Mini 1787: Peruvian Nightclub Mafia (Game End!)

[Jake from State Farm]

Like wtf Tyler. Move your vote to Dunn already.

he's town, man

look, if this is about teaching the kid a lesson so that he never does stupid shit like this as town again, then yea, we've got a couple mislynches to burn and there's no way for me to argue that

but you can't convince me that scum plays anything remotely like how dunn has played here

throughout the entire game

1. I don't agree
2. If he is town, I don't even give a fuck b

I'm not playing with him anymore. This day phase will not end with both of us alive.

[Jake from State Farm]

The thing that makes Dunn scum with this gambit was him continuing it after I claimed. He retracted it once the mood of people posting made it seem people believed me over him. If he was really claiming to get me to claim my reports he would have retracted sooner.

[Jake from State Farm]

Correction. He retracted once bins claimed and confirmed I was legit. Dunn made at least 5/6 posts after I claimed trying to imply I was lying.


He's scum trying to out the real cop cause he didn't think I was actually cop cause I played my wifom masterfully.

NOW
VOTE
DUNN
ASAP
GO
GO
DO
IT

[Jake from State Farm]

I'm a Voyeur
I'm going to claim cause I'm useless now

I targeted Robert N1 and yeah he got investigated
I targeted Dunn N2 and yeah he got investigated

So either Dunn is GF or Jake is scum investigative
Have fun someone figure this out

LOL

Ok I retract. And I'll explain what I was doing before you psychopaths jumped on me

The LOL was him laughing that his planned worked sort of.

[toolenduso]

OK yeah the logic here means Dunn is very probably town. Didn't get it at first, now I do. We can talk more about the merits of the gambit in postgame, but for now I think that'd just clog up the thread more, and we have basically two replacements who need to catch up right now -- one of them not even in the game yet.

Jake, I think you know you're being stubborn right now, and town needs you to be practical instead. We're at a place right now where town can more or less PoE -- we have a very good shot at winning.

Xyzzy's post re: trying to figure out Dunn...

might

be town. The qualm I'm having with it is that it looked like xyzzy was confused, not that they knew what dunn was getting it.

Jaack looks like a good candidate for scum on first glance. I'll check it out more.

[toolenduso]

look, if this is about teaching the kid a lesson so that he never does stupid shit like this as town again, then yea, we've got a couple mislynches to burn and there's no way for me to argue that

Bad idea for town. We have a pool of clears and our advantage is in keeping as many people in that pool as possible.

[toolenduso]

Also I looked back at what Dunn and Bins were talking about re: Keyserslot. Especially seeing which players we've narrowed things down to, I can buy the narrative of a daychat-planned bus between partners. The slot isn't at the top of my list atm, but let's remember my tool from earlier -- if we find the second scum, we can use their actions re: HA's claim to find the third scum.

[Jake from State Farm]

I'm not being stubborn with regards I believe it all the way down to my very core that he's scum. I see no town motivation at all for his actions and am seriously amazed anyone could. I've already explained the scum motivation for it. Scum had their back against the wall.

I need this lynch. I'm getting this lynch

[toolenduso]

I can't see the town motivation either, in the sense that it's not something I'd do. I think we're more or less in the same boat in that regard, since you said you hate gambiting.

But what matters is whether townDunn could see a reason to do it. And I think he could. It doesn't make sense to me, but other people do things that don't make sense to me all the time.

Something's gotta give, when you consider what has to be true in order for Dunn to be scum or town. In order for him to be scum, he has to be a godfather and he has to have somehow thought that it was a better play to gambit and out the cop, risking his own life in the process, than for him to ride a fake cop clear to victory.

If he's town, he needed to believe in weird logic.

[Bins]

Jake do you really think there's no chance Dunn is town or is this policy?




And I know my role is useless I've been saying this
the only thing I did is prove they're both not scum together

[Bins]

Oh nvm I missed this page entirely

[Jake from State Farm]

Like what sense does it make to out the cop prematurely? Absolutely none

He kept saying he knew I was cop day 1 which I find weird cause I certainly wasn't telegraphing my role. I could get why people thought day 2 and I sometimes I hate my inability to lie because I wanted to fake claim a guilty on him so bad but didn't.

I'm not playing this game with him and I'm not replacing out which means I'll do something really stupid to make sure town suffers for not listening to me. There isn't even a minor chance in my mind he's town and the fact that not only aren't people lynching him, they are actually listening to him is Just unacceptable

P.edit - not even a minor fraction of doubt. He's not town

[Jaack]

But what matters is whether townDunn could see a reason to do it. And I think he could. It doesn't make sense to me, but other people do things that don't make sense to me all the time.

Okay, so you don't understand why he would do what he did if he is scum, but you also don't understand why he did what he did if he is town.

How does that make him town?

[Jake from State Farm]

I have too much integrity to do anything stupid so I won't get myself modkilled but if people aren't going to lynch Dunn I'm just not going to do anything else because I don't endorse any other lynch. We have imo confirmed scum and nobody wants to lynch them.

I'm dead tonight anyway so I'm just a glorified tree stump at this point. Idk what the hell happened to this site but it has certainly gone down hill since I joined 6 years ago

[Creature]

VOTE: Dunnstral

This "no GF would do that" argument is terrible.

[toolenduso]

bins feels town was actually gonna vote her coming into today but don't really remember why

Doesn't her claim basically clear her?

Okay, so you don't understand why he would do what he did if he is scum, but you also don't understand why he did what he did if he is town.

How does that make him town?

I explained that with my "something's gotta give" argument.

VOTE: Dunnstral

This "no GF would do that" argument is terrible.

Interesting, and noted.

Creature, have you caught up? And what pronoun do you actually prefer? Your profile says "it," but I figured that was a joke to go along with your username.

[Creature]

I am male, so use he/him.

[Creature]

Well, gotta go, currently seeing this:

Jake - His hammer looks towny, he already showed intent to hammer Desmond, though, he wasn't overcautious when he wanted to hammer.
Robert - He seemed decently town despite the investigation.
Tyler/Tool - They haven't done anything particularly scummy/indicative, their general motivation looks good so far.
xyzzy - Kind of liked him D1. Haven't done much D2 or D3 to get a read from.
Jaack - Should say, his pushes are pretty terrible.
Bins - I dislike her posts since D1. Her claim is a coincidence, which makes me think she could be some kind of mafia PR.
Dunnstral

Bins

Why you targeted Robert and Dunn?

[Tyler the Creator]

mmm yea creatures probably scum

[Tyler the Creator]

If he is town, I don't even give a fuck b

yea i gathered that

[Tyler the Creator]

Bad idea for town. We have a pool of clears and our advantage is in keeping as many people in that pool as possible.

no shit?

[Tyler the Creator]

He kept saying he knew I was cop day 1 which I find weird cause I certainly wasn't telegraphing my role.

i mean day 1 i didn't really have any idea but day 2 you gotta admit it was pretty obvious you were a role

that's why the night kill narrows it down so much; like who's not keen enough to pick up on that

xy/jaack/creature are what im thinking

[Tyler the Creator]

Doesn't her claim basically clear her?

no? kinda?

i will say the way she claimed looked town regardless but why does it clear her?

[Tyler the Creator]

I have too much integrity to do anything stupid so I won't get myself modkilled but if people aren't going to lynch Dunn I'm just not going to do anything else because I don't endorse any other lynch. We have imo confirmed scum and nobody wants to lynch them.

I'm dead tonight anyway so I'm just a glorified tree stump at this point. Idk what the hell happened to this site but it has certainly gone down hill since I joined 6 years ago

you

do

have an inno result on him, yea?

[Bins]

VOTE: creature

I targeted Robert because I knew either scum or town investigative would want to target him.
I targeted Dunn because I wanted to know if scum had a roleblocker (I thought Dunn was cop).