiming to have JK'd Sgz13 both nights.

More NA analysis later.

[McMenno]

Player	Claim	N1	N2	N3
callforjudgement	Jailkeeper	Jailed BigYoshiFan	Jailed Sgz13	Jailed Sgz13
1 Shot Vanilla Town	Non-consecutive Watcher	Watched McMenno (No visits)	No action	Watched Heartache (No visits)
Heartache	Tracker	Tracked 1 Shot Vanilla Town (Visited McMenno)	Tracked McMenno (Visited no one)	Tracked Leonshade (No result)
McMenno	Vanilla Townie	No action	No action	No action
Sgz13	Weak Doctor	No action	1 Shot Vanilla Town	1 Shot Vanilla Town
Leonshade	Even-night Cop	No action	Investigated Heartache (No result)	No action

Notes: Leonshade and Heartache's results are both consistent with Leonshade being jailed N2 and N3, NOT Sgz13. This rules out callforjudgement + Heartache/Leonshade. This also means that it's either Heartache + Leonshade or callforjudgement + 1 Shot Vanilla Town/McMenno/Sgz13. So for either Heartache or Leonshade to be town, callforjudgement has to be scum. I assume there's no lying in actual roles, only in results. Now, Leonshade and Heartache:

Why aren't you voting callforjudgement? They should essentially be confirmed scum in your eyes.

[McMenno]

Nevermind, callforjudgement + Heartache/Leonshade isn't ruled out. But my second point still rests:

For one of Heartache or Leonshade to be town, callforjudgement HAS to be scum.

[Sgz13]

Why would Leon being jailkept cause Heart to get a no result?

[Heartache]

Either callforjudgement or 1svt is probably roleblocker.

[Heartache]

Someone was probably blocked n1 too, but most people had no action that night anyways.