Mini 1774: Formation of America's Mafiascum - Perfect Town W

[itlepip]

I believe you on Beeboy (obviously)

Peri and Alc need one, agree mostly with the rest.

[Suzune]

Need one what? A paragraph?
Alchemist
+ He keeps up with the flow of the game
+ Scum read the rules more then townies do post 62.
+ Decided not make own decisions rather then go with the flow post 129
+ Shows concern for the flow post 321 As a negative if he flips mafia we should probably check Peri
------
- Responded opposite to how Fire responded to the mail (struck a cord with me)
- Is fixated on who protested what

Peri
I will not lie this one is a lot of gut right now. I get a good feeling about it. Which I realize means little in the grand scheme of things but for now I a not looking for lynch that slot.

[Suzune]

I forewarned everyone but I feel pretty good about it. Although his reaction was weird to it. So something to watch. I do not believe I claimed inventor anywhere. Where are you puling information from?

Pip answer this

[Nosferatu]

why are you scumreading dier

[Nosferatu]

also I'm obligated to ask if you actually think me and sircakez was SvS

[Suzune]

also I'm obligated to ask if you actually think me and sircakez was SvS

It was far less of a versus and more of a cover. He stuck his neck out there for you, so it is something worth noticing.

[Nosferatu]

when did he stick his neck out for me?

[Dierfire]

I'm putting this off for another day because I've been unexpectedly busy and tired.

I didn't send in a protest vote N2.

[Suzune]

when did he stick his neck out for me?

I guess that is not quite what this is, but it just falls flat. Looks like a lot of effort then it just burns out, something to be looked at in my opinion. post 419

[Alchemist21]

Ok, now I just need

Beeboy

Ranger and Persivul to claim their protests and I'll have everyone's.

To answer Pip's question:

I think Klingon and Dier are scum. You are null. Looking back I can't remember why I was Townreading KTS unless it was for being on the Cakez wagon, so I'd put her back to null as well. Everyone else I think is Town.

[Alchemist21]

when did he stick his neck out for me?

I guess that is not quite what this is, but it just falls flat. Looks like a lot of effort then it just burns out, something to be looked at in my opinion. post 419

I think you're misreading that post. Cakez' comments are arguing with Nos, not defending him. He was one of the primary pushers of the Cakez lynch so I doubt he's scum.

[Alchemist21]

I protested quartering ftr.

Actually scratch that null on pip. If this is true Pip is probably Town since I don't think scum would have voted for the loss of their JK.

[Ranger]

Really? We had ranger replace into this? Ugh. Now I just want to replace out.

What did I do?

I mean, our last game together, I was scum. I may have treated you badly in the game thread while the game was ongoing, but that's because I was

scum

, and doing so was my wincon. I did nothing but praise you in the mafia PT, and in postgame had nothing but good things to say about you. You were right on your scumread there. You were obviously town, not needing the draft pick order to clear you. I consider you a good player. You displayed no such hostility to me prior to that game. :S

(Pretty sure Firebringer's town, though.)

@Ranger, when you see this can you tell me what protest, if any, Beeboy voted for last night?

Nope! I'm pretty sure that my role PM was the only thing the mods sent to me when I replaced in, not any actions done with it. I didn't even know there

was

that type of mechanic when replacing in. (I knew there was some mechanic, sure, but I didn't read the specifics behind it.) I'll ask in a bit.

[Ranger]

Quick note, btw: I don't have familiarity with any of the players I've seen posting so far save Firebringer, but I need to review Suikoden. I know it's a sample size of one, but the Suzune posts I've seen so far feel

different

compared to that game and that has me rather alarmed.

[Persivul]

I need to catch up. I voted for freedom of assembly. Since there was a hated before, I thought this might give us a loved.

[Ranger]

Btw, asked the mod about beeboy's actions.

I'm thinking I'll kill two birds with one stone: answer when they get back to me, and begin reading the thread.

[Nosferatu]

VOTE: Dierfire

still waiting for suz's explanation of her scum read on dier.

[Persivul]

Just did quite a bit of review and I don't see why kling isn't back on the board. She was on the Window CW to cakez and on the Shiro lynch. She's mostly defended and her few reads are weak and feel like scum making the obligatory list under pressure.

VOTE: Klingoncelt

[itlepip]

Nobody has said that Kling in off the table, but pushing easy null pushes Peri is incredibly scummy so either make a case as to why Kling is scum that isn't just 'Kling pings me a little' which totally worked well with Shiro or sheep me on Bboy to actually kill scum.

Btw Nos I think that Dier is town because he agrees with my Bboy case.

[Persivul]

Beeboy was on the cakez lynch. Kling was on the counter wagon.

[Persivul]

I just read beeboy's ISO and I don't see scum there at all. Your 975 reminds me of when I'm scum and want to manufacture a case on someone.

[Persivul]

She asked me to say it.
She is continueing to write a narrative where I am twisting her words which I am not doing.
I am obv town me and cakes would have scum reads on each other when we where both easy wagon contenders day 1 when

we both don't like to bus

.

I am so ok with my vote it isn't funny.

oh beeboy, clearly I was teasing you. Sorry if you missed it.

You are far from obvious town though.

Did you play borderlands 2?

Cakes never gave a good reason for me being scum day 1 for a reason.
He never tried getting me lynched beyond that for a reason.

I hard town read both my buddies when they where under pressure for a reason.

As players we don't bus

and it is obv you should know that if you are really critically scum reading me right now.

UNVOTE:
Does not look like the best option right now.

Huh you may actually be town after all.

If it is any consolation I still like you for scum.

Then go reread my interaction with cakes again.
Out of all the viable wagons he could have pushed when he was at L-3 he wouldn't choose a scum buddy since I could help him drive a mislynch.
Also

I wouldn't just hard bus

a buddy like that.

Sorry folks, tax season has me brain dead. I went to do some meta on beeboy and realized that I just finished a game with him (Open 630) in which he was scum, and bussed his partner D1. Not liking him so much now.

[Firebringer]

What did I do?

I don't want to go into it this game, but its your attitude after Fire and Ice, and previous games in the Blitz queue.
I am no longer talking about it though, beeboy was likely town. So I don't need to pay attention to your slot anyways.

[Persivul]

Snap, beeboy is now Ranger. This should be interesting.

[Ranger]

but pushing easy null pushes Peri is incredibly scummy so either make a case as to why Kling is scum that isn't just 'Kling pings me a little' which totally worked well with Shiro or sheep me on Bboy to actually kill scum.

Question.

Am I wrong in assuming beeboy was an easy null push? Because my impression of beeboy, both from this game in second-hand accounts and from his gameplay in general across the board, is that he is almost always an easy null push.

So, do correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't this hypocritical?

For the record: I don't like Persivul's white knight of my slot, nor the sudden turnaround on it. This behavior matches his scum game and not his town game.

I don't want to go into it this game, but its your attitude after Fire and Ice, and previous games in the Blitz queue.

Fair enough. But for what it's worth: I hold you to a high standard of play. You're a

good

player. I haven't thought of it this way before consciously, but I think one of the main reasons I've been harsh on your play before is

because

you're a good player, which means whenever you have a failing, it sticks out all the more obviously as being such.