Open 50: The New C9 - Abandoned!

[LoudmouthLee]

God. A Night 1 shooting vig. Well then.

Dear Vig,

Don't ever do that again.

-LML

On to possible scum hunting...

Vig, while it is possible that you killed scum last night

The vig has a 50/50 chance of either hitting scum or hitting a townie. For all we know, the vig killed the townie and the SK killed the mafia member. In the other "New C9", kill methods were shown. Here, they were not.

I find it incredibly interesting that your opening post contained that line. It's possible, as you say, but no more probable that he was the SK. I find it very curious how the tone of your post makes it seem like you KNEW that the vig killed Mafia.

Vote: Jordan

, our resident Serial Killer.

This would, of course, be the only way that anyone would know that the Vig killed mafia. I get that from the tone of his opening post.

[LoudmouthLee]

You catch more scum on page one than you catch on page 30.

[LoudmouthLee]

You're quick to jump to conclusions...

I said "while it's possible" which means "there is a chance the vig killed the scum", not "the vig definatly killed the scum".

I never said that you said anything about "definates."

Instead, I spoke about your TONE. Sometimes, it not what a person says, rather HOW they say it.

[LoudmouthLee]

timmers, I thought about that too. After re-reading I found out what he was trying to say. There isn't a 50/50 chance of hitting scum. But today, it was fifty percent chance that it was the vig that hit scum.

I think it was SK killing scum and Vig killing town. I don't know.
What are the odds of killing scum night one? I know it was more 25% than 50%.

Ahem. It was a 50% chance that the Vig killed the scum, rather than the SK killing the scum.

(eyeroll)

[LoudmouthLee]

I'm all for being serious on the first page, The only point of random voting is because there's nothing serious to talk about yet. If there's something serious, go for it.

As far as vigging goes, you may have a significantly higher chance to hit town, but hitting mafia is worth more. I'm not saying I'd recommend night one kills, but saying that you're more likely to hit town than mafia isn't the whole story.

As far a random vote, I'd

Vote TylerJ

because his avatar claimed godfather.

FoS: Shteven

You make the same "tone" mistake that Jordan makes. I dislike it. It makes me feel that you KNOW more than you should.

I wouldn't be shocked that one of them (Jordan and Shteven) is the SK and the other is the Vig.

[LoudmouthLee]

vote: Jordan

FoS: shteven

Tone thing is pretty big, but I'm more concerned about the way they both have tried to move suspicion back onto LML (although shteven not as much as Jordan). I don't understand how anything LML has done so far is anti-town.

I think you meant "although Jordan not as much as Shteven".

[LoudmouthLee]

Yeah, but I was inflecting on your own playstyle.

White makes short posts = Townie
White makes long posts = SCUM!

I know this to be untrue. He was making monster long posts in the newbie game in which I wrecked him in. He was town and mislynched.

[LoudmouthLee]

I, with baited breath, await the Mod's return to this thread.

I'm unhappy with the results of this thread.

Mod, if you are unsure as what to do about this sitiuation (I know I would be floored, and I have modded for a long time), I recommend talking to MeMe and asking her advice.

I strongly recommend

NOT

removing any references, as they have happened and probably WILL be referenced again in this game.

[LoudmouthLee]

Because it

HAPPENED.

We may need to refrence it later, especially if there are replacements in the game.

[LoudmouthLee]

Okay fine, but I refuse to have them used in argument against anyone, ongoing games are ongoing, and they should stay out of other ongoing games.

Here's what bothers me, Oman.

#1) This, in my opinion, casts a much darker shadow on AlyG than you. However, your incredible amounts of "defensiveness" makes me a little bit concerned.

I feel like you're going through a "I'm scum, and I shouldn't be lynched over something like this!"

I feel a town alligned player would have just waited for the mod to come and fix it, rather than an outcry for having it removed. I am not prepared to vote you on it, as it's unfortunate. However, you will probably be lynched over it.

If I were mod, I would modkill AlyG, but that's just me. Your reactions to the whole ordeal makes for interesting banter.

Major FoS: Oman

[LoudmouthLee]

The reaction, not the reference.

[LoudmouthLee]

yeah I think you are correct..honestly I didnt even meta those games until Oman freaked out.

QFT.

Neither did I.

[LoudmouthLee]

Okay, I got defensive because a player should have the integrity not to break the rules, anyone who breaks the rules (intentionally!) pisses me off mightly.

How do you know the intent was malicious?

[LoudmouthLee]

I am interested to hear AlyG comments at this point..

side question: both of your (Oman, LML) are on Jordan...do you both still think he is the SK?

Something about Jordan's D1 posts seem off to me, hence why I have not removed my vote.

[LoudmouthLee]

Just re-read (Sorry, was getting MS Mole set up).

I'm not feeling the laptop gun wagon, and I'm not crazy about the Oman wagon. The following people kinda peaked the scum meter in the past week.

-Ooba (Posting very little content while throwing suspicion around)
-Aimee (Her callout of SSF came out of nowhere. I have seen this a million times before. It's called the

Mafia Off Voter Play.

A mafia member puts pressure out of nowhere just so, if there's the tracing of votes later on, you see that one had the vote on the other.

I have tweaked my meta read of Jordan, and I'm willing to totally wait on him, for now.

Unvote.
Vote: Aimee
FoS: SomeStrangeFlea

[LoudmouthLee]

Your opinion, and you're allowed it.

I think SSF's reaction to it sealed it for me.