Prophecy Mafia - Over

[SeraphicMirth]

vote all of team asshat

pure jealousy

[SeraphicMirth]

vote Stark

b/c they haven't posted yet

[SeraphicMirth]

vote death_omen

same reasons..no talkie!

[SeraphicMirth]

I know, I know, jokevote stage and all, but "being confused" is often a scumtell.

QFT.

and I am also curious as to to Kanaga's reference only to Jedi and bubka...they aren't being targeted as scum or anything ATM, so why pick those to say they could easily be town? And really, at this point, anyone can easily be town.

[SeraphicMirth]

I did expand on why I specifically thought it was an odd comment, so that was my own opinion. Kthanks.

And that makes sense about their vote position..I didn't look at that in relation to your comment originally.

[SeraphicMirth]

I don't know the vote count right now. So, I'll vote for one of those quiet people..it's what I do at the start, I suppose.

vote UltimaAvalon

What say you about the Kanaga situation?

[SeraphicMirth]

There are other ways to get through d1, for sure. I always like games to get as far as possible without any claiming. You are pro-massclaiming..but on d1 as well?? I mean, I can see maybe a little later on in a game possibly helping but on day 1? meh.

[SeraphicMirth]

Could it be remotely possible they MIGHT claim on a later day when people were voting for them?

Is that what you're saying you meant originally??

[SeraphicMirth]

not only in the context of mass claiming day 1 but in their own actual sentence it says "if we did have a mass claim", it does not say "if they get voted and they have to claim". 2 totally different things. Hence, why I asked if they meant that originally. I was waiting for a "yes" and then pointing out the direct contradiction but..eh. it's obvious anyway.

so,

vote Kanaga

[SeraphicMirth]

Yeah, that wasn't me. :-/

[SeraphicMirth]

Also, how is it not scummy when you say that there would be cop claims with a mass claim and then turn around and say you meant cop claims if they were about to be lynched? They're 2 totally different things and you clearly meant one, not the other.

Now, the original line of questioning here-

there would be cop claims, etc. if we did have a mass claim.

What Cop Claims would there be on Day 1?

I didn't really see that as so scummy...yeah, if there was a mass claim, I suppose there would be cop claims in that..so your statement is kind of like a neutral to me. But, after you contradicted yourself by saying you meant that they would claim if they were to get hung instead of in a mass claim..you got my vote. I'm not down with contradictions.

[SeraphicMirth]

People don't (and shouldn't) claim cop unless they have investigations. We have had no investigations, so at this point, if we were to all massclaim today, we would have no cops claim

So the cops would lie in that case and claim town? I haven't seen a massclaim myself yet.
Anyway, interesting point, thanks for clarifying.

[SeraphicMirth]

And I think I mistook Seraphic's post, when she said "their" I thought she was saying that Kakeng and I were the same person.

ah...yes, I have a problem with using pronouns and use "they" or "their" often..my bad

[SeraphicMirth]

I'm L/A over this weekend, visiting home from college. Sorry!!

[SeraphicMirth]

Soooo... game??

I don't really have anything to add to the inanity of "he's lurking cuz he's lurking and you said he's lurking and you didn't say lurking, etc, etc," stuff going on. but..I'm here and I haven't posted in like a week I think :-/ whoops!

I guess I understand the weird arguments against people thus far...there hasn't been anything too substantial to make serious cases of but ...how do we get there?

I'll try reading through and seeing if there are any sort of patterns so far or something. I dunno.

[SeraphicMirth]

I'm still around. I think the vote against bubka is weak but so is everything else. So, while I won't vote and support..I don't really mind if it happens just to get the game moving. I dunno. Terrible way to play, but it's how i feel right now. lol

Anyway, I'm more posting to say I'll be gone all weekend, in case I was gonna get prodded or something.

[SeraphicMirth]

I agree with a deadline extension...if we get focused.

I think backing off of bubka is a good idea, especially now that he's claimed and the original argument against him was pretty weak anyway (though I don't get why he wasn't making more of an effort to defend himself).

If his claim is indeed true...would looking into the bandwagon right now be of any help or is it too iffy since we don't know the truth for sure?

oh and

unvote

I didn't mean to leave my vote like that for so long!! lol

[SeraphicMirth]

Um, here's a quick review:
dumb unrelated topic, dumb unrelated topic, weak reasoning bandwagon, dumb unrelated topic, weak reasoning bandwagon, ...and not much more than that..



Anyone who sees it as different, feel free to catch him up.