Open 38 - Jester Mafia 12p (Game Over!) - before 484

[ryan]

So why do you want to move on to night BUT yet you are worried we could end the game prematurely? That seems to be a slight contradiction

[Kerplunk]

That doesn't give them an excuse just because they are exprienced. I hate the fact that players who "play that way" are given a free pass to Day 2. That's just a joke if you ask me. Everyone is guilty until proven innocent in mafiascum.

If people consequently vote for them in every game they play this way, that would be a way to condition them. Just like "lynch all liars". But people don't do that, because mostly there are others who more suspicious and they take the irritating playing style for granted.

I understand you don't like it, but I don't think you can do much about it without changing the rules. And I think the game of mafia should have as less rules as possible.

And of course everyone is guilty untill proven innocent, but some are more suspicious than others.

[ryan]

Maybe voting them would get them to change their playstyle. I just don't like games where people lurk so they don't look guilty, that is just a stupid excuse to not participate. This game is about playing, and people who don't want to do that shouldn't sign up for games.

[Blue Zebra]

Now seeking a replacement for PookyTheMagicalBear.

Vote Count

d3sisted (5): Kerplunk, Numenorean7, Atticus, distad, Jimmy R
Atticus (2): somestrangeflea, PookyTheMagicalBear
ryan (1): JDodge
JDodge (1): Jex
Max (1): d3sisted

Not Voting: Max, ryan

[d3sisted]

we need to move onto a night here the first day lynch is always vital and normally the first day is over by now admittedly theres a jester but it can't rule the game for all we know it could be me it could be ryan, d3sisted anyone but the only players that are near hammer is d3sisted I think he is mafia but with that comes a risk of ending the game prematurely

HoS: d3sisted

That's the biggest crock of shit I've ever seen. First you say I'm Jester and now you say I'm scum? Stick to your story and play consistently.

My vote definitely stays.

[Blue Zebra]

PookyTheMagicalBear has been replaced by yeahitismark.

[ryan]

Welcome yeahitismark

[yeahitismark]

Morning all, just read it all. Ryan and d3sisted seem really angry at being supected, more angry than a fake-anger would be, I highly doubt they are Jesters.

Kerplunk replaced someone giving off Jester vibes and quietened down. I would have said Jester vibes but I dunno.

Max reads as insane townie. His talk of night killing instead of replacing and so forth.

That's about it really, don't have any gut feelings about who the mafia is apart from the angry pair, and I'm not about to put D3sisted on L-1 as soon as I'm replaced in. Better to let the game sink in and participate before condemning.

[Max]

I think you should unvote atticus now
We need to move to night then we have a lead for tomorrow.

Now if we constantly fear the jester the jester wins.

vote: d3sisted

[JDodge]

we need to move onto a night here the first day lynch is always vital and normally the first day is over by now admittedly theres a jester but it can't rule the game for all we know it could be me it could be ryan, d3sisted anyone but the only players that are near hammer is d3sisted I think he is mafia but with that comes a risk of ending the game prematurely

HoS: d3sisted

That's the biggest crock of shit I've ever seen. First you say I'm Jester and now you say I'm scum? Stick to your story and play consistently.

My vote definitely stays.

This statement officially wins

[Numenorean7]

Everyone please note: since Max's vote,

any further vote on d3sisted will be a hammer

. Most of you probably noticed this, but I've been in too many games in which someone claims they dropped the hammer unintentionally.

[d3sisted]

I think you should unvote atticus now
We need to move to night then we have a lead for tomorrow.

Now if we constantly fear the jester the jester wins.

vote: d3sisted

This is funny. The very first thing he said upon entering this game is that I'm Jester. So what does he go and do? Not only does he vote me, he's put me at L-1, saying "Now if we constantly fear the jester the jester wins. "

[Numenorean7]

He said, "now admittedly theres a jester but it can't rule the game for all we know it could be me it could be ryan, d3sisted anyone" He never said you're the Jester.

[ryan]

To those not voting d3sisted (including yours truly) who are the other top suspects at this time? Seeing d3sisted at -1 makes me skeptical that a few scum hopped on that wagon. Especially with him being at -1, I'm not confident on him as scum. I'll do a re-read and see if anything jumps out worth hammering.

[somestrangeflea]

I am getting

HUGE

Jester vibes from Max. His posts seem to be trying to push a d3sisted lynch, but it seems as though he's actually trying to make his case on d3sisted seem poor.

FoJS: Max

[Atticus]

I could not post yesterday, and today I will be gone for a couple hours, starting now. I'll be able to read and post later.

[d3sisted]

Vote: d3sisted

[Blue Zebra]

Vote Count

d3sisted (7): Kerplunk, Numenorean7, Atticus, distad, Jimmy R, Max, d3sisted
Atticus (2): somestrangeflea, PookyTheMagicalBear
ryan (1): JDodge
JDodge (1): Jex

Not Voting: ryan

d3sisted:

Jester

has been lynched Day One

d3sisted wins and everyone else loses!

[d3sisted]

Man, never knew how hard it is to draw suspicion on yourself. Seems so much easier in other games.

[Atticus]

Well done d3sisted!

[Jex]

Wow, I go away for a few days and come back and the game is over. Grats d3sisted! Do we get to know who the mafia were?

[yeahitismark]

Some mad fine fake anger there! well played

[somestrangeflea]

Fantastic play from d3sisted.

Does this mean that the other 11 of us have been Endgamed?

[Atticus]

I was a one shot doc.

[Numenorean7]

I should have known when you started repeating the Jester defense. Well done.

Who were the Mafia? I was a vanilla townie.