NY 178: MASQUERADE -- GAME OVER
-
-
Boonskiies That's Not All, Folks!
- That's Not All, Folks!
- That's Not All, Folks!
- Posts: 17939
- Joined: June 11, 2014
- Location: SF
I believe Anen was town reading me strongly."Let it be known that almost everything Boonskiies said is either hilarious or annoying." - Shinobi
Yes, I'mFlavor Leaf. That's my main; I just mod onBoonskiies.-
-
Boonskiies That's Not All, Folks!
- That's Not All, Folks!
- That's Not All, Folks!
- Posts: 17939
- Joined: June 11, 2014
- Location: SF
During the night Iz brought up how there is 'probably' a fourth neighborhood. He also said he is new to neighborhoods and doesn't know the ideal play in these situations. Those two don't match up. Why would you think there is probably a fourth neighborhood if you are new to them unless one of your scum partners are in it, and they told you during the night?"Let it be known that almost everything Boonskiies said is either hilarious or annoying." - Shinobi
Yes, I'mFlavor Leaf. That's my main; I just mod onBoonskiies.-
-
Izariael Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 534
- Joined: July 27, 2014
- Location: Narnia
Boonskiies wrote:During the night Iz brought up how there is 'probably' a fourth neighborhood. He also said he is new to neighborhoods and doesn't know the ideal play in these situations. Those two don't match up. Why would you think there is probably a fourth neighborhood if you are new to them unless one of your scum partners are in it, and they told you during the night?
Okay... wow. I'm gonna leave it to goodmorning and Shino to say whether this is misrep, because I feel that it's pretty blatant misrep. I gave theexact reason(I LINKED THE POST FOR YOU) of why I thought this. If you didn't read it, then fine, but don't put words in my mouth. I never even used the word 'probably' in that entire post, nor did I hint at it. In fact, I specifically said we haveno confirmation of a fourth neighborhoodand should move forward assuming 3 until proven otherwise.
Go reread the post, please and thank you.I have the comprehensive ability of a vegetable.-
-
davesaz HeSurvivorHe
- Survivor
- Survivor
- Posts: 12556
- Joined: August 24, 2014
- Pronoun: He
- Location: Socially distant
In post 2619, Boonskiies wrote:Thor's town. And it's multiball...
These points, that you just posted.-
-
Flubbernugget Survivor
-
-
Izariael Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 534
- Joined: July 27, 2014
- Location: Narnia
In post 2618, goodmorning wrote:
I personally think that plan was a bit of aterribleidea, but I would like to hear from you on the subject of the thing I brought up, if you don't mind.
I'm glad you brought it up, as I was planning to do so anyway. I never got a chance to touch on it before the thread lock because of Halloween stuff. That means that everyone here who isn't in our hood gets a really vague post (which you can hopefully follow soundly):
I will admit, your final post of the night left me a bit confused, as I didn't understand what was tipping you off in such a manner. Anen's post that followed it was able to shed light on it for me though, and I will say I have to agree. It looks that way because I was not properly applying my own stance to thescenario. I've been basing most of my thoughts around NOT assuming it's guaranteed. But then suddenly my comment looked as though I said WAS guaranteed. It was a disconnect of logic that unfortunately pervades pretty much everything I said about the topic last nightfullandon Day 1. To clarify, my stance is the former - NOT guaranteed. That is how I will be operating and you, Boonskiies and Shiro can hold me to that.
Having seen where you're coming from, and now understanding where my reasoning went awry, I'm now following why you took the stance you've taken since the start of Day 1. Your stance has been consistent at the very least, and I'm definitely townreading it now that I'm understanding it a bit better. On day 1 I had thought you were being a bit dodgy about it unnecessarily, but now I think you were right to do so.
You're welcome to follow through with theterribleplan, and heck, I would probably endorse it after seeing the angle you are approaching it from.
Also, I appreciate your vagueness on the matter, especially given how Boonskiies is launching out of the Day 2 gate...I have the comprehensive ability of a vegetable.-
-
Flubbernugget Survivor
-
-
AxleGreaser Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 3346
- Joined: April 19, 2014
- Location: (+10)
In post 2607, Boonskiies wrote:I'm not answering it because you'll just come up with an ignorant response, so I decide that I'm better off just ignoring you so I don't get frustrated.
Oh noes I have duel of wits with Boonskies
VOTE: boonskies-
-
Izariael Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 534
- Joined: July 27, 2014
- Location: Narnia
Many of my reads from 1875 still currently stand until I voice that I've modified them. I haven't fully evaluated how the flips have changed things for me. I'm still going just from what I've seen of day one at this point until I do so.
The read on T S O that I posted back in 368 was null because of ongoing games, but since NY176 has ended with T S O as town I would say that I'm townreading T S O. I did admittedly gloss over several of his posts though, so I might be missing something indicative. I think his interaction with Csareo and later with Axle is in line with what I was seeing of his interaction with reinoe in NY176. I am interested in seeing where he chooses to go today with his top scumread dead (and flipped town)
Greyfoxxx has all but disappeared, though I did like him for town what little we saw from him, and didn't have a scumread on Csareo when he was in slot either. I am keen to see a new face in the slot though.I have the comprehensive ability of a vegetable.-
-
Boonskiies That's Not All, Folks!
- That's Not All, Folks!
- That's Not All, Folks!
- Posts: 17939
- Joined: June 11, 2014
- Location: SF
Axle's voting me even though I've made it pretty obvious that I'm a PR. Interesting. I'll hop on a wagon that starts on Axle if no one sees Iz as scum. @Flubb - Thank you. You also just got finished with my last scum game, and will be able to tell if I'm scum or not pretty easily probably."Let it be known that almost everything Boonskiies said is either hilarious or annoying." - Shinobi
Yes, I'mFlavor Leaf. That's my main; I just mod onBoonskiies.-
-
Izariael Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 534
- Joined: July 27, 2014
- Location: Narnia
In post 2631, Flubbernugget wrote:Yeaah I can see Iz as scum.
For having a vague reply to a vague question? I think goodmorning and I are on the same page of wanting to keep the details of our discussion within the neighborhood.
If there's more to it than that I'm all ears.I have the comprehensive ability of a vegetable.-
-
beastcharizard Mafia Scum
-
-
Izariael Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 534
- Joined: July 27, 2014
- Location: Narnia
In post 2636, beastcharizard wrote:Who is sheepable?
No one. Read the game and try to form a read. Thanks.I have the comprehensive ability of a vegetable.-
-
Boonskiies That's Not All, Folks!
- That's Not All, Folks!
- That's Not All, Folks!
- Posts: 17939
- Joined: June 11, 2014
- Location: SF
beast, Iz is sheepable. Also, so is Axle."Let it be known that almost everything Boonskiies said is either hilarious or annoying." - Shinobi
Yes, I'mFlavor Leaf. That's my main; I just mod onBoonskiies.-
-
Izariael Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 534
- Joined: July 27, 2014
- Location: Narnia
In post 2634, Boonskiies wrote:Axle's voting me even though I've made it pretty obvious that I'm a PR. Interesting. I'll hop on a wagon that starts on Axle if no one sees Iz as scum.
Yeah, you've made it pretty obvious;tooobvious IMO. Butclaimingto have a role doesn't mean youhavea role. I don't think it's indicative of Axle's alignment to vote against you and you should be careful of joining a wagon on Axle if this is your sole reason for doing so.
Personally, I have my doubts that you are what you say you are, but for today I'm fine with not pushing for proof.I have the comprehensive ability of a vegetable.-
-
Izariael Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 534
- Joined: July 27, 2014
- Location: Narnia
In post 2638, Boonskiies wrote:beast, Iz is sheepable. Also, so is Axle.
Haaah!
This guy; what a jokester!I have the comprehensive ability of a vegetable.-
-
Boonskiies That's Not All, Folks!
- That's Not All, Folks!
- That's Not All, Folks!
- Posts: 17939
- Joined: June 11, 2014
- Location: SF
Of course you do. ;p"Let it be known that almost everything Boonskiies said is either hilarious or annoying." - Shinobi
Yes, I'mFlavor Leaf. That's my main; I just mod onBoonskiies.-
-
Flubbernugget Survivor
- Survivor
- Survivor
- Posts: 11751
- Joined: June 26, 2014
In post 2634, Boonskiies wrote:Axle's voting me even though I've made it pretty obvious that I'm a PR. Interesting. I'll hop on a wagon that starts on Axle if no one sees Iz as scum. @Flubb - Thank you. You also just got finished with my last scum game, and will be able to tell if I'm scum or not pretty easily probably.
Yeah this claim is a carbon copy of your tracker fakeclaim.-
-
AxleGreaser Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 3346
- Joined: April 19, 2014
- Location: (+10)
Spoiler: fluff
@Axle
I'm willing to answer questions as long as they don't get caught up in one subject and we get stuck debating the same thing for the whole day so take them as final and if you have any criticism about it just note it and move TO ANOTHER POST.
In post 2481, AxleGreaser wrote:In post 2441, Garmr wrote:axle this is the last time I'm going to talk about that initial conversation with anne
fuck It here it goes. What I found scummy was I didn't like the he stopped my pressure on boon at the time boon was a weak scum read and I wanted more reactions to get a feel for him. Annenin comes in and trys to dismantle my case because he doesn't agree (Town motive)/wants to discredit(scum motive what I think) he fails to do so as my points still actually stand. I believe he had to try and discredit because I don't think he was expecting to be questioned on 418 becuase he just labeled me as scum because of my reasoning for voting boon and getting lost early in the game, if he is going to label me as scum for my reasoning he should be able to show why it's flawed and then explain the scum motivation behind my post.
Plus I have Labeled other reasons why I think annenien is scummy especially His victim complex in post 1003 and he continues to show it in 1050 trying to gain sympathy.
That's the short of it.
Lets do this one bit at a time
Garmr: "What I found scummy was I didn't like the he stopped my pressure on boon at the time boon was a weak scum read and I wanted more reactions to get a feel for him."here is way you described it earlier
Garmr: "It's the fact you tried to discredit my points. Which you weren't able to then you just brushed it off passively by saying oh well we don't agree. It really cut any progress on boonskies short as he hasn't provided much content."
So if he failed to discredit your points how did it cut any progress on Boonskies?
@Garmr
You missed a question
If your points were still valid and sound how did the pressure just go away and you not pursue Boonskies?
Spoiler: what pressure on boonskies?
garmr wrote:
Axle wrote:
While that may be bad play (and personally I do try not to cut across other peoples lines of enquiry.
have you examined how Aneninen plays to see if it was something thats just bound to happen, with how he plays?
He comments on sooooo many things in a post by post way, that if he sees something and has a point of view he posts it.
So Aneninen's natural play is just likely to do that and in 3/4 of the games you play with him he will be town and your likely to scum read him for that....
Seems to me like your tell on him is not very reliable. (You will find him to be scum in 100% of his games)
Well he flipped town so I guess you were right about this bit but Inever played a game with himbefore and this was different than his newbie game(can chalk that up to trying to improve but did the reverse?)
yeah I had the guessed, after I saw the Aneninen flip, that you might approach the day this way.
You do indeed now(or always did if you are scum), know your push was wrong.
the flip however relieves none of my concerns that you were pushing a read in way, for reasons, I found inconsistent with you being town.
and although younever played a game with himthat was the exact reason I referred you to an appropriate game to get a feel for him.
Spoiler: BTW @Aneneinen
So far... Uncontested points.
Spoiler: Garmr not considering timing
Failing to consider timing is not inherently scummy, but having scum reads inconsistent with the facts, kinda is, as scum dont really have to try and work stuff out they just make it up and have tendency to stop when it looks right enough (but is still little inconsistent).
Garmr beingover sensitive about being labelled scum
Spoiler:
Garmr wrote:
I'm going to take a step back and look at this game with different set of lenses.
if you are town that would be a very good idea.
I think its probably a good one if your scum as well,
PS I may or may not have deleted important bits out of my original post this edit got unwieldy at some points.
Spoiler: meta discussion-
-
Flubbernugget Survivor
- Survivor
- Survivor
- Posts: 11751
- Joined: June 26, 2014
In post 2635, Izariael wrote:In post 2631, Flubbernugget wrote:Yeaah I can see Iz as scum.
For having a vague reply to a vague question? I think goodmorning and I are on the same page of wanting to keep the details of our discussion within the neighborhood.
If there's more to it than that I'm all ears.
Yeah get a little more aggressive and I can start town reading you.-
-
Flubbernugget Survivor
- Survivor
- Survivor
- Posts: 11751
- Joined: June 26, 2014
-
-
Muffin Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 2092
- Joined: September 17, 2009
-
-
Garmr Survivor
- Survivor
- Survivor
- Posts: 10482
- Joined: August 22, 2013
- Location: The Ban Thread
In post 2643, AxleGreaser wrote:Spoiler: fluff
@Axle
I'm willing to answer questions as long as they don't get caught up in one subject and we get stuck debating the same thing for the whole day so take them as final and if you have any criticism about it just note it and move TO ANOTHER POST.
In post 2481, AxleGreaser wrote:In post 2441, Garmr wrote:axle this is the last time I'm going to talk about that initial conversation with anne
fuck It here it goes. What I found scummy was I didn't like the he stopped my pressure on boon at the time boon was a weak scum read and I wanted more reactions to get a feel for him. Annenin comes in and trys to dismantle my case because he doesn't agree (Town motive)/wants to discredit(scum motive what I think) he fails to do so as my points still actually stand. I believe he had to try and discredit because I don't think he was expecting to be questioned on 418 becuase he just labeled me as scum because of my reasoning for voting boon and getting lost early in the game, if he is going to label me as scum for my reasoning he should be able to show why it's flawed and then explain the scum motivation behind my post.
Plus I have Labeled other reasons why I think annenien is scummy especially His victim complex in post 1003 and he continues to show it in 1050 trying to gain sympathy.
That's the short of it.
Lets do this one bit at a time
Garmr: "What I found scummy was I didn't like the he stopped my pressure on boon at the time boon was a weak scum read and I wanted more reactions to get a feel for him."here is way you described it earlier
Garmr: "It's the fact you tried to discredit my points. Which you weren't able to then you just brushed it off passively by saying oh well we don't agree. It really cut any progress on boonskies short as he hasn't provided much content."
So if he failed to discredit your points how did it cut any progress on Boonskies?
@Garmr
You missed a question
If your points were still valid and sound how did the pressure just go away and you not pursue Boonskies?
Spoiler: what pressure on boonskies?
garmr wrote:
Axle wrote:
While that may be bad play (and personally I do try not to cut across other peoples lines of enquiry.
have you examined how Aneninen plays to see if it was something thats just bound to happen, with how he plays?
He comments on sooooo many things in a post by post way, that if he sees something and has a point of view he posts it.
So Aneninen's natural play is just likely to do that and in 3/4 of the games you play with him he will be town and your likely to scum read him for that....
Seems to me like your tell on him is not very reliable. (You will find him to be scum in 100% of his games)
Well he flipped town so I guess you were right about this bit but Inever played a game with himbefore and this was different than his newbie game(can chalk that up to trying to improve but did the reverse?)
yeah I had the guessed, after I saw the Aneninen flip, that you might approach the day this way.
You do indeed now(or always did if you are scum), know your push was wrong.
the flip however relieves none of my concerns that you were pushing a read in way, for reasons, I found inconsistent with you being town.
and although younever played a game with himthat was the exact reason I referred you to an appropriate game to get a feel for him.
Spoiler: BTW @Aneneinen
So far... Uncontested points.
Spoiler: Garmr not considering timing
Failing to consider timing is not inherently scummy, but having scum reads inconsistent with the facts, kinda is, as scum dont really have to try and work stuff out they just make it up and have tendency to stop when it looks right enough (but is still little inconsistent).
Garmr beingover sensitive about being labelled scum
Spoiler:
Garmr wrote:
I'm going to take a step back and look at this game with different set of lenses.
if you are town that would be a very good idea.
I think its probably a good one if your scum as well,
PS I may or may not have deleted important bits out of my original post this edit got unwieldy at some points.
Spoiler: meta discussion
Depends it's situational if someone out the blue calls me scum with little to no reasoning I get a little annoyed and Notice how I didn't jump onto ane straight away and waited till after the conersation. I was trying to work him out. I'm more likely to react when pushed if someone is to buddy buddy or when someone scum reads me for shit reasons (or no reason). I work best if there's interaction between me and the person. Also if i can see the thought process and they are wrong but it's obvious they are town and they are trying I list them as town simple. Also If I'm admitting meta to you and showing meta where it actually happens then don't ignore it that is so fucking annoying since It's something I would do in aboutnearly every game I ever had.
Also wtf is with thatMisrepMy vote came off boon when I started reading him as town why do I need to apply pressure on a town read?
Also making shit up is lame you have to actually find things you would consider scummy as town then that way if your questioned on it you don't get caught out that's like scum 101. I'm proud of my record as scum (%100 win rate) not so proud of my town win rate (like 25%) so that's why i want to improve the latter. I know what to do if I actually care about being scum read and can cruise by with little to none actual work but when I care about hunting scum I put my mind out there.
Also I don't know your alignment where the fuck are you getting that from but my guess from yesterday still hasn't changed scum.
VOTE: Axle
@Axle you should vote me lets make this a 1v1 you and me.-
-
Izariael Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 534
- Joined: July 27, 2014
- Location: Narnia
I don't recall saying I don't have a read on him; I simply haven't posted one. I haven't done so because I don't know what to make of his claim yet.Flubbernugget wrote:Iz how come you don't have a read on boons?
I don't think Boonskiies is playing in a way that is beneficial for town, regardless of what role he may have or may be claiming. That leads me to think a fake claim is highly possible.
I think his claim is working against town here because:
1) He's suggesting that he's unlynchable because he's claimed a PR - I disagree. Claiming to have a PR does not mean you HAVE a PR, as I've said previously.
2) He's scumreading Axle for voting a claimed PR despite the fact that Axle has already made it clear that he doesn't believe the claim. This seems to be a mentality that stems from #1.
3) The majority of his scumhunting here and in neighborhood thread has to do with garnering reactions to his claim. While it's certainly valid to do so, I think limiting himself to that alone is not effective (see #2) I think a town player would be looking at multiple facets of the game, and his fixation on this one topic makes me think he could be fakeclaiming as scum and is trying to look like he's scumhunting effectively/actively.
If Boonskiies DOES have the role I think he's claiming, then proof of it should come soon enough. If it doesn't, then I will happily advocate for his lynch at a later date. Today is not the day for that though.
TL;DR: I'm scumreading him, but the cost of lynching PR-Boonskiies today does not outweigh the benefit of lynching scum-Boonskiies today, in my opinion.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
..... there's also that part where he, you know, hammered PeregrineV.
Here, let me recap for you: 2031 2332 2534
Sorry guys. I know it's pretty scummy, but he's claimed a PR so we can't vote for him. That would be scummy. (see #2 above)I have the comprehensive ability of a vegetable.-
-
Izariael Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 534
- Joined: July 27, 2014
- Location: Narnia
In post 2648, Izariael wrote:TL;DR: I'm scumreading him, but the cost of lynching PR-Boonskiies todayoutweighsthe benefit of lynching scum-Boonskiies today, in my opinion.
EBWOP. I ended up saying the opposite of what I meant. I won't be lynching Boonskiies today.I have the comprehensive ability of a vegetable.
Copyright © MafiaScum. All rights reserved.