Mini 1774: Formation of America's Mafiascum - Perfect Town W

[Nosferatu]

Nos, give me your top three town and scum reads gun to head please.
~wgeurts

town:
1. suzune
2. BBmolla
3. idfk

scum:
1. Dierfire
2. SirCakez
3. idfk

[Suzune]

calling someone on tunneling on page 7 is bad.

Why? Is being called out for tunneling better some how if it happens on page 14 or page 45? Also on the subject of tunneling I do not feel like Firebringer would have any reason to do this as scum because in the event he is wrong, that places all the focus on him as one of the main drivers of the train. For this reason, I think I can say with slight reasonablness right now that Firebringer is a slight town lead for me.

How about you two stop fighting and we lynch widow attack

I think that we can reasonably assume there is more then one mafia in this game. Therefore, it serves the town little value to quick lynch so early into day one. We should use this time to get reads on other players as well because this is a good time to do that. Town hunting is important too.

Hey FB, Can Shiro sheep you and lynch scum? I trust you are town.

Well where do you stand? I have heard where Firebringer stands what is your position on it. Or is it a blind sheep?

[Firebringer]

Sheep your townread Suzune!
You know you want to!

[Suzune]

I think the problem with Kill comes down to, at the very heart of it, that he is not doing anything. He spends all his post time complaining about what people say about him, defending himself, and nitpicking other people. But he never comes out and pushes for anything. That is what makes the defensiveness of the slot that much worse because we only ever see reaction. I am interested to see if they develop a little otherwise the cards are not stacked in their favour.

The only other slot that is currently up for suspicion on me is Shiro. I would like to hear from that slot quite a bit. Right now she(?) does not have any original posts that really discuss the game state. Shiro while I said this above, no one reads catch up posts, where do you stand? Discuss the gamestate with me.

p-edit- No I do not sheep people. Plus I would not want the round to end so early. This is a good chance to hear from and push many players. I think it is foolish to move for a quick lynch as it limits information.

[Firebringer]

Stop being a stereotypical town.
Its boring.

[Suzune]

Take a walk in my head for a few minutes late game and you will see what I am thinking for. You are just risky and enjoy the gamble. I appreciate that quality as a mafia but as a townie, not so much.

[Firebringer]

>_>
Suzune, stop calling me bad and just sheep me.
Widow is scum! We can figure out who is scum with vote analysis afterwards.

Not wanting to just to figure more stuff out is just annoying and attempting to derail this train.

[Killthestory]

What the fuck?

i was literally pushing whats their face at the time, r u blind?

[Firebringer]

Pretty sure Killthestory is town too.

[Suzune]

I do not believe I called you bad by any stretch of the imagination. You enjoy the risk. What is wrong with that. See I am beginning to think that kill is a better target or at the very least, I want to see where that goes. I will tell you the honest truth I never have seen vote count work as a way to find scum in a mafia game. Are you going to attempt it?

Wait, are you suggesting that it is a annoying to want to figure things out? Or the other way around?

p-edit, you are mentioning you do not like them kill. But you are doing little to engage them.

[Killthestory]

LOL BRO.

Thanks for not reading my ISO. When I started scumreading him all my posts were centered around him, and I was pushing him. Once again, r u blind?

W E W L A D S, some people just can't read for shit.

[Firebringer]

LOL BRO.

Thanks for not reading my ISO. When I started scumreading him all my posts were centered around him, and I was pushing him. Once again, r u blind?

W E W L A D S, some people just can't read for shit.

Who are you arguing with?
Its like your having an imaginary argument with someone lol.

[Killthestory]

Read Suzune's posts lad

[Suzune]

Well your main case on him seems to be the contradiction between the posting order, therefore, I am wondering how to intend to continue it. Or picking at other people's responses but not really pushing them about it. That is what I mean.

p-edit, he is talking to me

[Killthestory]

No my main case was me misinterpreting him when he said, "This is my first." I assumed he had been talking about votes, of which I pulled up his other 4 (?) votes.

I only pick at shit that is insignificant but still stupid

[Suzune]

Okay since you think I cannot read, let's run though the game shall we. Or at least the beeboy parts:

186 You mention your opinion on them
188 You question if that is their typical play
191 You mention you have bad vibes
203 Vote order post
204 You think they are backtracking because beeboy said something about being the first on you
209 filler
210 Fight with window. You are not voting beeboy at this point
218 fight with window.

Am I missing something. If you feel strongly about it you do not push it or even vote for it. Instead you put more effort into your defense posts. This is why I find you not doing much.

[Killthestory]

posting order for votes doesn't matter. It was just to show I wasn't his first vote.

Tbh voting back on the old forum I played on was uncommon this early in the day, so I forget at times lmfao.

Anyway I was fucking pushing him lol. Once again, I ask, r u blind.

[Suzune]

I guess we have a different definition of what pushing them looks like. Repeating what I disagree with you about does not make me believe it. I believe I explained what I saw therefore, I am not blind, just not seeing what you see. I am expecting more and with equal terms of engagement. Right now I have your attention, we can discuss things. That makes this a useful discussion.

Likewise, I tend to hold my vote until I am ready.

[Shiro]

FB <3 Let's act as if we are a hydra but talk in the main thread. Like, we just added double voted to our role and we are cool.

Vote:Window

[Dierfire]

I feel like a few people are voting for Window Attack (although it's difficult to be certain as we haven't had a VC in some time). I did a short ISO there and I don't see anything that makes me agree with Firebringer's opinion (that Window Attack's posts seems fake). I think that all of their reads are reasonable, although I think that they're prematurely discounting the potential that Nosferatu would vote for Persivul as Town (it's an easy reason to vote for Persivul as Mafia precisely because the reasoning from a Town perspective is obvious). I'm undecided on Killthestory--some of the problem might be stylistic or (site-specific) cultural.

[Dierfire]

Oh, hey, I missed that Nosferatu was voting for me.

@Nosferatu

Why are you voting for me?

[Firebringer]

FB <3 Let's act as if we are a hydra but talk in the main thread. Like, we just added double voted to our role and we are cool.

Vote:Window

Cool, lets now talk about all the players behind their backs where they can read it.

IT WILL BE GOOD TIMES FOR ALL!

We should really revive White Fire sometime, we did good with that Hydra.

[Killthestory]

Suzune is definitive town. She's not pushing me with a scum mindset, too open to possibilities.

[Firebringer]

Suzune is definitive town. She's not pushing me with a scum mindset, too open to possibilities.

You should open your vote to Widow Attack.
That will prove your towniness to all.

Even though it is obvious to me.

[Killthestory]

Suzune is definitive town. She's not pushing me with a scum mindset, too open to possibilities.

You should open your vote to Widow Attack.
That will prove your towniness to all.

Even though it is obvious to me.

Currently, I actually don't mind. I'd like to see how this wagon progresses the game.

VOTE: Window