Title Fairy: Killer App Edition (Swipe Right!)

[kraska77]

inspired by parama's post in wake's derp madness dead thread

nominate wake88 for me up

edit: or maybe

cant wake up

lol

[kraska77]

I only like fun that isn't stupid

There's zero wit or creativity to that, just "oh hes firebringer so he brings fire amirite"

You could have reversed the situation here and had firebringer nominate flame axe for the same title

I DEMAND EXCELLENCE

U suck

[kraska77]

i see more complaining about shitposting than actual shitposting tbh

[kraska77]

Chevre is gonna crush it anyway

but why

[kraska77]

natirasha likes it
and double bewbs = double science so....
i dont see any reasons not to approve this

[kraska77]

Nth chestchest

[kraska77]

2nd leanon sidhe

I like it it's pretty
I don't understand the Lily one

[kraska77]

yeah i was just going to say
unless im missing something this seems snide

[kraska77]

Does anyone have any thoughts or ideas regarding my suggestion? I feel like it kinda got lost in all the other stuff going on. (Or maybe I'm just not cool enough to get any attention in this thread. )

Nominate Aristophanes for

Love the Scummer, Hate the Scum

(or Hate the Scum, Love the Scummer)

I'm going to be honest in that I don't think this is the best possible title for Aristophanes but it's the best idea I've had so far and I definitely think Aristophanes deserves a title.

I saw the whole "Aggressively Loving" debate, and while I agree that he has a unique personality that deserves to be recognized, I also don't think that title covers it all, because in my experience it's more than just loving.
Obviously, the title is a play on the expression, "Love the sinner, hate the sin." It reflects the idea that while people might do bad things, they aren't bad people, which is in and of itself reflective of Aristophanes's optimism. But more particularly, it's a reference to how he's like in games. It seems to me that he's there to play the game but also to be friendly with other members of the community, two goals which sometimes conflict-- when you want to cooperate and be friendly with someone but at the same time you're accusing them, hence the dichotomy of the title.

Aristophanes's unique personality is hard to put into words as it's more of a feeling, and that's probably why there haven't been many good suggestions for him. If anybody can think of a better and/or more elegant title that plays on the same themes, I'd gladly support that as well.

Ooooh I like the Aggressively Loving title it fits ari perfectly

[kraska77]

Chevre why decline =(

[kraska77]

Can I anti-nom by default any Accountant titles referring to his moral views? If so, that please.

Ditto this.

Me too

[kraska77]

Can we try "aggressively loving" for ari again? it's perfect

[kraska77]

Reject

Deus Vult

. I mostly agree with Davsto and Psyche on this issue. Accountant's outlook on the world is certainly notable, but it's not something to commemorate. Frankly, I think he's caused a lot people needless agony due to his uncompromising nature. I can't think of a time where it was a joy rather than a point of stress.

Fuck literally everything about that.

I don't say that because I personally like the title, I say this as a former title fairy, fuck that rational so very fucking hard. You don't fucking get to play favourites, I don't care if you think Accountant is the biggest piece of shit since Genghis Khan decided to take the mongols on a road trip. It's notable, it's got lasting appeal and it's so very very strongly resonates with him. Get the fuck off your high horse you unbelievable arrogant piece of shit, we don't bother doing the job to get to decide who's beliefs are "worthy" of a title or who's posting we like enough to reward.

Is it a good title yes or no? The second start adding anything else to the decision process then its time to hang up your hat and give the role to some new blood because you've stopped doing it as a service to the site and started doing it to stroke your own ego.

are you fucking serious lol?

you people take this shit too seriously and that was way out of line buttonmen ure being ridiculous

[kraska77]

well it needed to be said, his post was really unnecessarily hurtful and personal in its attack

[kraska77]

nom nahdia for scheherazade

[kraska77]

nominate mcmenno for arent we all

[kraska77]

is there a good reason y u arent seconding my nom

[kraska77]

no

[kraska77]

dudes the reference to affirmative action makes no sense at all here and is still there if you swap the words

^ 100% exactly this

I also still oppose this title on principle. It's a title about titles. It's not real get rid of it.

Actively Affirmative is not a title about titles.

It's a title about Aris' affinity for affirmation.

no. bad.

[kraska77]

I'm inclined to agree with those saying that KainTepes getting that title would encourage bad behaviors. I stand by my earlier thought that we shouldn't give titles to people for behavior that isn't particularly fun or enjoyable. Last I knew, a lot of people didn't care for Tepes' schtick . . .

I'm with this guy.

But kain is pretty fun and his posts are always funny

Nth aggressive!!!