In post 1743, JarJarDrinks wrote:
You don't think that the fact that we have so many PRs and he hasn't been countered doesn't point to him being town?
Agree with leaving the watcher alive for a day but this is out of character for jarjar. He strikes me as the type of guy that would do anything to get his scumreads lynched, damned be a PR claim, and in fact in the last game we played together I remember him saying VT claims were towny.
In post 1747, Vedith wrote:I'll just say it otherwise we get no where. I'm a Watcher.
No way is there 2 in the game for town.
Oook
In post 1752, JarJarDrinks wrote:So unless someone can come up w/ a reason how Vedith can be town, we're lynching him once we get the final claims.
Why so eager to lynch vedith over DGB? Especially after you just said to lynch DGB in
1748?
In post 1760, JarJarDrinks wrote:MariaR wrote:The only problem is where's the scum motivation for Vedith to claim right into a cc like that
Also he may have realized that this statement looked pretty fishy unless he could come up w/ a strong reason to scumread DGB:
In post 1744, Vedith wrote: In post 1743, JarJarDrinks wrote:You don't think that the fact that we have so many PRs and he hasn't been countered doesn't point to him being town?
No, I do not think that at all.
She
(DGB) is most likely scum.
Why would scum change their read randomly like that?
This seems pretty obvious for a defense of DGB, but after my analysis of kts interactions, I think jarjar may be trying to lay on the WIFOM. The transition from "let's lynch DGB" to "here are some reasons vedith is scum, let's lynch vedith" is unnatural. The normal town reaction if you're unsure is to think about it for a little, and make a decision.
It's worth mentioning that vedith has claimed cop to get a town PR lynched before, but this feels very different. Given how towny kraska was, and how scummy DGB has been, and jarjar's frantic attempt to save DGB, I think we should just lynch DGB today. I ~guess~ we could wait until tomorrow to sort it out, but scum could lay on some WIFOM with roleblocking (and in fact, I think DGB might be the roleblocker).
How many votes are we at?
In post 1766, Slandaar wrote: In post 1736, JarJarDrinks wrote:Unless I'm missing something, here's what I have for claims:
DrippingGoofball - PR (Watcher)
Firebringer- VT
hiplop - ??????
Infinity 324 - PR
JarJarDrinks - PR
LicketyQuickety - VT
Manuel87 - PR
MariaR - PR
Raskolnikov - VT
Slandaar - ??????
Vedith - PR
Way too many PR claims if this is accurate but then 1 of DGB/Vedith is scum (DGB) so that is one. Another PR claim is scum at least.
I agree. I think the PR-claiming scum are DGB and jarjar.