Mini 1774: Formation of America's Mafiascum - Perfect Town W

[Klingoncelt]

Prod dodge

This was alchemists last post.

It was before you called him 2ND best lynch.

What changed between post 819 and 855

It certainly wasn't alchemist with his 0 posts in-between.

It was a re-read of his ISO.

I re-read everyone's ISO and made the list from there.

I wish I could place Suzune and I wish I weren't scumreadng Firebringer.

[Klingoncelt]

I am surprised that I went from a townread for Klingoncelt, to full blown scum read in only 2-3 pages.
I mean, a lot of those reads drastically change.

I am wondering if Kling actually would do that as scum tho or if her mind is just so scattered she really doesn't know where to begin.

Actually it

was

scattered last week. The holiday frenzy has died down so I'm able to start focusing better now.

[Klingoncelt]

I don't know about you Kling.
WHY CANT YOU EVER GIVE ME A STRONG READ EIETHER WAY!!

UNVOTE:

Because I'm often scattered? R/L is nuts.

Also, I've been trying to keep my Town/Scum playstyles the same, so I'm not super obviously scummy when I roll Scum.

I've learned that life is safer in the Null pile.

[Firebringer]

At this point I am so indecisive I want to no lynch.

>.>

Suzune, *hint* what you think about using it on diefire? *hint*

So good with those hints.

[Killthestory]

this game is stagnated, so we should lynch kling clearly

[Shiro]

Guys please at least if you decide to lynch me don't ignore my reads after death.

Ignoring the reads of dead townies loses games.

[Persivul]

So give us a current reads list.

[White Fire]

Kling and you

Off chance it is fire

[Suzune]

I see, thanks for the hint there firebringer. I have read it.

I am swing back and for forth here on my feelings for Kling. I tend to disagree with his reads lists and I am beginning to think more and more that he might be scum. He is working very hard to keep things going but, very little resonates positive with me.

VOTE: Kling

[Suzune]

I think there are people who would be better though fire.

[Firebringer]

So who would you rather I do....

[Suzune]

Ah misunderstood. For that it is a good choice.

[BBmolla]

Life busy af

[Nosferatu]

Okay, more than an hour.

Reads List:
TOWN
Alchemist21
Beeboy
Firebringer
Persivul

NULL
BBmolla
Dierfire
Nosferatu
Suzune

SCUM
Killthestory
Shiro


Discuss.

I'll lynch you Kill.


I am waiting for a shiro lynch imo

An Alchemist lynch is my 2nd choice.

It got busy here at Grand Central, but finally here's the list. I modified it a bit. Nosferatu's up, Firebringer's down. Shiro's Null-ish.

TOWN
Alchemist21 - Paying attention, calling out stuff as he sees it.

Beeboy - His thought processes are similar to mine.

Persivul - His scumgame is horrible. He's not playing baly, therefore he's nearly confirmed Town.

Nosferatu - Tunnel on SirCakes was good.

NULL
BBmolla - Lurking and tiny posts always bug me. The tiny posts aren't horrible, at least, but this could end up being a policy lynch down the road.

Dierfire - Obviously engaging other posters, generating content, keeping the game going. Not necessarily Alignment Indicative, though, I've seen Scum do it. I don't know Dier well enough.

Suzune - Her Town and Scum games are good enough that I can't sort her yet.

Shiro - Fluffy. More policy lynch material.

SCUM
Firebringer - The tunnel on Window Attack was... unfortunate. I find myself at odds with his post 277 reads list too. It looks like he's just throwing suspects out there to see what sticks.

Killthestory - I'm seeing a lot of Wanting To Be Town Leader here. I see that a lot from Scum.

I'll lynch you Kill.


I am waiting for a shiro lynch imo

An Alchemist lynch is my 2nd choice.

It got busy here at Grand Central, but finally here's the list. I modified it a bit. Nosferatu's up, Firebringer's down. Shiro's Null-ish.

TOWN
Alchemist21 - Paying attention, calling out stuff as he sees it.

NULL
Shiro - Fluffy. More policy lynch material.

.

Good to know your 1St Choice for lynxh is a null Pl and your 2ND choice your top townread.

Can we lynch her now?

I believe I said that I modified my list.

Are you suggesting that reads can't change during the game? Because they can, you know. They should.

You went from town to lynch to town again?

[Dierfire]

As best as I can tell, everyone is voting for Klingoncelt or Shiro currently.

I'm willing to vote for either at this point. My slight preference for Shiro is a combination of the fact that Klingoncelt is not voting for Shiro (seems not to indicate the survivalist impulse that I would expect from a Mafia player at this point) and that Shiro hasn't given any reasons for any reads.
I'm willing to change my vote to Klingoncelt because I still think that there should be a high density of Mafia players on the D1 Window Attack wagon.
---
I've just remembered to check on BBMolla and I see that his vote in on me, which surprised me.

@BBMolla

Why is your vote on me? Why do you think that Shiro and Klingoncelt are both Town?

[Nosferatu]

tfw I just now realize my name has been spelled wrong in every VC.

[Klingoncelt]

this game is stagnated, so we should lynch kling clearly

What?

Do you ever say anything sensible? Or do you have some kind of post restriction?

[Klingoncelt]

Kling and you

Off chance it is fire

Great hydra slip.

[Klingoncelt]

I see, thanks for the hint there firebringer. I have read it.

I am swing back and for forth here on my feelings for Kling. I tend to disagree with his reads lists and I am beginning to think more and more that he might be scum. He is working very hard to keep things going but, very little resonates positive with me.

VOTE: Kling

Funny, I was thinking the same thing about you.

And you forgot that I'm a "she."

[Klingoncelt]

You went from town to lynch to town again?

I had Alch as Town, yes.

Then he said something that pinged. Now Alch is a clever player, so when I saw it I thought 'oh, he's actually Scum!' When I re-read his ISO, though, I realized that I misunderstood what he was saying. So he's back to Town. Very solidly, I might add.

[Klingoncelt]

... I still think that there should be a high density of Mafia players on the D1 Window Attack wagon.

I don't put too much stock in Day 1 wagons myself. Too much confusion that early on.

(Myself, when I roll Scum I try to get the Team's votes spread out among all the candidates. Harder to pin any of us down that way.)

And IC Titus will tell you not to do VCA's before Day 3.

[Klingoncelt]

tfw I just now realize my name has been spelled wrong in every VC.

Nosterfaru



I never noticed.

[Klingoncelt]

Mod needs a prod...

[Shiro]

Kling and you

Off chance it is fire

Yea oopsie xD

[Firebringer]

I don't want to lynch Shiro or Kling.
I have a soft spot for both of them right now, and I am completely divided on either of them being scum right now >.>