In post 62, Shadow_step wrote:Day 1 was awful for me, it is no matter what alignment I am. All the better players got the PRs hmm, that kinda sucked.
Also whoever verified this setup for balance needs a head check. Way too town sided IMO. Esp with ascetic claiming day 1.
We didn't even have day talk btw
Obviously disagree with this. The ascetic almost got lynched. And still has a chance of getting lynched.
Both the town and scum had some great night actions. You guys might enjoy the Mod thread/Review thread after the end of the game.
The probability of such an event happening is pretty low. And ultimately escaping the lynch while also staying away from mafia's eyes, while getting all those innos on all the alive people on day 4 is a pretty good achievement.
Look at the positives, 8 day phase for Days means theoretically it should be easier to lynch town. Although I never believed that personally.
IMO scum still has a chance and I think town has played really well up until now. Let's see how it goes. You played well on day 3 I thought. Kinda difficult to get out of that situation with the vig.
This is true and I also wanted a traditional mafia game with no day talk. In my opinion those games tend to have the best day games and entertainment all around. I feel that a combination of informed minority + day talk planning is a bit too much.
In post 81, chilledtea wrote:Look at the positives, 8 day phase for Days means theoretically it should be easier to lynch town. Although I never believed that personally.
IMO scum still has a chance and I think town has played really well up until now. Let's see how it goes. You played well on day 3 I thought. Kinda difficult to get out of that situation with the vig.
How well do you think mafia played in comparison to town, to even have this argument of balance vs unbalanced? Lets not act like the night actions are the only thing that have helped the town be in this position. Their day game has helped them make great choices during night.
If scum doesn't kill at all, then there is no more a danger to town.
In that sense, town generally wins. The lynching is taking place because of the killing. If the no-kill and no-lynch keeps happening then either it is considered a draw, or a town win.
Not sure what the normal guidelines on this are. But scum would be kind of playing against their wincon by no-killing for several days.
No killing on a single night is acceptable but if it turns out to be no killing on consecutive nights then it means that as long as town doesn't lynch scum won't, which means town wouldn't have a reason to lynch in the first place.
Yeah that's pretty strong stuff that. Good thing for scum you are here and not there.